Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

[Arne Slot]

are you scared of Odo & Magic?

Why wouldn't you try to convince them about your read on T-Pein and push for them to join you?

Or anyone else for that matter?

You're just providing proof that you were showponying that you had excellent reason to push T-Pein today then backed off as if it was enough effort to not look like busy work.

I work with other thread leaders, I was sure t-pein was scum d1 of MHW too but let Magic have his lethal lynch. Was that a pony show too?? I did push him more then because he was around to actually push and I had a lot of support including people who sussed him before me (not the case at all here), yet I still relented in the end.

 

[Evans]

I work with other thread leaders, I was sure t-pein was scum d1 of MHW too but let Magic have his lethal lynch. Was that a pony show too?? I did push him more then because he was around to actually push and I had a lot of support including people who sussed him before me (not the case at all here), yet I still relented in the end.

Was T-Pein scum that game?

Why would you make that same mistake twice considering you're so sure on his meta? You're not that selfless of a player.
Nor is it in towns interest for you to not push through on a read that you're certain is scum, especially after relenting before for the same result

 

[Arne Slot]

Was T-Pein scum that game?

Why would you make that same mistake twice considering you're so sure on his meta? You're not that selfless of a player.
Nor is it in towns interest for you to not push through on a read that you're certain is scum, especially after relenting before for the same result

yes that's literally the game we're talking about lol

I'm not going to kick and scream for people to follow me on a guy who isn't even around

 

[Evans]

yes that's literally the game we're talking about lol

I'm not going to kick and scream for people to follow me on a guy who isn't even around

It was rhetorical.

 

[Evans]

You don't need to kick and scream. That's just oversimplification. You could have easily made more of a case considering you used MHW as a basis for how concrete your read is on T-Penis.

 

[Arne Slot]

You don't need to kick and scream. That's just oversimplification. You could have easily made more of a case considering you used MHW as a basis for how concrete your read is on T-Penis.

no I couldn't, I literally can't think of anything else to say about it

 

[Evans]

no I couldn't, I literally can't think of anything else to say about it

So, you're absolutely certain someone is scum and you can only think of

"eh, vote him and go to bed. That'll do it"

????????

 

[Arne Slot]

So, you're absolutely certain someone is scum and you can only think of

"eh, vote him and go to bed. That'll do it"

????????

k this is disingenuous, you quoted more from me than just that about t-pein

 

[Arne Slot]

Which reads do you feel decent about? Here's what you said:

"minor town reads on Tweet and CP (but I'm more on the fence with CP than Tweet)"

"I do think I'm fine with your (Gram) slot"

hedged the T-Pein read

"Xad might be town?"

"I guess Tsword has been fine as well"

The bit about lethal there

Like none of these sound like you're actually town reading any of these people, so what are these town reads you feel decent about?

@Black Pegged Dragon I didn't get a response from you about this btw

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Well no you didn’t say anything, that’s why I’m asking

i have no connection, no
i think cp is scummier than tpein and aurelian, and could be simply jumping from one mislynch to another

@Aurelian can you respond to this for me?

And also, hmmm voyeur

is this a real question? u expect him to answer something different other than the 120+ posts he already had on the topic?

 

[Evans]

k this is disingenuous, you quoted more from me than just that about t-pein

No it isn't.

brb sleep, think t-pein is the best direction

I'm about here rn

1 - @RÆM
2 - @Evans
3 - @Magic
4 - @CraigPelton
5 - @TSworder
6 - @Black Pegged Dragon
7 - @Ekkologix
8 - @T-Pein™
9 - @Psychic
10 - @Xadlin
11 - @Grammaton
12 - @Lord Melkor
13 - @Aurelian
14 - @Hans Tweetenberg
15 - @Natalija
16 - @Odd
17 - @Lethal

could see Evans/Aurelian together, maaaybe Evans/T-Pein. don't see T-Pein/Aurelian really

nobody biting on t-pein has me a bit shook tho like did I not catch him dead to rights in MHW? did I not show receipts for how he's exactly the same? why did everyone just no-sell that lol

unvote
vote Aurelian

gone like a whimper

 

[Arne Slot]

No it isn't.









gone like a whimper

err my posts about why I think t-pein is scum came before I went to bed

 

[Aurelian]

[Unvote]

 

[Evans]

err my posts about why I think t-pein is scum came before I went to bed

... Yes they did.

