Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

[Aurelian]

His reaction to his own wagon is entirely nonchalant. He's not really going hard at defending or deterring people off the wagon and that would check out with the stump claim

Hard disagree. He posted like 6 posts back to back when I started on attacking and ISOing his waffling for most of the game.

 

[Magic]

Hard disagree. He posted like 6 posts back to back when I started on attacking and ISOing his waffling for most of the game.

Posting or defending one's self is not what I'm judging off of. He isn't actively trying to get votes off himself is he? Not from what I saw. No trying to get everyone back on you aggressively or anything.

 

[Arne Slot]

Psychic also had raem as scum and had no reaction to his modkill and moved on like it was nothing. Just an absent of a reaction.

Honestly likely want to lynch psychic at this point but want to see others weigh in. The content of her multi quotes were fine but the reads list is lacking compared to her recent town games. On top of thst I see heavy teammate equity with cp and I'm not feeling him either.

Nah we're not lynching Psychic you said yourself her play this game is nothing like her scum games

 

[Magic]

Nah we're not lynching Psychic you said yourself her play this game is nothing like her scum games

It also isn't like her town games. The read list she produced is also more similar to her scum games as it has two omgus in there but unlike her town games she isn't phrasing it in a way where she says scum is coming after me to lynch me.

 

[Aurelian]

Posting or defending one's self is not what I'm judging off of. He isn't actively trying to get votes off himself is he? Not from what I saw. No trying to get everyone back on you aggressively or anything.

Not sure how you came to this conclusion but I'm going to have to assume we'll agree to disagree:

Very odd behavior.

I have already expanded. Melkor and Psychic I actually gave decent posts about. Expanded on Lethal when Magic asked. Gram I've expanded on because of how he handled Fang. Already talked about my decent town reads.

Can you expand on what rang true?

How am I cooked??

Fang's reply to me is basically talking about how I've not interacted with players and how I haven't commented on Ekko. I've already explained how someone doesn't need to interact with a slot to get a read. I've already explained that Ekko hasn't asked me or directed anything my way that needs a response from me. Fang is struggling for content and wants to get into another twenty page argument with another player. I'm not interested.

Like I've responded to Fang, Craig, and Magic when they've asked, given pretty Thor ohhh response, but Craig just wants to say I'm cooked here. Got it.

Now you want to come back to Tpein, eh?

Here's a fun fact, I can GUARANTEE that I will be around until the end of this game.

This is like 1/5th of his total posts in the game coming off me going after him in a pretty fast flurry and like half of his total posts before going to bed once I had my iso big multi post on him. I'm just feeling that he's getting jilted from these quick reactions and way too defensive.

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Her read list is weak but on top of that the way she talked about aurelian needing to be resolved felt weird. If aurelian is town scum would suggest that his lynch needs to go through but it's way too early to be suggesting that. The rest of her reads don't even come across as real reads.

His reaction to his own wagon is entirely nonchalant. He's not really going hard at defending or deterring people off the wagon and that would check out with the stump claim

Hmm yeah not the worst point in the world re: resolving Fang though idk if that's necessarily scummy out of someone like her. I associate being plain completely inactive with her scum game more than anything tbh. On that account she's sort of in the middle of where I'd expect her to be on the town/scum scale sooo... indy?

 

[Magic]

Not sure how you came to this conclusion but I'm going to have to assume we'll agree to disagree:

















This is like 1/5th of his total posts in the game coming off me going after him in a pretty fast flurry and like half of his total posts before going to bed once I had my iso big multi post on him. I'm just feeling that he's getting jilted from these quick reactions and way too defensive.

These are all in response to just you. See past yourself. He isn't actively deterring people to move off his wagon or asking them directly.

 

[Arne Slot]

Hmm yeah not the worst point in the world re: resolving Fang though idk if that's necessarily scummy out of someone like her. I associate being plain completely inactive with her scum game more than anything tbh. On that account she's sort of in the middle of where I'd expect her to be on the town/scum scale sooo... indy?

nah I've caught her as indy she isn't any better at that than being mafia lol

 

[Magic]

Hmm yeah not the worst point in the world re: resolving Fang though idk if that's necessarily scummy out of someone like her. I associate being plain completely inactive with her scum game more than anything tbh. On that account she's sort of in the middle of where I'd expect her to be on the town/scum scale sooo... indy?

