Oh, welcome!
No, I've noticed as scum you tend to say a lot without saying anything, and these specific posts are very much that, for example:
"To an extent I agree, since like I said he seems self aware and hasn’t given the type of response I would expect as a town throughout the interaction. A little more concern would be nice, but I also know nothing about them as a player or what’s typical of them. You’ve referenced a recent game with them as part of your argument but I can’t exactly share my thoughts on that aspect meta-wise. Since it’s early I’m giving him the benefit of the doubt very sparingly, but I can see the logical conclusion given his scumminess."
This is basically: I agree but I dunno in a lot more words.
Also, you know I love you, you're scary as scum