Game Ranked Medieval Fantasy Mafia - Game Thread

[Arne Slot]

unvote

i might go back to melkor but i want to review his posts first. im on post 720 and so far this aligns more with what id expect from town lethal than scum lethal, which is largely him punching down on people he thinks he's above and being antagonistic opposed to looking to appease. dont think he'd come in acting like an ass when he already had a big wagon on him. although ill be interested in his claim since he brought up it not being good for him to claim yet.

Flower
Hime
Whicker
Aurelian

Psychic
Melkor
Gram
Lethal

Null-ish

Ratchet
Ultra

Scummy

BPD
RDK
Tpein

This is probably about where I’m at currently. I don’t like really anything that ratchet has been doing but from conversing I do at the very least get a sense that he believes what he is saying which is a good sign.

With haza I think he’s mostly stuck to real easy stuff so far. His only town reads are fang and flower. Flower is consensus and fang is not somebody he can ignore due to their history so he’d pretty much have to give him a read. The only person he is pushing is lethal, and he seemed to work backwards to where he voted lethal alongside the other guys, and then began sussing lethal independently afterwards. Didn’t seem natural

Touched on Tpein and BPD already but I think I wanna lynch BPD. He’s just night and day compared to what I’m used to seeing from him as town. I get that he might have tempered his energy recently but even so I’d expect him to be scum hunting and pressing people, he’s almost solely focused on defence and how he looks, and whilst he is voting melkor and calling him scum, he hasn’t made any effort to explain why, convince others or either typically harass him which in my experience he ALWAYS does when he has a strong scum read. Like he’s saying he’s almost 100 on Melkor being scum but I couldn’t tell you why and he barely seems interested in interacting with him.

Play wise, I’d say he matches what I saw from him in wrestling wars far greater than he matches any game I’ve ever seen him play as town.

vote BPD

vote ultra

LET'S GO

VOTE LYNCH ULTRA

[Vote Lynch Psychic]

Aurelian and Psychic im not sure about.
VOTE: ULTRA

Ok, you're gonna keep focusing on this shite instead

vote ratchet

you're way too good for this as town. probably the worst wagon i've ever seen in my life

Did you provide a reads list yet?

Noted for trying to pocket Whicker.

So what do you make of Whicker townreading LM who is your scumread?

One of these two are mafia.

Prob Vinegar since he started posting after CP said so, and scum chat prob yelling at him to post more.

I'm psychic.

In what dimension do you live in?

Weren't you sussing someone else before me?

Are you even gamesolving? So you think I'm scummy for gamesolving but you're not going to even use your brain to think at all?
I'm happy to lose you today.

Change vote lynch Vingegar

anyway

vote bpd

so you're willing to vote there too?

let's get it tweet

vote lord melkor

I think we should melkor today, it would give alot of info.


Change vote lynch LM

If he flips town. I'm sorry LM but you were scummy.

If he flips Mafia, we vig Whisker for defending him.

[Vote lynch RDK]

I'm not directly opposed to this, I am almost always wrong about LM though.

Vote Lynch LM

UNVOTE

VOTE: Psychic
nothing worse than lying on day1

Going to bed. Not a fan of BPD seemingly tapping out there to be honest and I can see where the proverbial lack of bite is coming from.

vote BPD

Vote Count

Lord Melkor (5) - BPD, Flower, Magic, Psychic, MangoSenpai
BPD (3) - Grammaton, Poyser, Alco
RDK (3) - Lord Melkor, Ultra
Lethal (2) - Ratchet, T-Pein
Psychic (2) - Aurelian, Balsamic Vinegar
Grammaton (1) - Whicker
Hans Tweetenberg (1) - hime
Ultra (1) - RDK

With 20 alive, 11 is required for a majority. You have ~16.5 hours remaining.

Let me know if I missed your vote. Reminder that only bolded votes will be counted.

 

[Ultra]

Who we lynching today?
same state as 10 hours ago?

I think we're lynching Melkor?

 

[Magic]

@Magic This was your post right after the fact, which comes across as very hedgy but it sounds like you were crediting him with something very easy to do. Doesn't seem appropriate treatment for a player like RDK. Satisfied keeping my vote there if this is the best you got

I have him as null. I'm not defending him. I voted you to see what he would do. There was no guarantee he votes you right after. The fact he did doesn't change the fact he may not have.

Voting you was easy. Didn't say it wasn't. That's why I wanted to see if he would vote there.

Similarly I asked tweet to vote melkor after I switched there and tweet had expressed suspicion. Tweet didn't vote there and said he wants to fully catch up then disappeared, meaning it's unlikely he does fully catch up. If melkor is scum thst looks worse on tweet.

 

[Arne Slot]

try using the threadmarks for this.

Ooh didn't know about this feature, neat! Thanks

 

[Whicker]

Vote lynch RDK

 

[Whicker]

Looks like a deadline of around noon for me. Very doubtful I’ll be up before then.
I’ll be around sparingly this evening and I’ll read everything closely again tonight before I go to sleep

Currently voting RDK as I still think Melkor and BPD are town.

