• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Ranked Baki Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Grammaton

Grammaton

Consigliere
Moderator
Magic said:
xenos you explained, mind expanding on the other two.
Click to expand...

Retro is a vibe check, she reminds me of negima

Hayumi I can empathise with voting me, and I find their train of thought fairly straightforward to follow, which usually bodes well
 
Magic

Magic

Resplendent
Gadministraitor said:
I'm not. But I just want you to look at this from my pov for a min. I'm trying to read this, but I know nothing, and everything I read that I don't know confuses me further. You and Xenos took up a big chunk of what I've read, and it probably stood out more cause I can't exactly form a read on others as well when there's a lot of "That's how X played in Y game when he was mafia/town" even outside of your posts. And while you might have only talked about one game, I remember Xenos mentioned another during his argument with you and it just makes things hard to grasp and these games were mentioned frequently as well.

So tldr: Not interjecting, you left an impression, I am still fuzzy about it, and I'm curious, yet not confident enough to make a read out of it.
Click to expand...

Aurelian said:
Okay but I mean I'm gauging him from his reactions and behavior in response to my vote on him. And why I'm happy to keep my vote on him. That's the tl dr version of it.
Click to expand...
the overall point is that youre judging his behaviour using past meta(meta in regards to his fluffing being associated to his scum games) as well as his responses(like the one gad was responding to in the top post) being more aligned with his scum meta. from his pov he wouldn't know 1) whether youre being accurate/truthful in your description 2) if any of it is actually alignment indicative.

not trying to say youre perspective is wrong, but in terms of in game content he doesn't really read as much as scum with what he's given.
Gadministraitor said:
To add, I didn't really have a reason to come to you asking this question besides that you're on right now. And I can get behind your reasoning except I read him as more annoyed and salty than nervous. I could be wrong and that's just how he acts when he's nervous but hey. I'm asking for a reason.
Click to expand...
does anyone have any history with gad?

what site are you from gad?

i feel like this is explicitly townie but just want to be somewhat aware of your range.
 
Grammaton

Grammaton

Consigliere
Moderator
Magic said:
i honestly felt like i was doing the opposite. after the last game(and a few others) i feel like my initial observation reads were better than my reads established from direct interactions(as in, arguing back and forth not just asking questions) so i wasn't going so hard in any one direction and watching. the only thing i thought was silly to continue, which i still didn't intervene in, was the aurelian/xenos back and forth and that's because if those go too long it's just way too unproductive and i thought they were both town prior to them even arguing.
Click to expand...

If you’re wondering what made me think that, it was your opener on Nibel- reminded me of WF days where you used to bumrush players you didn’t know. That combined with positioning yourself as something of an arbiter - for example I think your read on Aurelian is generous at this stage but I do acknowledge that you make good town reads when town so, you know, not gonna leap to any conclusions
 
Magic

Magic

Resplendent
Grammaton said:
Retro is a vibe check, she reminds me of negima

Hayumi I can empathise with voting me, and I find their train of thought fairly straightforward to follow, which usually bodes well
Click to expand...
fair, as i said i liked hayumi's vote on you more than what it initially came off as, which was a bit weird looking in terms of them just dropping their suspicion off very little.

what do you think of sky and freckles? im not really a fan of sky's play live from what i've seen so far.
 
Grammaton

Grammaton

Consigliere
Moderator
Magic said:
fair, as i said i liked hayumi's vote on you more than what it initially came off as, which was a bit weird looking in terms of them just dropping their suspicion off very little.

what do you think of sky and freckles? im not really a fan of sky's play live from what i've seen so far.
Click to expand...

I don’t think it’s implausible sky is scum, but again, shes proactively antagonising… well basically everyone in some way, and I have to question the wisdom of doing that when it’s a reliable ticket to an early crave

I don’t really know what to make of frink
 
Magic

Magic

Resplendent
xenos5 said:
I’m not going to bother responding to him directly (though he still can’t seem to keep my name out of his mouth), as I agreed to give it a break.

But yeah, it’s exactly this.

I wanted him to back up his point with evidence, and he refused to at every turn because he knew it was BS.

Anyone can say secondhand “this guy is totally like he was in this other game where he was scum!”. Because almost no one is gonna bother going into the Mafia archive to find the game being referenced. But it takes real confidence to point to specific posts from that past game and try to demonstrate HOW they are similar.
Click to expand...

do you have reads of anyone that commented on your interaction?

thoughts on myself, craig, gramm, and hayumi?
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top