Game Ranked I Think You Should Leave - A Mafia Game by Sky

[Chuck]

No and you just slipped up there.

Example: if Cubey (vig) shoots Hime (bus driver) but I target Cubey (self-redirector) then his kill shot is automatically redirected to me.

I am pretty confident you aren't Doctor and you aren't town.

Are you Indie or scum?

These sounds like 4 completely different posts, talking about something else.

1. i slipped? where? how?
2. you explain your role just like i did
3. what does me asking you for your usage has to do with me being doctor
4. how me asking "who wasn't performing faction kill at night" makes me scum? and even better, indie?

 

[Dr. Watson]

Tell me why WOULD i be faction kill? I'm scummy af, i'm on none of lynch wagons other than indie, only reason i wasn't lynched yet is my claim that could be easily contested with janitor on N1 (which is still kinda ridiculous to think i'd be so confident with my claim D1, hoping i'm going to kill and janitor good power role claim at random, but whatever).

Point being i'm great material for myslynch. Scum kills confirmed people. First Orca, then Ultra. People who have zero chances to end up lynched. I'd assume they'll kill Cubey, another confirmed town, next.



Actually, I posted in my PM I'd like to use Doctor on Cubey, in case I had 1 more shots for whatever reason (like, one of my actions didn't work and i got it back or whatever), but i got confirmation I'm indeed out of shots.

I mean, I'd have protected Cubey anyway .-.

It feels almost like you're leaning in on my normalized perspective over my mislynch and LHF theories but I digress

True, you're great mislynch material but from a scum POV, you're still an obstruction - I understand then gunning for Ultra since they were placed in a position where their thread position was going to be compromised
But I don't entirely buy that you, a doctor, are still alive this far into the game

Maybe they're playing at a different angle here, but you haven't necessarily been a major factor in getting wagons to gain some steam on you either; you've mostly been background noise, not too obstructive compared to other people, and not really part of the equation up until now
There's no sensibility in your claims is what gets me
The 2x theory you had is believable, but if that's the case, Cubert kind of fucks that theory up - I think it's safer to build the assumption powerful roles or abilities are kind of mixed with 1 shots that might be too disadvanteous to Mafia if Mafia are more likely to have 3 shots with an additional 1 shot
I don't know if numbers would be a way to counteract that or no

Yes, at this stage of the game you're unlikely to be faction killed now
Earlier? No
See: Nibel (town in this scenario and theory)

 

[Dr. Watson]

Watson voted for penguini but then avoided lethal, tweet and frinckles

A new challenger appears!

Not bothering with a voucher but I do this as either alignment, I'm flattered you took notice of it

This game, I mainly used it as bait

But you're correct that it indeed comes across scummy and avoidant rather than being proactive

 

[Dr. Watson]

I was wondering when someone was going to point it out

 

[Ultra]

Time for THE BEAR to hibernate. Thanks for the game.

 

[Chuck]

i mean, like i said, if you all think we're in good enough position to just mislynch me and solve the game from there easier this way, i'm good, really

 

[Chairman Nibel]

how many scum games have u played for this to be an impossible scenario?

One.

 

[hime]

Aurelian hasn't voted for a lynch or duel (that is 4 deaths he has avoided, 1 indie and 3 scum)

Gad voted for the indie and hopped on the Orca side of the duel late but avoided lethal and tweet

Chuck just like Aurelian hasn't been on any lynch or duel line

Nibel has been on all lynch lines...bussing to the max or town through and through

Watson voted for penguini but then avoided lethal, tweet and frinckles

Xaldin/ratchet has been on most of the scum lines, looks good to me

From play and voting patterns and even claims

Here is the game solve imo , final scum are in this 4

Aurelian
Chuck
Gad
Watson

aurelian, charlie, and watson r all town
call it gut, instinct, whatever
they r town

gad is kinda eh and trending down in poe but i feel hes more likely to be town than not

 

[Dr. Watson]

Anyone else give action claims if you haven't

 

[hime]

i mean, like i said, if you all think we're in good enough position to just mislynch me and solve the game from there easier this way, i'm good, really

no, lets lynch scum today

 

[Polar Bear]

A new challenger appears!

Not bothering with a voucher but I do this as either alignment, I'm flattered you took notice of it

This game, I mainly used it as bait

But you're correct that it indeed comes across scummy and avoidant rather than being proactive

I still have you as null so that why I noticed lol. I have much stronger opinions on the other 3

 

[Aurelian]

These sounds like 4 completely different posts, talking about something else.

1. i slipped? where? how?
2. you explain your role just like i did
3. what does me asking you for your usage has to do with me being doctor
4. how me asking "who wasn't performing faction kill at night" makes me scum? and even better, indie?

1. Why did you bring up Nibel specifically to me
2. You misunderstood my role and how it works given you wanted clarity on it from me
3. Strawman: I asked you why you haven't used your role to protect anyone all game if you are Doctor; you know the cop (Ultra) and vig (Cubey), why didn't you protect them last night?
4. I asked you because you are lying about your claim and are terrified of being outed if we have a Tracker or Watcher

Your actions don't make sense. For all I know Craig was the real Doc and you stole his claim if your scum. But besides that by your own WORDS you haven't attempted to protect anyone yet somehow are still alive in day 4. No scum team can be this inept.

 

[Chuck]

btw, i've played one game as scum here with Hans but i died right away i subbed in and he wasn't really that active when i was alive

Can y'all tell me how does he act as scum? Does he bus his teammates or does he avoid that?

 

[Aurelian]

Anyone else give action claims if you haven't

Wait for Flower first, I need something from her.

 

[Chuck]

1. Why did you bring up Nibel specifically to me

just example from poe

2. You misunderstood my role and how it works given you wanted clarity on it from me

i thought i understood (i did), then i started question it seeing your responses, then you explained it again and turns out i as right at first

3. Strawman: I asked you why you haven't used your role to protect anyone all game if you are Doctor; you know the cop (Ultra) and vig (Cubey), why didn't you protect them last night?

BECAUSE I ONLY HAVE 2 SHOTS OF DOCTOR AND IT'S NIGHT 3

4. I asked you because you are lying about your claim and are terrified of being outed if we have a Tracker or Watcher

EVERYONE CLAIMED AND THERE'S NO TRACKER OR WATCHER

 

[Aurelian]

Chop chop Chuck

 

[Chuck]

i mean, i feel like i'm on crack rn

can someone else read what fang is saying and tell me whether i'm the only one not understanding what's his point?

 

[Aurelian]

just example from poe

i thought i understood (i did), then i started question it seeing your responses, then you explained it again and turns out i as right at first

BECAUSE I ONLY HAVE 2 SHOTS OF DOCTOR AND IT'S NIGHT 3

EVERYONE CLAIMED AND THERE'S NO TRACKER OR WATCHER

>know who cop and vig are by day 3
>doesn't protect either

Nah you need to go

 

[Polar Bear]

aurelian, charlie, and watson r all town
call it gut, instinct, whatever
they r town

gad is kinda eh and trending down in poe but i feel hes more likely to be town than not

Id agree with Watson for the most part.

Charlie i was high on but he slid down just a little to below gad and aurelian

I personally would not vote any of these unless aurelian flips town, he won't (if he did, flower and hime become suspect imo)

Cubey
RDK
hime
Flower

 

[Flower]

Wait for Flower first, I need something from her.

What do you need? My claim and night targets are all in the thread.

Magic - doesn't have a night action to use
Alco - same as above
Nibel - has a night action to use