• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Negima Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Oneiros said:
Gram, Psychic confirmed town

Sky town or GF

RDK vig or SK

Balsamic looks the towniest to me on play. Can't even fathom scum tunneling like that.

Tweet, Polar and Whicker I'm neutral on. Disagree that Tweet's play around Lethal was shady, but he hasn't really done anything that makes me think he's town either. Whicker's reads seem genuine, but might be worth a look if Retro flips town. Could have been trying to set up a mislynch by naming Aurelian/Retro as possible mates. Giving me an uncompromised vibe. Polar's votes have probably been the worst in the game, but he's attracted a lot of attention to himself since the start of the game which I don't really see as a scummy move. Don't know how he plays like, so it's really a moot point.

Big Man, Orca, Sigismund, Craig, Retro my main POE. Craig pushing Aurelian when he knew Lethal was going to be the lynch really doesn't do anything for me. Seems to have tried to steer clear of conflict thus far. Sigismund probably needs to be pushed soon because it's D3 and there's 0 to read from there. Big Man too but if you ISO Sig he hasn't given one (1) single thought on the game. I'm alright with pushing Orca first, hasn't commented on Aurelian at all from what I've seen and included Lethal into one of his scum lists but without really saying anything about. He's throwing shade at all inactives so that might be why, but that in itself is a bit yucky when it constitutes most of their reads. About Retro I don't like how she handled the Kurumi situation D1. Conceded Kurumi was acting out of spite but still voted for her. Seemed a bit on edge during the interaction with Aurelian, but Aurelian being scum eases my worries on that specific question. Then again, I still think it's not good strategy for scum Aurelian to engage in a conversation with a townie about his perceived meta of said townie, it's uncharted territory. So while I think Retro (if scum partner) handled the role play well, I struggle to understand Aurelian's motivation for it if not staging.

Also if there's a vig counterclaim somewhere now is probably the time.
Click to expand...
Suspected for being good, I'll take it. What would you like to know?
 
Oneiros said:
Craig pushing Aurelian when he knew Lethal was going to be the lynch really doesn't do anything for me.
Click to expand...
Really? Why would I try to shine the spotlight on a scummate nobody (except a minor comment from whicker in a long reads list) was talking about as anything but town during a phase when lethal was the guaranteed lynch? I'm already losing a teammate and I decide to throw a town-read teammate into the chum for ??? reasons? That does *nothing* for you?

Awful.
 
Oneiros said:
Lethal was getting lynched anyway and she knew it so don't think she was trying to derail.
Click to expand...
Just before she started stalling Gram mentioned a scenario from a previous game where a scum had been caught, town started voting other people to not waste a Day, and then a townie got executed while the caught scum lived to see another day. Are you dismissing that that might be what Vinegar was trying to make happen?
 
CraigPelton said:
Really? Why would I try to shine the spotlight on a scummate nobody (except a minor comment from whicker in a long reads list) was talking about as anything but town during a phase when lethal was the guaranteed lynch? I'm already losing a teammate and I decide to throw a town-read teammate into the chum for ??? reasons? That does *nothing* for you?

Awful.
Click to expand...
Interestingly, Craig is appearing more and more town since early in the game. Like these thoughts in general
 
I can see this being disinterested Town tweet but I'm going to have to insist on a claim. He's in a fairly constricted POE for this stage of the game and our best roles are outed. The upside greatly outweighs the risk in my view.
 
Oneiros said:
Lethal was getting lynched anyway and she knew it so don't think she was trying to derail.
Click to expand...
Yes I suspect that vote might have served another purpose which is to look good for having put a vote on another scummate that phase. But I won't pretend to have a handle on Retro in any way.
 
CraigPelton said:
Yes I suspect that vote might have served another purpose which is to look good for having put a vote on another scummate that phase. But I won't pretend to have a handle on Retro in any way.
Click to expand...
Nevermind I thought we were talking about Retro there, not Balsamic, I have Balsamic as definitely town
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top