• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Fang's reply to me is basically talking about how I've not interacted with players and how I haven't commented on Ekko. I've already explained how someone doesn't need to interact with a slot to get a read. I've already explained that Ekko hasn't asked me or directed anything my way that needs a response from me. Fang is struggling for content and wants to get into another twenty page argument with another player. I'm not interested.
 
Like I've responded to Fang, Craig, and Magic when they've asked, given pretty Thor ohhh response, but Craig just wants to say I'm cooked here. Got it.
 
Magic seems off this game but I would need to see more from him before I write him off as scum, I don't really like Odd's entrance. I don't mind going in that direction over Aurelian. Although I don't want to see Aurelian vs Gram next dayphase either. I feel it's better to resolve his slot now.

magic - scum lean/feels off
Odd - scum lean
Aurelian - needs to be resolved
Nat - says alot but nothing substantial
Lethal - something about him feels off
What would you get from an aurelian lynch may I ask?

Nat also has said very little and lethal looks like omgus.

Your multi quote posts look better than this read list. Two are omgus(myself and lethal), two are bottom posters(odd and nat) and the other is just you saying aurelian needs to be resolved.


@Grammaton can you humor and look into a world where aurelian is town and bpd is town and tell me if those two scenarios are true who do you have as scum?
 
Psychic also had raem as scum and had no reaction to his modkill and moved on like it was nothing. Just an absent of a reaction.

Honestly likely want to lynch psychic at this point but want to see others weigh in. The content of her multi quotes were fine but the reads list is lacking compared to her recent town games. On top of thst I see heavy teammate equity with cp and I'm not feeling him either.
 
The fact you admit you aren't confident fully that I am scum but still wolf read me but not a single other player is pretty much damning testimony that I can't resolve you as being aligned as town when you've displayed so many counters to your normal town meta play.
Ye when he says that what I read is, I'm fine parking my vote there and yes I definitely read him scum except if he isn't I told you I might be wrong so don't look at me
 
Ekko the Kekko time:

page 5/7 (stopped at post 150)

town
gram - strongest town read. thoughts on aurelian and sworder matched mine as im catching up
melkor - attempts to solve magic and gram early seems townie melkor. scum melkor would drop a line that says "they are giving me power wolf vibes" and call it a day

lean town
magic
sworder

town side of null
evans - if hes scum im gna need tpein to bury him here

null
BLD - can see as potential town but what hes discussing with gram RE: sworder seems pointless
CP - telling evans to stop talking about tpein is easy topic. need something else
aurelian
RAEM
psychic
Ekko opens up with his first meaty post after fluffing it up early to give some decent reads on Grammaton, Melkor, Magic, Sworder, and Evans.
Pay attention to Craig here though in regards to Ekko.
i think fang is town. id love to know ur thoughts on the other players / who is next in PoE for u, and thoughts on my read list above when u get time


i agree with the read, but not the reason. melkor asks lots of questions as scum too. how come is this town indicative for you?


can u explain this pls


no not about tpein, but rather about u. what was the point of that question to evans? what did u hope to gain from it? whats ur current read of him?

also do u still think gram is lying? i saw ur recent posts and seem that now u reversed ur initial argument and now think that gram's sus on you came before BPD's posts / was premade. this would tell u that gram's posts are original atleast so could u accept a world where gram is town and move on from him to the next sus player? i expect gram to move from u as well
So Ekko here moves from seeing me as null to town while responding and replying to Grammaton.

He also asks Grammaton where else he wants to go and who he wants to read besides me, supporting his normal town behavior. But then he also questions Tweet about town reading Melkor, another important player when it comes to reads from Ekko but we'll get back to that later.

Obviously the tail end of this post is him asking me about Grammaton and specifically me questioning Evans about T-Pein.
where do u draw the line / how do u determine whether fang is "trying to fake or play like his town game" versus "fang is simply town playing his town game".. like how did u arrive to him faking it rather than simply being it


dont like this either. melkor asks lots of questions as scum. the number of questions is not how u read him, but rather the content of those questions. is this what u r referring to? how caught up r u with the game?
Much like Craig later on in the game, Ekko is pressing BPD to give evidence or explain his reasoning for claiming I was faking being town vs my normal play style as town.