 

[The X]

1. @RDK - null scum lean
2. @T-Pein™ - null prob scum
3. @Grammaton - town lean
4. @Ultra - town lean
5. @Aurelian - unfortunately prob town
6. @hime - null scum lean
7. @Lord Melkor - scum leam
8. @BalsamicVinegar - scum
9. @Ratchet - town lean
10. @Flower - town lean
11. @Psychic - TOWN LEADER
12. @Whicker - scum
13. @bebebebababa @Lethal - Poyser made a good point about Lethal will put him in null for now
14. @Magic - Thought was town until he spontaneously voted Ultra for no reason now null
15. @Hans Tweetenberg - null
16. @Black Pegged Dragon - lean town
17. @Poyser - lean town
18. @ConquistadoR - scum, I espected more from this slot
19. @Alco - null
20. @MangoSenpai - nul lean town for now

Can you talk to me about your Whicker read?

Also, what are your expectations for Conq?

 

[The X]

I think we should melkor today, it would give alot of info.


Change vote lynch LM

If he flips town. I'm sorry LM but you were scummy.

If he flips Mafia, we vig Whisker for defending him.

What info do you think we'll gain?

Who do we flip if Melkor is town?

 

[Psychic]

Can you talk to me about your Whicker read?

Also, what are your expectations for Conq?

He came in defending Melkor when the votes started stacking.
If Melkor flips scum, then I'm sure he's scum with him.

Conq seems like a competent player from what I've seen in previous games. I expect him to contribute as town this game.

 

[The X]

Also I feel like Psychic is kind of out of range but has been kicked around quite a bit, can someone suspecting her toss me some cliffnotes?

I'm going to give townie points for this post. I think that Ultra going out of his way to defend Psychic here, while also showing an open mind on her maybe being wolf, shows Ultra trying to show good faith and patience. Don't sense a wolf ready to pounce or push in any given way.

 

[Psychic]

What info do you think we'll gain?

Who do we flip if Melkor is town?

On his scum flip, we gain some info on his wagon. On his town flip, we look at those who voted him early.
Right now there's alot of people for and against his wagon.
This is all very telling.

 

[The X]

He came in defending Melkor when the votes started stacking.
If Melkor flips scum, then I'm sure he's scum with him.

Conq seems like a competent player from what I've seen in previous games. I expect him to contribute as town this game.

I'd have to look at Whicker's specific defense of Melkor. Maybe @Whicker can help clarify this? I was reading Whicker town for his entrance and reads, which show a thought process I could follow.

Conq is a very competent player, that's why I'd like to give him time to read a bit. If he's town, he'll show us, and he'll be a good sound board to bounce ideas off of. I do not expect him to lead or make hard pushes this game since he's kind of already on the backfoot being late into the game and this isn't a community he's used to. But I do expect him to be able to answer questions about the game and give his opinion on what goes down.

 

[The X]

On his scum flip, we gain some info on his wagon. On his town flip, we look at those who voted him early.
Right now there's alot of people for and against his wagon.
This is all very telling.

Are you waiting for the flip to do wagonomics or do you at least remember a handful of the names you're referring to here that we'd get information about?

 

[Aurelian]

Can we lynch T-Pein

 

[Psychic]

Are you waiting for the flip to do wagonomics or do you at least remember a handful of the names you're referring to here that we'd get information about?

I based my reads from actual votes, it's more telling.

 

[Whicker]

I'd have to look at Whicker's specific defense of Melkor. Maybe @Whicker can help clarify this? I was reading Whicker town for his entrance and reads, which show a thought process I could follow.

Conq is a very competent player, that's why I'd like to give him time to read a bit. If he's town, he'll show us, and he'll be a good sound board to bounce ideas off of. I do not expect him to lead or make hard pushes this game since he's kind of already on the backfoot being late into the game and this isn't a community he's used to. But I do expect him to be able to answer questions about the game and give his opinion on what goes down.

I just think Melkor’s town. I’m not defending him beyond that read.

I don’t get how Psychic can have me scum based on Melkor being scum, but he only has Melkor as lean scum on that list. Which I guess all I can remember Psychic doing recently is shout Melkor scum so that’s odd on its own

 

[Flower]

Sup guys.

I‘m back.

 

[The X]

Poyser makes this observation and Haza immediately decides to adjust his britches and take a swing at me, hard noted.

Does this give you any read on Poyser?

 

[The X]

I just think Melkor’s town. I’m not defending him beyond that read.

I don’t get how Psychic can have me scum based on Melkor being scum, but he only has Melkor as lean scum on that list. Which I guess all I can remember Psychic doing recently is shout Melkor scum so that’s odd on its own

Why do you think Melkor is town? I did feel he was wolf out the gate so I'm curious as to why our reads differ.

 

[The X]

Sup guys.

I‘m back.

Poyser super copped me and found out I am wolf and that one of my teammates has quoted my posts.