But you left your vote and then pretty quickly moved onto Aurelian when you re-appeared in the thread.

1hr20 minutes exactly.

 

[Arne Slot]

... Yes they did.

But you left your vote and then pretty quickly moved onto Aurelian when you re-appeared in the thread.

1hr20 minutes exactly.

yep and my posts explain why very clearly, this is going in circles

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

another way to look at it if you weren't just tunneling: encouraging players to solve rather than wage personal vendettas is a pro-town move

not in page 2, no. the value of letting it play out to see tpein's/other player's response to it is greater than cutting it short

literally led to her dropping some substance which felt like town psychic, which I was the first to acknowledge. so it led to a town read.

psychic did not make that post just cuz u tagged her btw. she is bound to eventually post. ur posts to her also seemed more like jokes not real pressure. u get no credit for any of this

yeah I have reservations about it because he's not too different from MHW but Odo has made some good points and was right about him in Fallout, I tend to trust players like Magic and Odo d1 more than my own reads and also letting them get their way helps me read them

no offense to odo but i have barely seen anything worthy to make me blind follow him in all games ive played with him here. im sure he is capable, but no way im blind trusting him to the degree u r doing here

what if aurelian flips town? i saw u earlier say its about the method not the result. so u have gram as town eitherway. do u need to give him his lynch now or do u think u can convince him on another lynch? whats ur own take on fang?

 

[Arne Slot]

I'm not responding to that btw so we can move along

 

[Arne Slot]

[Unvote]

thoughts on BPD?

 

[Aurelian]

thoughts on BPD?

I'm wondering why your asking me this. You earlier had BPD as one of your stronger town reads but later today seem to show reservations about him. Does it have anything to do with you and Evans?

Probably he is probably a wolf here. Very defensive about people's suscpions on him but outside of me seems to be fence sitting.

[Vote Lynch BPD]

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Can you clarify this, not sure what you mean

were u able to catch up?

my thoughts:

Town:
Melkor
Gram
Magic
lethal
Hans

Pro town:
Ekko
psychic
Craig
Ekko
Black dragon
Sworder

Indie:
T-pein- hes to good of a heel for me to put in either category.
Evan- his hateboner for t-pein makes him neg in my book

leaning Scum:
natalija- asked for a catchup and posted more then me
odd- odd made some town claims on day 1 so I think thats sus

[vote Lynch odd]
I dont get the whole Aurelian thing that happened for lik 5 -10 pages

why do u have cp and BPD as town?

Yes, I have a wolf lean on Fang, but I could see how he's playing coming from Town Fang, maybe. I do think there's a better chance he's putting on a show than not, though.

what gives u that impression?

I had a town read on Melkor and Psychic that I discussed, as well as minor town reads on Tweet and CP (but I'm more on the fence with CP than Tweet). Think Raem is been no bueno. I do think I'm fine with your slot with how you dealt with Fang. Evans might be fine as well? Unironically liked Tpein's entrance a whole lot more than I liked him last game, but he could be wanting not to be another easy lynch if he did roll wolf here. Magic I'm a bit curious about? I think he has definitely been proactive, but I'd have to look at his posts closer to see how he's framing and guiding things. Ekko I initially kind of got a not so great gut feeling about; that read is in development. Xad might be town? Nat is meh. Odd is Odd. Think that covers just about everyone?

Oh and Tsword and Lethal. I guess Tsword has been fine as well. Lethal's catchup hasn't moved me in one way or another. I'd probably say slight town on his slot, though, just because I don't sense any real fakeness from him at the moment.

fang aside, who wud be ur preferred direction today? there is a lack of wagoning for pressure from u this game