Again in the second half of this post it was directed to Tweet and directly says he's suspicious of the town read on Melkor.
cant really say im the strongest melkor leader

i think his reads come off more into one-liners as scum and he will generally project over excitement. he will also be more mechanically/flavor focused over gameplay. he also doesnt take big risks and tries to avoid having to wifom out of problems later. reason why i still think he could be townie here is i think scum melkor wud say he is getting power wolf vibes from u but not try to go more into it, atleast not this early.

here r 2 recent scum games of his if u wanna take a look:


His follow up going into more detail and producing evidence and receipts about Melkor's scum play and habits in past games. I don't want to say this seems premeditated but it also will reek of tying myself into it to Ekko, but Ekko, HAS claimed he is able to read both me and Melkor strongly when we play as any slot to figure us out.

Ekko is very confident about this.
i dont think fang is "gaslighting". i think he is just worried that gram could be scum trying to paint him as scummy and lynch him

when fang is scum he town read the people pushing him iirc

i feel like he thinks gram is town but then he doesnt wanna town read someone tunneling him this much so he decides to scum read him so he isnt wrong later in case gram was scum

========

rem's contributions r on the weak side yes, but do u sense any ill agenda? like sus'iest thing i can feel from him is maybe a tmi read on fang (but i arrived at same read so idk). its just i remember rem does pocket as scum but this doesnt feel like he is gaining favor of fang and using him to push anything. also him having a scum list of 5 players doesnt help him as scum. need his reasoning for the reads rn cuz they r mostly lazy

do u town read everyone else? thoughts on cp?
More interactions between Ekko and Tweet regarding me vs Grammaton & BPD. He offers a very different theory/angle on my interactions with them which goes against the majority of what the rest of the game's players were seeing it, like Grammaton or Tweet getting flashbacks of the Elden Ring game when I was scum and caught early on and put on the backfoot.

Its not always true but sometimes a good sign of a town player is going against more 'popular' ideas regarding another player's play style.
Anyway tenders suspicion but doesn't give a clear read on Rem/Raem.
Note he double backs to asking about Craig.
when will u be able to share more?

could we have this by end of the day:

- if aurelian is town - where u go next?
- if aurelian is scum - where u go next?

im still 5 pages behind but we can try to solve beyond aurelian and if u wanna pivot to him later u can. i feel like day is being too stale on him

+ thoughts on cp pls
Back to responding with Grammaton, he's playing more focused again and trying to see besides my slot where Grammaton wants to go, who else is at the top of his bucket list to pressure or press on to further solve in the game.
gram thats what a voyer is. it gives u the types of abilities visiting ur target. it doesnt give u any hint at alignment. i feel like u have so much confidence talking about this when u shudnt even know what abilities scum have this game

think of it this way. if fang targets a player and that player was visited by a preventative or manipulative ability that nobody claims, then that player can be considered town (or indie) as they were mostly targeted by mafia. does this make sense? thats the best utility of a claimed voyeur. he will hardly catch a scum lying about usage, but he can atleast confirm townies being targeted by scum actions (unless u think scum targets themselves with roleblocks/redirections)
Has a good idea of what my role is after I explained it, trying to bridge any misunderstanding about it. Also slight but warning tone in the early part of this post about Grammaton's idea of what capabilities the scum team should or shouldn't have but otherwise nothing else notable about it.
seems like best direction to move game forward at this point

can u talk to me more about the town read of cp. which points did u agree with and felt like he was solving? could they not come from scum cp?
Again back to interacting with BPD. Ekko seems to be resolved to just go with it now but once again talks about Craig, as he did with Tweet and to Grammaton. I parsed through earlier so am still a bit confused why Ekko seems to have Craig singled out as the player he wants to hear opinions and thoughts on the most to multiple other people in the game.
nice, agree on cp. down to yeet even before aurelian
Again to Evans, is happy to push Craig into a lynch even before me.
Why?
i dont have a reason to town read him

