• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hades Mafia - Game Thread

Magic you seem really defensive right now m8. Aside from Luka and you saying Craig is the hardest player for you to read, you've just double downed on defending Orca more than necessary for a day 1 kickoff.
This has little to do with Orca for me and more to do with reading poyser seeing as he's the one asking me the questions.
 
Why are you playing so stupid. Can't tell if you're being intentionally dense. It's being proactive relative to one's self, not a general thing.

This kind of read doesn't actually apply to players who are less self aware. For example you wouldn't slap this on T-Pein for doing *insert blatantly scummy thing here* because he genuinely dgaf
 
Can't say I feel too strongly about Retro but I do agree with Poyser's general observation that her posts have been fairly reactive observations and I haven't gotten any of her trademark psychobabble yet
 
This kind of read doesn't actually apply to players who are less self aware. For example you wouldn't slap this on T-Pein for doing *insert blatantly scummy thing here* because he genuinely dgaf
Do you think my meta of him is wrong?

Also same question to you about ratchet that I asked poyser
 
TOWN

Nibel
Luka
Tweetums
Ultra
Aurelian

could wagon any of
Retro
Ekko
Xadlin
magic

Haven't mentioned magic yet but just think he's largely been talking shite so far. Xadlin read sucks, he also just decided to read retro town based on how her posts progressed but didn't really say why or anything. i dont really see how her posts progress as townie tbh

vote magic

ill go for the spicy option
Xadlin and magic are good!
 
well my issue with him is he gave a future reason to justify a past vote and then doubled down on it

cant tell if serious or joking.. wagon kinda built too quick tho meaning..... its a scum wagon!!!
Can't really agree with this. Best buddy, tell me you ain't scum.
I didn’t really accuse her of panicking, I accused her of being over defensive
Well, I don't think a calm retro would go out of her way to over react is my point. But eh, we'll see.
 
Do you think my meta of him is wrong?

Also same question to you about ratchet that I asked poyser

What has Orca done in your opinion to put him in town pile based on "meta".

Look at his last game, he was doing shit besides whatever this is. If this is his town meta I'm assuming your standard for his scum game is doing absolutely nothing

I think the contrast between the game that just wrapped up with scum Luka is significant enough that there's nothing wrong with that read what with Luka blasting the thread with content
 
Ahh, you are doing your natural obstinate aggravation, so I'll explain to you in even simpler terms. Wouldn't it be far more of a limp wristed tactic for someone to push votes on an absent player?
Aurelian taking issue with my play after attacking his limp wristed comment about someone. Even though he had no issue last game and we both were town
What is your schizo thesis here exactly? That players who haven't posted yet are scum? I assure you Poyser isn't intentionally ducking. Last game, you voted Frinckles before he appeared technically, but he wasn't gone for that long. Beating on this drum at the moment comes off as forced.
Ultra jumping on board while being wrong id say. Page 17 voted voted Frinckles, page 27 first posted. Here page 8 voted Poyser, page 27ish first posted
I just told you he does this as scum, he does it all the time, he has a "strategy" revolving around voting someone with 0 posts. It's asinine, but he believes it, ergo there's no reason to assign him town points for doing it
Ultra trying to drag meta into this is amazing. He is 2/2 at trying to meta me, in being wrong because both times he was mafia and I was town. So have you seen me vote someone with 0 posts and push it when I am scum, id truly like to know?
How can he possibly have genuine confidence in pushing a player who hasn't posted yet?
Ratchet gets in on questioning the method and confidence again after seeing it be successful last game. Is scum catching themselves now lol
His push on someone with 0 posts vibes town??
Didn't you play last game here? You were scum right?
*furiously writes a SCATHING Orca role PM for members mafia*

you will regret this
I regret lots of things
I wanna give some town points to Aurelian for going to bat for Retro somewhat. Don't think someone would stick their neck out like that if scum tbh.
Interesting
Don't agree.

I called this out earlier too, pushing a wagon and going after a then inactive slot isn't reactive. It's suboptimal play assuming he is town. Already said you do more solving with active players then ones that are absent.
Why didn't you say anything last game when it worked?
Yeah but your spinning it as a positive for Orca and I don't see how???
Is he?

So far we have 4 players taking drastically different thought processes to my play this game vs last (in which it worked beautifully)

I have a problem with this because its a distinct shift in thinking usually is a tell in alignment shift. 3 of these were town last game I believe...so....

Aurelian
Ultra
Ratchet
Hans

@Poyser are you town, and if so, which one of these do you suspect more likely to be scum?

I can't see all 4 as town. 1 for sure is scum
 
Back
Top