Game Unranked All Fiction Favorites Mafia (GAME THREAD! GAME OVER!)

[Flower]

Overhyped.
Never right about anything

Dude, he caught scum the last two games. WTF even.

 

[T-Pein™]

Then why not talk to him?

Cuz he aint slick.
Waste of time

 

[Emil]

right, you get it

does it look like she’s doing that here?

And do you think this was a relatively straightforward observation to make?

agree psychic seems townie. i thought u were arguing otherwise initially. misunderstood ur posts to tea

I've got an idea for an interesting experiment I would like to get your approval for before going ahead with.

Given its favorites every role in this game is probably a power role to varying degrees so people saying how happy they are with the role they were given shouldn't be too revealing.

So I would like everyone to rate how happy they are with the role they received from a 1 to a 10 scale (or a 1 to 5 scale if that's too broad). If we have that as a baseline we can see how it gets contradicted later, and try to determine what's the reason for the contradictions

like the others said this wont work as scum can easily tailor their happiness response to match what they plan on fake claiming later anyway
So let's say someone gives a 7/10, and then later they claim and their role seems fairly weak. How do you reconcile that from the 7/10?

The problem here Xenos, is that you're asking for a subjective measure to provide an objective result, which doesn't really work. The risk of course is outing powerful roles, and lying about the power of one's role isn't something that only scum have incentive to do. Hence why it's not a great idea to implement.

expected ur first response to call it "fishy"

 

[MangoSenpai]

What?
No.
I said ultra loves arguing with gramma.
I aint ultra not interested

Yeah, but, how does that make any sense?

You're just saying Ultra loves to argue with Gramma, that has got nothing to do with you avoiding talking with Gramma.

I mean, you're just arguing with someone else rather than Gramma?

What is the difference?

 

[T-Pein™]

Yeah, but, how does that make any sense?

You're just saying Ultra loves to argue with Gramma, that has got nothing to do with you avoiding talking with Gramma.

I mean, you're just arguing with someone else rather than Gramma?

What is the difference?

Gramma never learns.

 

[Flower]

Why does Pein want me to get offed…not cool .

 

[Tempest]

Also, only gonna say this once

no matter how cool/exciting/powerful/shiny your role is, don’t claim it or any results until it’s actually relevant

Looks like we'll be modkilled if we claim before d3??

 

[Grammaton]

It’s whack as well cause generally ultra and I read each other well lol

 

[Emil]

page 6

town
mango
psychic
xenos

lean town
tpein
doddsy
retro
maybe gram

lean scum
ultra
ratchet
maybe oneiros

 

[MangoSenpai]

This is whack lmao, I think pein is a good contender for the block today at this pace lmao

 

[Tempest]

vote tpein

Vibing with gram so far, TPein feels nervous

 

[T-Pein™]

Why does Pein want me to get offed…not cool .

That's whst you get for being disrespectful to psychic and not awarding an mvp or at least an hm

 

[Ratchet]

So let's say someone gives a 7/10, and then later they claim and their role seems fairly weak. How do you reconcile that from the 7/10?

Why are you quoting my responses verbatim?

 

[Emil]

Can you point me to where I town read Psychic?

am i being uncharitable here to call ur focus this game being more gotcha driven than actual solving?

 

[T-Pein™]

Looks like we'll be modkilled if we claim before d3??

Dont think so.
Nothing happened to me and I claimed

 

[Ratchet]

am i being uncharitable here to call ur focus this game being more gotcha driven than actual solving?

Yes.

 

[MangoSenpai]

vote tpein

Vibing with gram so far, TPein feels nervous

I take it you've read the thread since you come in swinging on pein?

I believe you missed the part where there's a wagon on you lmao

 

[Flower]

page 6

town
mango
psychic
xenos

lean town
tpein
doddsy
retro
maybe gram

lean scum
ultra
ratchet
maybe oneiros

The audacity of leaving me out here .

 

[Tempest]

Competitors?

At least quote the song properly:

Kind friends and companions, come join me in rhyme
Come lift up your voices in chorus with mine
Come lift up your voices all grief to refrain
For we may or might never all meet here again

Here's a health to the company and one to my lass
Let us drink and be merry all out of one glass
Let us drink and be merry all grief to refrain
For we may or might never all meet here again...

The song should quote me properly!

 

[Tempest]

I take it you've read the thread since you come in swinging on pein?

I believe you missed the part where there's a wagon on you lmao

Nope just don't see anything worth addressing there!