this is what i recall from cp

> opened by telling evans not to talk about tpein. very easy topic to have as scum
> tagged psychic multiple times for asking her to do stuff. this goes nowhere. nor from cp's side nor psychics. potential teammate equity
> cant tell his stance on the you vs aurelian topic. as evans mentioned it feels like cp is wishy washy about this wagon. i ant really tell u other than this who he really scum reads
> his comments are honestly nitpicking easy inconsistencies that town can make all the time, like his posts to tpein. this isnt really solving. this is scum fake contributing


i dont have anything from cp to town read him off
First real push back from another player, Grammaton, about Ekko being very trigger happy to lynch or push on Craig. Ekko's response here is a bit bizarre, not out of character, but I can't follow his weird but haphazard tells of logic on why he wants Craig gone so happy. He's talking about mainly using Evans vs Craig as the crux of it, and Craig going at Psychic, which is something townie Craig has under his belt multiple times and caught her on as town and mafia in past games.

Why would this rattle Ekko? Especially since he was already pressing about Craig's slot well before this happened?
He also argues Craig is being too "pushy" with his stance with other players like with Psychic or Evans but this seems completely in character?
I just can't follow it.
its not in ur control to just adjust, unless u mean ur gna hard bus ur whole team stronger lol

gna depend on how well town does in finding ur other teammates. if we r doing well u will be forced in awkward position sooner or later
After Magic responds that Ekko was reading him as "pro town", Ekko says basically Magic can't really change how he's portrayed himself in the game but argues this will give him leverage to pressure Magic down the line if he becomes suspicious?

Don't really get this either.
i didnt draw any sort of connection at all, if anything id say scum's best bet here is to no lynch maybe?
Evans liked this post from Ekko responding to Grammaton questioning why some people were scum-reading Craig or wanting to prep him for a possible lynch down the line. I mean his statement is true about a no lynch being the best option for day 1's end but its like...okay? That's stating the obvious. Again though I don't know WHY Ekko has hyper tunneled as much on Craig until later pivoting to underlining why he can't have BPD as town right now without resolving for me or him, or rather prefacing to pushing Craig as the counter wagon.
 
Ekko the Kekko time:


Ekko opens up with his first meaty post after fluffing it up early to give some decent reads on Grammaton, Melkor, Magic, Sworder, and Evans.
Pay attention to Craig here though in regards to Ekko.

So Ekko here moves from seeing me as null to town while responding and replying to Grammaton.

He also asks Grammaton where else he wants to go and who he wants to read besides me, supporting his normal town behavior. But then he also questions Tweet about town reading Melkor, another important player when it comes to reads from Ekko but we'll get back to that later.

Obviously the tail end of this post is him asking me about Grammaton and specifically me questioning Evans about T-Pein.

Much like Craig later on in the game, Ekko is pressing BPD to give evidence or explain his reasoning for claiming I was faking being town vs my normal play style as town.

Again in the second half of this post it was directed to Tweet and directly says he's suspicious of the town read on Melkor.

His follow up going into more detail and producing evidence and receipts about Melkor's scum play and habits in past games. I don't want to say this seems premeditated but it also will reek of tying myself into it to Ekko, but Ekko, HAS claimed he is able to read both me and Melkor strongly when we play as any slot to figure us out.

Ekko is very confident about this.

More interactions between Ekko and Tweet regarding me vs Grammaton & BPD. He offers a very different theory/angle on my interactions with them which goes against the majority of what the rest of the game's players were seeing it, like Grammaton or Tweet getting flashbacks of the Elden Ring game when I was scum and caught early on and put on the backfoot.

Its not always true but sometimes a good sign of a town player is going against more 'popular' ideas regarding another player's play style.
Anyway tenders suspicion but doesn't give a clear read on Rem/Raem.
Note he double backs to asking about Craig.

Back to responding with Grammaton, he's playing more focused again and trying to see besides my slot where Grammaton wants to go, who else is at the top of his bucket list to pressure or press on to further solve in the game.

