• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked You Will Eat The Bugs - A Mafia game brought to you by the World Economic Forum

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
RDK said:
agree with this and also think even after the burst of posts not much was contributed despite his activity

feel better about this than the lind vote
Click to expand...
Do you rly think that we have a burst of posts in this 20 pages thread? Well excuse me for not solving the game having 10 inactives.
 
Poyser said:
Why do you like it then lol? He’s not only scum reading melkot for the exact same reason you town read him, but he’s scum reading melkor for doing exactly what he said tweet should be doing
Click to expand...
No, though. I gave townie points to Melkor for doing exactly what I asked Tweet to do, but scum read him for the push he made on Bachi. Please read my post again.
 
Can you explain this more? What did Tweet pick up similar to you?
 
You weren’t just saying you didn’t have a read on them though. You went in a round about way saying “based on x’s list, I have y as null. Based on a’s list, I have b as null”. It made no sense lol. How are null reads based on somebody else having a read of them? It just reads like you’re chatting shite

I disagree with your point on Melkor because it’s so unnuanced. As a townie it’s actually very common for you to have an internal thought, only to see somebody voice the same suspicion which gives you more confidence in your own feeling and cause you to follow them on the vote. Even more common earlier in the game! Not only that, but tweet projected confidence based on using the same tell to catch you before. Following that doesn’t require Melkor to remember the games himself personally, because he’s following somebody else’s tell.

You didn’t give any thought to him coming from a townie pov and just went straight into trying to make him look bad for it. It looks defensive if I’m being charitable, and agenda driven if I’m not

What do you make of lind being so confident that you’re town so easily. He says he doesn’t know you so that must be quite surprising to you really?
 
Bachi said:
So what if he didn't read his role PM? Do you need a claim from him to judge him?
Click to expand...

I actually missed this but yes, of course you do. If he himself isn’t aware of what his agenda should theoretically be, how is anyone else supposed to read him? The whole construct of the game relies on people being aware of and playing to their win condition, then the other players work out what that win condition is.

Amazed you tried to defend him here tbh
 
It’s a bad take because it’s going for the lowest hanging fruit imaginable. I can’t really see a world where a scum player makes that post. If you’ve seen him do this before though then fair enough. Do you have a link to that game out of interest?

How did he counter tweets posts? Because his maths were wrong? Not really a counter is it kek
 
Lindltaylor said:
No, though. I gave townie points to Melkor for doing exactly what I asked Tweet to do, but scum read him for the push he made on Bachi. Please read my post again.
Click to expand...
Yes. You have tweet as scum because he should be doing this, this and this

Melkor is doing this apparently inherently townie thing, but he’s scum anyway because you don’t like his read

Make it make sense
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Menu
Log in
Register