Game Ranked Medieval Fantasy Mafia - Game Thread

[Magic]

if i die and melkor flips scum pls look into gram and some others that opted for bpd/cal but never melkor on day 1 and ultra on day 2 over melkor.

 

[Lord Melkor]

i genuinely dont think ratchet is scum here or at least it's very hard to see.

when i pressured him last phase he went all in are defending himself and then OMGUSing me back. he could easily do the same to aurelian and psychic to dirty them but isn't. like i understand he'd switch up his playstyle, but as scum im sure he would at least go out of his way to dirty them a bit or at least put greater effort in shutting them down.

He has been pushing Aurelian a bit though.

 

[Lord Melkor]

if i die and melkor flips scum pls look into gram and some others that opted for bpd/cal but never melkor on day 1 and ultra on day 2 over melkor.

And what when i flip town?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Though i think @Magic looks the best among the trio of my main pushers.q

 

[Magic]

And what when i flip town?

then I'll look into the wagon and those who didn't vote you without much reason except for it looking like to avoid being on the wagon.

Don't think there's a high chance of you flipping town at all tho

 

[Magic]

Though i think @Magic looks the best among the trio of my main pushers.q

Why?

 

[Ultra]

And what when i flip town?

Assuming you're town here - what are your current thoughts on the game state given the current wagon split?

 

[Ratchet]

He has been pushing Aurelian a bit though.

I was supecting him before he was suspecting me.

To be honest I still have a feeling you're going to flip town but my best angle has been shut down and it turned out to be a massive detriment so it's best for me to step back here.

 

[Lord Melkor]

why are you so certain mango is town?

Main point in Mango's favour is actually his mason claim with Vinegar, correct?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Also from what I've seen I think T-Pein is probably scum, because of this post:



Where he seems like he's TMI'ing me as town, which he really can't help himself from doing as scum. Would recommend getting him the fuck out of here.

Or don't - just get your votes off me, thank you.

Indeed, T-Pein may be not the easiest to read but he has not done anything townie this game so far from my perspective.

 

[Magic]

Main point in Mango's favour is actually his mason claim with Vinegar, correct?

There is nothing really in his favour as they aren't confirmed Masons. Some of his early posts looked good, but nothing that should give such a confident town read. I think vinegar looks better out of the pair due to the reaction to the claim.

 

[Lord Melkor]

That's a fuckin nope

You don't force me to claim here and then go "lol sorry sucks for you", out with it

Especially that his result on you was NAI if he has just seen you visiting someone. But it lools more like bad town play that scum play for me from @ConquistadoR

 

[Ultra]

Sure but I stand by the process I asked for. Unfortunately I have to account for insanity apparently.

He has completely evaporated as well, the fuck

 

[Lord Melkor]

There is nothing really in his favour as they aren't confirmed Masons. Some of his early posts looked good, but nothing that should give such a confident town read. I think vinegar looks better out of the pair due to the reaction to the claim.

Point in his favour as in it would be a very bold play for 2 scum to play masons together, correct?

 

[Ultra]

Especially that his result on you was NAI if he has just seen you visiting someone. But it lools more like bad town play that scum play for me from @ConquistadoR

I do not like you giving a preemptive excuse for this, of course he could have made a mistake but he has an obligation to explain himself here

 

[Lord Melkor]

Def Town:
- Ultra
- Grammaton
- Tweet
Likely Town:
- Poyser
- Magic
- Psychic (?)
- Alco
- Whicker
Null:
- Lord Melkor
- BalsamicVinegar
- MangoSenpai
- ConquistadoR (unless he claims)
Scum:
- T-Pein
- Ratchet
- BPD

I'm comfortable with this list

Why do you have Tweet and Gram as "definately town)"?

 

[Lord Melkor]

How is this a point in his favor? The coincidence town doctor gets killed and flipped with almost the exact same abilities he's claiming to be town as healer and she dies night 1 while he skates on to day 2? You aren't making sense at all Melkor. Not only does BPD never address this to me, he repeats or avoids it with others who question his claim.

Healer doesn't necessarily mean town anyway, its NAI. It could very well be his role and he's scum.

So your point here is that BPD has similar role to Hime as scum? This is actually possible yes.

I just do think it is very unlikely he knew Hime's role.

 

[Ultra]

Why do you have Tweet and Gram as "definately town)"?

?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Why?

You are putting a lot of effort and i get your thinking process.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Assuming you're town here - what are your current thoughts on the game state given the current wagon split?

I think Whisker, Poyser are town. You are propably town based on cop claim. Conq is either town or scum tracker, leaning more on town.

I did not like Vinegar's threadplay yesterday, seemed like busywork, but has a mason claim from Mango as a point in his favour.

I am also leaning town on Aurelian and propably on Magic. Slight town lean on Gram.

After my town flip i would look at Ratchet, Psyche, BPD, t-Pein, Alco mostly.