• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Medieval Fantasy Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
still sticking to my reads. and as of yet - nothing has been done to convince me the pair aren't both scum.

and by Mango's flip - im virtually confirmed town. so
You aren't confirmed by Mango's flip even by mechanics. Let me walk that back for you:
Sworn Brother (passive) - You may communicate with another member of your order via means provided by the host.
You win when all threats to the Expedition have been eliminated.
The neighboring/chat ability is something he can do with members of his order, it doesn't say the Expedition IS the order technically.
 
I just checked and your last post before today was at the start of day 2. Are you telling me nothing that has happened since has changed your reads at all?
 
the fact he didn't really tell me his plan to out me and him as mason - i thought he might be up to some sort of nonsense. but really it was just a strange play. but yeah - if people want to push that i'm not his mason partner, despite not being the one that outed us. then i don't know.
 
the fact he didn't really tell me his plan to out me and him as mason - i thought he might be up to some sort of nonsense. but really it was just a strange play. but yeah - if people want to push that i'm not his mason partner, despite not being the one that outed us. then i don't know.
Nobody is disputing that you’re his mason partner - but it’s not uncommon for mason partners to be different alignments

I don’t really understand where your confusion comes from. Your own role pm confirms you are masons with him, so if you think mason = town then why would you have been suspicious of him?
 
the fact he didn't really tell me his plan to out me and him as mason - i thought he might be up to some sort of nonsense. but really it was just a strange play. but yeah - if people want to push that i'm not his mason partner, despite not being the one that outed us. then i don't know.

That's not the accusation

It's that you're using his flip as a self clear when by your own admission your role doesn't specify alignment. That doesn't make sense, if Mango's role as stated clears you, your role as stated should have cleared him prior.
 
the fact he didn't really tell me his plan to out me and him as mason - i thought he might be up to some sort of nonsense. but really it was just a strange play. but yeah - if people want to push that i'm not his mason partner, despite not being the one that outed us. then i don't know.
Okay but even if this is accepted and brushed aside as mindless speculation, why are you sussing the cop who hasn't been counter-claimed either the day he was outted by Conq (day 2) or today in day 3 with now 7 dead townies and none flipping cop?

RDK: Vanilla
Flower: Tracker
Hime: Doctor
LM: Double-Voter
T-Pein: Inventor
Ratchet: Hider
Mango: Mason

Why have you tunneled on Ultra every day?
 
i was sus of him - because he didn't communicate with me - bar on message. and just outed himself and me, without any plan in place. was strange thats all. but then again, not played with him before knowingly
 
Can you elaborate on all 3 of these slots?

Some of arguments BPD had against me yesterday seemed to be nitpicky (like that I did not say every suspicious stuff about him at the same time). He seemed more focused on defending himself than game solving and looks worse in retrospect today. Also his claim looks sketchy, especially considering mechanical info we have now. His scumreading Alco also looks worse since I now know Alco is town.

Psychic I had mixed feelings about most of the game - her stubborn approach I could see as town, but she was hesistant to vote me at first day 1, as pointed by some and yet seemed to be focused on me at the expense of other stuff. She also said "sorry if you are town", while in other posts she was really confident I was scum - could be inconsistency caused by TMI?

Magic I am not sure about - some of his posts seemed like genuine game solving, so he propably looks the best of these 3. Would need to reread his posts when I have time.
 
Okay but even if this is accepted and brushed aside as mindless speculation, why are you sussing the cop who hasn't been counter-claimed either the day he was outted by Conq (day 2) or today in day 3 with now 7 dead townies and none flipping cop?

RDK: Vanilla
Flower: Tracker
Hime: Doctor
LM: Double-Voter
T-Pein: Inventor
Ratchet: Hider
Mango: Mason

Why have you tunneled on Ultra every day?
yourself, Psychic and Ultra have been my three biggest scum reads. tunneling would just be one person. nice try though
 
yourself, Psychic and Ultra have been my three biggest scum reads. tunneling would just be one person. nice try though
You aren't making sense because when I was fully trying to push Psychic for being out-of-character through day 1 and casing her lynch, you think that was the evidence I'm scummates with her?

:whathekong
 
Excellent

duel Melkor @CraigPelton

Also

vote conq

Think he’s probably scum. The way he played around his info with ultra yesterday was shady as fuck and I don’t really buy it as town that was just dumb as fuck, I think he just wanted a way to set up his claim and prove he has his role, and maybe get ultra’s claim if they didn’t already have it. Also, with flower flipping tracker, ratchet flipping hider and ultra being cop, if he’s a watcher or similar then that’s a shit tonne of investigation roles

What the fuck you are doing dueling me over Lethal, BPD or even Conq? I have been actually town reading you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top