Nope. Her read list seemingly has an agenda to it. That's scum.

Indy she'd be indifferent to who is lynched or would pick the one going most after her.

 

[Arne Slot]

It also isn't like her town games. The read list she produced is also more similar to her scum games as it has two omgus in there but unlike her town games she isn't phrasing it in a way where she says scum is coming after me to lynch me.

looks the same to me

I don't think she's really been pressured enough to go into victim mode

 

[Aurelian]

These are all in response to just you. See past yourself. He isn't actively deterring people to move off his wagon or asking them directly.

They are in response to me but he's made a total of 30, read them, THIRTY POSTS, from that single ISO and my follow up on why he's my strongest scum read. The other important point being about his very weak, lackluster, and fluffed out "reads" list which he did verifiably get pinched on. Like I said I'm not gonna push you too hard on this so we'll agree to disagree here but my man BPD made more posts in reaction to my breaking down his overall lack of...investment with other players for interactions and went the extra mile in responding with matching his total prior posts with that chain.

 

[Aurelian]

Also thoughts on @Natalija?

 

[Arne Slot]

eh maybe we just lynch t-pein here

 

[Arne Slot]

seems like he's just in duck and cover mode while we push other people lol, hasn't done shit, wanted to lynch RAEM yesterday but didn't push it yet was adamantly against lynching Aurelian. I do think he's just scum again here

 

[Magic]

looks the same to me

I don't think she's really been pressured enough to go into victim mode

Calling me out for being odd is being dishonest when it is more likely that I'm going after her as a suspect. It's disingenuous.

 

[Arne Slot]

Calling me out for being odd is being dishonest when it is more likely that I'm going after her as a suspect. It's disingenuous.

She was sus on you early on in MHW mafia too

 

[Arne Slot]

The first 2 pages is a bit tryharding imho.

Can the man post first before you decide this?

Suprised that LM's early reads are similar to mine. Slight town lean on Sworder and slight scum lean on Magic as well.

I have no idea what you mean by this. Can you elaborate?

Slight town lean on : Sworder, Ekko, LM
Slight scum read on : Raem, Magic

Magic hadn't even mentioned Psychic by this point in the game.

Hi. Why do you think I am scum? Can you elaborate?

I've posted quite a bit, I think you probably missed them. You putting CP in your town read just because you don't wolf read them is a bit off to me. If anything, he should be in your null pile.

I actually think Psychic makes a good point here about Lethal. He's town leaning me out of hope? Since when is that a thing? He's usually careful around town reading my slot as most people are

I'm not seeing OMGUS here at all

 

[Arne Slot]

Also I'm having a hard time seeing Aurelian as scum anymore tbh

BPD I'm kind of wavering on. Would rather just yeet T-Pein at this point

unvote
vote T-Pein

 

[Magic]

Magic hadn't even mentioned Psychic by this point in the game.


I actually think Psychic makes a good point here about Lethal. He's town leaning me out of hope? Since when is that a thing? He's usually careful around town reading my slot as most people are

I'm not seeing OMGUS here at all

Your persistence in defending her and town reading her seems over the top relative to how far you tend to go for other town reads of yours. Why is psychic so special?

 

[Aurelian]

Just going back over some other posts from BPD but this caught my eye:

@T-Pein™ @Psychic @Aurelian @Hans Tweetenberg @Black Pegged Dragon vote cp pls

Why did BPD like this post

Why would someone who was so happy to have Grammaton and others hyper focused on having me lynched immediately like a post from Ekko again suggesting Craig as a viable alternative lynch/wagon?

There is precious little to nothing from BPD prior to my offensive against him that paints him being suspicious or overtly distrustful that he would point himself into agreeing with a lynch on Craig, so why like this post from Ekko trying to go against my wagon to push Craig?