Never lynch:
CraigPelton
Black Pegged Dragon
Town reads:
Grammaton - If he happens to be scum he's probably the last we get to, also just very likely we lose in that case. Don't have much reason to sus outside of unfounded paranoia
Ekkologix - Seemed solvy throughout but his takes have reached WOAT territory with his constant sussing of CP in particular. Still think he's town tho, like I struggle to think of that continued CP tunnel as agenda
T-Pein™ - Also looked good d1, still think he's town though slightly higher chance of his role spec in particular to be agenda
Xadlin - I think the way he claimed and kept tapdancing around the exact wording of his result out of fear of a modkill looks like someone who has no team to help him out, also the fact that his usage on a scum read of his checks out as Gram pointed out. No play-based reason to read him town beyond that.
Lethal
So we got 4 scum in
Magic
Rej
Psychic
Natalija
Odd
For Nat, Odd and Rej I got no reason to read those slots any direction on play. Pure POE except maybe Rej because Sworder had a few posts d1.
Psychic is kind of an odd one, has made a few posts more than I'd expect her to make as scum but that's honestly a very low bar to clear. I couldn't tell you any of her takes either. I think that slot has been flying under the radar a lot more than it would as town so she's likely just scum.
Now that I say that, the being allowed to fly under the radar a lot also applies to Odd and to a lesser extent Rej so I think that's what I wanna apply as my primary metric here.
Going by that one, Nat in particular has had a few detractors too many to fit as scum, certainly compared to those other three. You could say the same for Magic though which gives me pause, he made a point of telling me that nobody reads him town and as slimy as I found that post it is kind of true.
I think my conclusion for now is that Psychic, Odd and Rej are all scum. In case those are right ima need more thought on the final one.
Please note that I already forgot about most of peoples' interactions with one another so idk how much sense these guys really make together as a team. Off the top of my head though, Odd went hard for Nat so that's probably never a pairing.
