No, he doesn't have to. However, the claim was that the thrust would allow him to one-shot Gyutaro and somehow avoid the retaliation from Rotating Circular Slashes. I pointed out that you can't have your cake and eat it too, so either Cu thrusts and gets shredded or stays back. It's literally...
forums.spacebattles.com
Oh boy, it's this person... again.
No, he doesn't have to. However, the claim was that the thrust would allow him to one-shot Gyutaro and somehow avoid the retaliation from Rotating Circular Slashes. I pointed out that you can't have your cake and eat it too, so either Cu thrusts and gets shredded or stays back.
Because Gyutaro would be dead? Again Gae Bolg TNR if it hits your heart then skewers you from the inside as stated in it's Materials in H/A when it skewers Bazett, you was literally just shown that earlier. Gyutaro would be no different if Nasu states that Arcuied would be dead and she's far, far superior to him in terms of regeneration.
It's literally the entire reason why Tracing and Projection magic is effective against Servants despite their MR. Making things and then smacking someone with the thing is not stopped by MR.
And no, that's not how it works. Nasuverse having curses that are affected by MR ignores the fact that there are also curses that are not affected by MR. In this case, Blood Demon Arts are more similar to Noble Phantasms in that they're specific techniques and methods that are signatures of the demons that even have what's basically their own True Name Releases.
What? There are explicitly 2 known Noble Phantasms that are easily stopped by having decent enough MR already known(Maria The Ripper and Atalante Alter's own NP) and Archer explicitly doesn't go beyond MR more than other typical NPs. And that is the dumbest comparison I have seen in my life to allow that bullshit.
(Apologies for it being a reaction video.) The blood blades shred the buildings in the district into rubble and then fly hundreds of meters into the sky. Shirou and Saber manage to survive Caladbolg II's Broken Phantasm explosion just by jumping away into cover.
As for why they wouldn't be affected by the space warping, it's because they don't rely on their form to function. It's the difference between using space warping to destroy a rigid structure like a building by warping it out of shape, and attempting to "destroy" running water. Warping it doesn't stop it from being fluid water that continues to run even after it's warped.
1. Shredding a Building =/= Blowing it up, you need to go back to school.
2. They absolutely would be affected by spatial warping, that's the entire point of how ridiculous that is that even if Medea tried to teleport away, she would still get absolutely shredded by it. And even then, do you even have proof of such a thing?
I mean... we already explicitly know that demons don't require internal organs to function. If they haven't been beheaded by a Nichirin sword, they will not die from internal damage even if they can't directly regenerate around it. Hell, if we go by the actual feats of the thorns, Bazett was still able to talk after being heart-stabbed, so they're clearly not that big of a hindrance.
"Bazett can still talk meaning it's not a big deal to demons", literally ignored she was fucking dying and on her way to brain death and ignoring how Gae Bolg's Curse even works... again. And more Nichirin wank and fully ignoring how Cu can just put a Fire or a Sunlight Rune on his Gae Bolg just for added effect.
Too fast based on... what, exactly? In this case, his Rotating Circular Slashes were able to casually outpace Uzui.
Based on the fact that Cu is canonically the fastest in the HGW and considering how fast Medusa and Salter's battle was in HFIII even for SB standards, I would say that Cu COMPLETELY shits on them speed wise.
And there's really no evidence for that either. Again, Daki's neck is harder than demons that can survive taking hits from Tanjiro's tank round level swings without a single scratch. Even Lower Five's neck was so hard that Tanjiro's boulder cutting strike couldn't even break skin. Then Tanjiro gained the ability to cut his neck with Sun Breathing. Tanjiro then fails to cut Daki's neck with Sun Breathing even when he's literally killing himself to amp his physicals up. Meanwhile, Uzui can casually sever her neck so quickly that she doesn't even notice, and his bombs can sever her neck as well just from her striking one of them with a glancing blow.
Yeah and Tanjirou never matches that level of strength again... that would be explicitly an outlier so I find it hilarious that THIS is how it's primarily used despite he never even cracks the fucking ground, let alone does shit like that. And again, Heracles simply sapping away most of it's strength and the REMAINDER blew up the Cemetery so bad, the ground was basically looking like it was fucking MELTED in some cases. No one in KnY is even remotely matching THAT.
Rho Aias managed to block a severely blunted Excalibur. Quantify what fraction of Excalibur actually hit Rho Aias, because pulling 1/10th out of nothing is not evidence.
Someone didn't read actually watch HFIII... Shirou explicitly blocked most of that with Rho Aias rather than the VN having him block the rest after Belleophron took plenty of it(but even then, Rho Aias still blocked most of Excalibur regardless).
That doesn't say anything about Emiya being unable to react. It just says that he leaps back a great distance. Maybe Archer let him, considering his goal was to stay out of thrust range.
Why would EMIYA allow Cu to use his 2nd Noble Phantasm? That doesn't even make sense.
Okay, I'm not seeing anything about it being able to resist anti-army NPs, only that it can "even block a great Noble Phantasm."
What do you think that means? Like this is now officially cherrypicking unless you think Rule Breaker is a Great NP...
Why would we assume that weak Excalibur would only have 1/100th of its normal power when all it does is break the ground? Does it blow away a city block? Does it carve a trench a dozen meters deep into solid rock? Does it do anything that would be quantifiable?
Because Heracles literally would have tanked it otherwise? We have explicitly seen what happens if Heracles doesn't feel threatened by the attack:
He just let's God Hand null it. So the fact that even Artoria's weakened Excalibur from the Bad End required him to actually physically stop it meant it would have taken a life. This isn't rocket science. And yes, it's very, very clearly obvious it's a weakened to hell and back Excalibur considering she was on E and was all but about to fade away before Heracles killed her.