@CraigPelton @Ekkologix For the record, I am not 100 on Fang being wolf here, but he's definitely a wolf read.
He's not confident or absolutely certain I'm scum but feels safe enough to say I'm a wolf read:
I don't have specific notes written down nor do I have a strong vibe he's town; it's an ultra light town read. Think it was his read of Melkor and maybe Tweet that I liked? He could be wolf for sure.
Repeats the same thoughts and process around Craig, not giving him a direct town read, essentially null one. He can't even
peg down the reason for his light town vibe for that matter.
Well I saw more than once people were like 'BPD is wolf reading Fang' and I felt those comments were most absolute than how I was feeling.
Also, you've never saw a townie say they felt 100 on someone begin wolf and death tunneled them? Of course you have.
Seems very flustered when Nat questions his motives for voting/wolf reading me as scum but wifoms about the semantics of his previous statement.
He doesn't have a better reason then this to push his vote on me?
Yes, I have a wolf lean on Fang, but I could see how he's playing coming from Town Fang, maybe. I do think there's a better chance he's putting on a show than not, though.
Seems again to be doing the whole fence-sitting thing, trying almost TOO HARD not to over commit in one direction or another with how the votes and reads are ebbing and flowing in the thread around himself and me. To my knowledge, normally as a townie, BPD is never this cautious or wish-washy about pushing his scum reads.
To scummy to be scum is a viable strategy to some.
Offers nothing, interestingly Raem was a player that Craig was reading as town.
I had a town read on Melkor and Psychic that I discussed, as well as minor town reads on Tweet and CP (but I'm more on the fence with CP than Tweet). Think Raem is been no bueno. I do think I'm fine with your slot with how you dealt with Fang. Evans might be fine as well? Unironically liked Tpein's entrance a whole lot more than I liked him last game, but he could be wanting not to be another easy lynch if he did roll wolf here. Magic I'm a bit curious about? I think he has definitely been proactive, but I'd have to look at his posts closer to see how he's framing and guiding things. Ekko I initially kind of got a not so great gut feeling about; that read is in development. Xad might be town? Nat is meh. Odd is Odd. Think that covers just about everyone?
Admits to Grammaton he's fine with him doing the arguing with me, doesn't really give any actual detailed reasons for his town reads on Tweet or Evans, then sort of backsteps himself about T-Pein from earlier. Doesn't give anything solid about Magic either: continuing his odd trend of being extremely wish-washy and noncommittal to giving big decisive reads. In the Eastenders game, BPD was aggressively tunneling and arguing with me and Poyser for arguing back against him calling both of us wolves, here he's just liberally dolling out 'soft' town reads or null ones.
Very lazy reads list/compilation.
Oh and Tsword and Lethal. I guess Tsword has been fine as well. Lethal's catchup hasn't moved me in one way or another. I'd probably say slight town on his slot, though, just because I don't sense any real fakeness from him at the moment.
Almost every player at this point is getting a "light" or "small" town read.
BPD is playing it too safe.
Way too safe.
This doesn't align with his normal town meta in past games I've seen.
I'm definitely lacking some wolf reads here but I think there's enough meh slots for me that will sour more. I feel decent about most of my town reads.
Worthless fluffing, no substance again here.
I mean, what reads do you feel like I just threw out there? I commented on every slot in the game. And you are changing my words now because you are saying I feel good when all I said was I feel decent about most of my town reads. I'm not 100 confident on all my town reads, but I do think that the wolves are probably going to be somewhere within the slots I have a wolf lean on or that or more null or in between. I do feel like I could be wrong about slots, but I also do feel decent about how I'm reading the game so far.
Again BPD gets defensive over Craig showing reluctance about his slot and moving away from his earlier town read on him. While Craig doesn't really go into super detail about it he essentially posits that BPD is acting/behaving in a way that doesn't jive with his normal town play like I've mentioned from past games. BPD even admits his reads are not "100%" accurate but still commits to them despite most of his reads and positions with said players being very weak positionally; little interactions, little to no engagement, or cautious outside of specifically myself and Grammaton.
This is a far cry from every game he's played a hyper-aggressive townie, confident in his reads, confident in his choices to vote or support.
My vote is still on Fang. I don't really like how you're trying to say people aren't balls to the walls against Fang so that must mean he's not wolf. Shouldn't you be happy town is willing to not go gung ho and be diligent about things?
Ironic.
Not sure why BPD is getting a pass for any of this but I will not vote for Craig over him.
