Tempest
Leprous Monarch
kinda made it easy for her with my fuck up, which she called a fuck up apparently without thinking through that it would only be a fuck up if I was town, as scum it'd just be a calculated gambit to save a mate
- Thread starter Lord Melkor
- Start date
- Status
eh possibly
It's not like he wasn't paying lip service to xadlin being scum though, he just never actually acted on it, which is usually a bad sign
I don't think it's wrong to call it a "fuck up" presuming you as scum didn't read last phase or something though. Which is a generous assumption of how bad you'd have to be playing but I don't see why that implies you'd have to be town.
What I was more getting at here is that even after her initial reaction she decides resolving nibel is the way to go. Do you think that's her only recourse as scum?
Not mathematically consistent
Night 1: OLU doesn't shoot
Night 2: OLU doesn't shoot
Night 3: Gad doesn't shoot
This is what you're required to believe if you think there's an SK (that's killing people)
@Hans Tweetenberg Why didn't you answer this question?
Night 2: OLU doesn't shoot
Night 3: Gad doesn't shoot
This is what you're required to believe if you think there's an SK (that's killing people)
@Hans Tweetenberg Why didn't you answer this question?
There's room for some combination of crossfiring or intervention but the odds of that happening consistently are exceedingly low
Sk would probably be magic pussymoding or doesn't exist, logic doesn't dictate that all 3 vigilantes are asleep at the wheel or have attempts at kills fail and never say anything
Sk would probably be magic pussymoding or doesn't exist, logic doesn't dictate that all 3 vigilantes are asleep at the wheel or have attempts at kills fail and never say anything
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
err, sure? why not? she knows she's not getting me lynched and she needs other people to vote with her so she's not going to start pushing others
OLU is a very inconsistent player and probably doesn't say what he's actually thinking half of the time so I wouldn't bank on him not shooting Bachi either
The only thing missing here is that dead men don't speak - if there's a scum Bus Driver in play for example, Hime could have protected Bachi or whatever, etc.
The only thing missing here is that dead men don't speak - if there's a scum Bus Driver in play for example, Hime could have protected Bachi or whatever, etc.
Okay sorry guys something came up (Had a turbo)
Back
Back
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
nothing to do with math. OLU didn't kill polar.
Well because Nibel flipping town would be automatically condemning wouldn't it?
Does she need that flip to win? Do you not think she could just defer to another option?
I don't think that Tempest really "messed up" and I'm slightly confused why Hime is taking that angle. It's pretty blatent that they forgot; not sure why they would take this angle as a wolf or as a town.
Nope, it's retarded. People press buttons here, two consecutive players abstaining for 3 nights straight is a terrible assumption
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
nibel flipping town doesn't condemn her at all. she can say my fuck up made her theory plausible, which it does
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
idk what you're saying here. do you think I'm lying?
No, Tempest claims they didn't see the coordination here. The angle is obviously that he shouldn't have done that, and by CP's own admission if he had read that he would agree.
Fencesitting attempt denied.
Yes it does lol, from a practical standpoint. Challenging that knowing the person is gonna flip town is going to bring consequence
Again I ask, you don't think as scum she could just accept a single clear? Or is she walled into thunderdoming here?
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
by that same token if nibel's scum he could've protected bachi too. and given how hard I went at bachi going into n2, you'd think I'd protect him afterwards! I outright said he claimed magic's role and gave a detailed breakdown of why that was likely.
Can we please not kill Nibel today, they're generally way more active as a wolf I think
- Status