• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked You Will Eat The Bugs - A Mafia game brought to you by the World Economic Forum

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Flower said:
I'm honestly getting stronger scum vibes from you than Magic rn. You literally said I followed Nibel on Gad when I started the wagon, never moved my vote and consistently pushed for him all day. I think Magic is your most likely partner since he protected you a lot. Town Magic leaves no stone unturned, and I feel if he was Town he would have looked at you more at some point.
Click to expand...
Followed is probably a semantic argument here. The word I was aiming for is more akin to coinciding. Where your vote and Nibel's were on the same wagon and both were pushing the same player. Frankly, I'm not allied with Magic, so this is probably a PoV that's more certain to me than to others.

That's why I'm not able to figure out who Magic's mate here is.

Poyser said:
Magic is probably the best scum player on this site lol, he’s certainly capable. This is the main reason I’m unsure on him tho. Like idk why change his mind on D2 when he’d been pushing gad so hard. But with his role, going for him makes the most sense anyway

Idk why scum wouldn’t have killed him last night if he’s town. It doesn’t make any sense
Click to expand...
I see. Thanks. I mean to me, in that scenario Magic probably told Nibel to not budge on Gad while he tries to rally town's votes on Reloaded. Supposing he succeeds and Reloaded did get lynched, then Nibel would be top suspect next day for his reluctance to budge on Gad and vote Reloaded. He should have taken into account Flower's reluctance to budge on Gad and Fang's stubbornness as well. Along with Melkor then coming in and voting Gad too.

With this hypothetical scenario in mind, Magic's profile is basically a serial busser who puts his teammates in suspicious positions to make his more secure.
 
Lindltaylor said:
Followed is probably a semantic argument here. The word I was aiming for is more akin to coinciding. Where your vote and Nibel's were on the same wagon and both were pushing the same player. Frankly, I'm not allied with Magic, so this is probably a PoV that's more certain to me than to others.

That's why I'm not able to figure out who Magic's mate here is.


I see. Thanks. I mean to me, in that scenario Magic probably told Nibel to not budge on Gad while he tries to rally town's votes on Reloaded. Supposing he succeeds and Reloaded did get lynched, then Nibel would be top suspect next day for his reluctance to budge on Gad and vote Reloaded. He should have taken into account Flower's reluctance to budge on Gad and Fang's stubbornness as well. Along with Melkor then coming in and voting Gad too.

With this hypothetical scenario in mind, Magic's profile is basically a serial busser who puts his teammates in suspicious positions to make his more secure.
Click to expand...
Another thing to consider tho, is that magic would have gotten no credit for a Nibel lynch because that wagon was strong and he was actively defending Nibel to me, very strongly. Magic defended Nibel and pushed gad hard a lot at eod 1 and sod 2, so Nibel flipping would have been worst case scenario to him as scum at that stage and would have completely tanked his credibility. That’s a possible explanation for why he started the reloaded wagon. Nibel was in trouble anyway so if you’re gonna lose a teammate, you may as well make it one that’s gonna make others look good
 
Poyser said:
The fact that he was so sure the claim didn’t make sense probably counts against him tho overall, for the fact that he didn’t really push reloaded at all on D3, despite all those reasons still being there
Click to expand...
Poyser said:
And if magic is scum, getting reloaded to use his role on cp to get a town read and then dropping it himself once his main pusher has cooled down makes a lot of sense. As town idk why he’d stop caring about the claim not making sense
Click to expand...
Is Magic someone who compromises and rearranges his reads based on other players? Because on day 3 Tempest and I wanted Rugrat, you wanted me and Reloaded didn't quite come up by others at the start of that day I believe.
 
Lindltaylor said:
Is Magic someone who compromises and rearranges his reads based on other players? Because on day 3 Tempest and I wanted Rugrat, you wanted me and Reloaded didn't quite come up by others at the start of that day I believe.
Click to expand...
I’m not sure I’m following?
 
I have about 30 Mins left on my lunch break if any questions or concerns for me nows the time to ask
 
Yoho said:
I have about 30 Mins left on my lunch break if any questions or concerns for me nows the time to ask
Click to expand...
How do you feel about voting magic? You’re not gonna be around much and people want you on the wagon so if you could vote him that would be swell
 
Lindltaylor said:
Forget it. I'm just trying to gather Magic's profile as a player here and how he plays as town to how he plays as scum.
Click to expand...
He’s probably the hardest player to read I’ve ever played with to be honest

Well, at least the hardest to read in terms of being very good, rather than just being such a pile of shit that you can’t read them either way. Been plenty of those :heston
 
I'm not going to be around after about an hour. Should I just vote on the wagon if it isn't close to hammer yet?

I'll probably log on next only after about 12-13 hours.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top