Has a good idea of what my role is after I explained it, trying to bridge any misunderstanding about it. Also slight but warning tone in the early part of this post about Grammaton's idea of what capabilities the scum team should or shouldn't have but otherwise nothing else notable about it.

Again back to interacting with BPD. Ekko seems to be resolved to just go with it now but once again talks about Craig, as he did with Tweet and to Grammaton. I parsed through earlier so am still a bit confused why Ekko seems to have Craig singled out as the player he wants to hear opinions and thoughts on the most to multiple other people in the game.

Again to Evans, is happy to push Craig into a lynch even before me.
Why?

First real push back from another player, Grammaton, about Ekko being very trigger happy to lynch or push on Craig. Ekko's response here is a bit bizarre, not out of character, but I can't follow his weird but haphazard tells of logic on why he wants Craig gone so happy. He's talking about mainly using Evans vs Craig as the crux of it, and Craig going at Psychic, which is something townie Craig has under his belt multiple times and caught her on as town and mafia in past games.

Why would this rattle Ekko? Especially since he was already pressing about Craig's slot well before this happened?
He also argues Craig is being too "pushy" with his stance with other players like with Psychic or Evans but this seems completely in character?
I just can't follow it.

After Magic responds that Ekko was reading him as "pro town", Ekko says basically Magic can't really change how he's portrayed himself in the game but argues this will give him leverage to pressure Magic down the line if he becomes suspicious?

Don't really get this either.

Evans liked this post from Ekko responding to Grammaton questioning why some people were scum-reading Craig or wanting to prep him for a possible lynch down the line. I mean his statement is true about a no lynch being the best option for day 1's end but its like...okay? That's stating the obvious. Again though I don't know WHY Ekko has hyper tunneled as much on Craig until later pivoting to underlining why he can't have BPD as town right now without resolving for me or him, or rather prefacing to pushing Craig as the counter wagon.
thanks for reminding me BPD had that bizzare town read of cp and the explaination to it was meh as fk

tell you what, i dont wanna lynch u anymore tbh

its between BPD and cp for me now. with pressure on xadlin odd lethal nat slots needed
 
Psychic also had raem as scum and had no reaction to his modkill and moved on like it was nothing. Just an absent of a reaction.

Honestly likely want to lynch psychic at this point but want to see others weigh in. The content of her multi quotes were fine but the reads list is lacking compared to her recent town games. On top of thst I see heavy teammate equity with cp and I'm not feeling him either.
She's kinda just been "around", didn't get any sort of AI vibes out of her so far which is kinda odd

What did you like about BPD enough for you to unvote?
 
@Black Pegged Dragon i noticed u have cp as scum now / want to go to his direction. where did that transition happen? you had him town before?

Psychic also had raem as scum and had no reaction to his modkill and moved on like it was nothing. Just an absent of a reaction.

Honestly likely want to lynch psychic at this point but want to see others weigh in. The content of her multi quotes were fine but the reads list is lacking compared to her recent town games. On top of thst I see heavy teammate equity with cp and I'm not feeling him either.
hey magic is there a game related reason holding u up from making a definitive read on cp btw?
 
@Grammaton its time u divulge those reads u were withholding earlier imo. i kind of dont think aurelian is the way. thoughts on his most recent posts?

surely u must have someone else next in line that u wanna explore right?
 
@Aurelian fill this list with all the players as much as u can pls. dont have to give reasoning for now

town
-

lean town

-

town side of null
-

null
-

scum side of null
-

lean scum
-

scum

-
 
She's kinda just been "around", didn't get any sort of AI vibes out of her so far which is kinda odd

What did you like about BPD enough for you to unvote?
Her read list is weak but on top of that the way she talked about aurelian needing to be resolved felt weird. If aurelian is town scum would suggest that his lynch needs to go through but it's way too early to be suggesting that. The rest of her reads don't even come across as real reads.

His reaction to his own wagon is entirely nonchalant. He's not really going hard at defending or deterring people off the wagon and that would check out with the stump claim
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top