Game Ranked Negima Mafia

[Penguini]

I can deal with the result. But with multiple players being very open that it was the mechanism of the role that made them town read the role, I think its fair in saying that a Serial Killer who can Night Skip - is not a balanced roe.

 

[Ratchet]

I don't want Flower taking the flak for what was clearly a broken role that was an automatic clear, as evidenced by the fact you made it double bulletproof to protect it from scum. That's something that should be caught on game review.

But it was neither a broken role nor was it an automatic clear lmao. You guys insisting it is over and over again doesn't actually make it true.

As for taking me off approved hosts, feels more like some sort of grievance you have with me personally over anything based on reason. If one single contentious element (and it is contentious rather than being outright brolen, given plenty of players have also defended the idea behind it I think we can at the very least agree that it isn't "clear cut") is enough to disqualify me outright, then how come I'm held to that standard when you, who have included an almost carbon copy of the role except that you gave it to the Mafia instead of the Serial, are not?

Like I've discussed the thinking behind it, you can't argue that it just got missed when there is clearly motivation behind the inclusion. You're free to disagree with the result, of course you are, but advocating some sort of blacklisting (or removal of white listing, I suppose) just seems extreme to me.

 

[Penguini]

I should get an HM - for clearing CP and Orca, with one redirect - and not picking up on the fact that CP was clear because of it. Mong Bear achievement unlocked

 

[Emil]

I think it is fair to tell them IMO.

i actually agree with the way WS does it, i think they shudnt be notified, otherwise people cant lie about where the kill was shot at or if it was blocked or not etc..

say player A is bulletrpoof townie (unclaimed)
player B is mafia roleblocker
player C is a claimed vanilla town

if B killed A and it failed, he can fake claim blocking player C and frame the failed kill on him. its a viable strategy
if you notify A that he was shot, player B cannot do that frame anymore

 

[RDK]

I don't think I deserved a HM, was wrong on pretty much everything except Aurelian lol

I'm partial to common sense though and you at least had that

 

[Tempest]

Anyway, it is what it is. Congrats Bachi on an overpowered SK win, you join a club that includes myself.

Thanks for the game

 

[Magic]

Let's just take Ratchet off the approved hosts list and call it a day imo, don't want Flower getting any more backlash for a well run game

I would have approved that too and I'm pretty thorough with reviews. Yall gotta be less salty, it's rude.

 

[Psychic]

I personally don't want to get an HM in this game, also because I was super inactive.

But anyways, congrats Bachi on a win,

 

[Tempest]

I would have approved that too and I'm pretty thorough with reviews. Yall gotta be less salty, it's rude.

No you wouldn't have, enough contrarian gaslighting, nobody is impressed or buying it

 

[Magic]

I can deal with the result. But with multiple players being very open that it was the mechanism of the role that made them town read the role, I think its fair in saying that a Serial Killer who can Night Skip - is not a balanced roe.

Most of the people open about this were losing town players that seemingly can't look in the mirror and say they fucked up

 

[Grammaton]

I personally don't want to get an HM in this game, also because I was super inactive.

But anyways, congrats Bachi on a win,

I mean

 

[Lord Melkor]

I can deal with the result. But with multiple players being very open that it was the mechanism of the role that made them town read the role, I think its fair in saying that a Serial Killer who can Night Skip - is not a balanced roe.

Not standard role, but SK needs to have the most powerful role in the game.

 

[Grammaton]

Not standard role, but SK needs to have the most powerful role in the game.

They don’t, this is a misconception

 

[The Orca]

Not standard role, but SK needs to have the most powerful role in the game.

@Polar Bear

Lmao

 

[T-Pein™]

They don’t, this is a misconception

why do you have a barbieheimer profile pic?
you liked the movies?

 

[Grammaton]

why do you have a barbieheimer profile pic?
you liked the movies?

Some oblique commentary about the duality of man

 

[Penguini]

if anyone wants more casual Juice/Vinegar game - i can always take reps for my MGS game on WG ;)

 

[Magic]

No you wouldn't have, enough contrarian gaslighting, nobody is impressed or buying it

I'm not trying to be contrarian. I don't see that role as much of an issue as you. A lot of salt is from people not being good enough to solve it. Some, like psychic and and balsamic, just want to be able to role spec easier

Saying those roles should never be in games makes role clearing too easy which I find shit.

 

[Psychic]

I mean

I mean I literally found the godfather day 1 when you all were too blind to see it,

 

[Whicker]

Good game everyone. Thanks @Flower @Ratchet
I enjoyed it and have 0 complaints.