I think Sky played well, I had a sinking feeling I was going to get shot or killed Night 2 and went against my instincts because I was thinking of having Psychic bus driven to me and get rid of the cop. We did screw up not going after RDK and killing him since day 2 ended with us knowing who the Watcher, Cop, and Vig were which was a blunder on our end.
Then we used the strongarm kill on the One instead of Bachi/Big Man.
Sky still deserves a HM. She effectively kept herself outside of a main wagon the vast majority of the game until the final days, dissociated from me, Whicker, and other members of our team and was able to manufacture several mislynches with her pushes.