• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hades Mafia - Game Thread

why did you end up voting me instead of ekko or watson, particularly the former, when they had more votes and interest? like you even questioned why there wasn't a wagon on watson then you end up voting me despite, from your position and not having played in like 6 months, knowing that it would be much harder to pull off and require people to get away from ekko.
I didn’t question why there wasn’t a wagon on Watson, think that was alco

I told u in the post u quoted. I went for you for the SPICE. Tbh I didn’t really know which scum read I felt strongest about at the time
 
Idk man I didn’t really like the post. She seems to have basically decided Ekko as scum and points all of the posts she quotes to lean that way. I’m used to her being way more open minded in her analysis lol
I agree it felt very forced and shallow. I think it's a bus tbh
 
@Magic what player would you say in this game do you typically struggle the hardest at reading?



Magic you seem really defensive right now m8. Aside from Luka and you saying Craig is the hardest player for you to read, you've just double downed on defending Orca more than necessary for a day 1 kickoff.
seriously what the hell was this.

why would you add that bit about craig. it all comes in within like 10 minutes and you didnt even wait for me to answer "why craig" before saying this.
 
Magic is wasting quite a lot of time trying to make sense out of Aurelian, something he has criticised me for in the past and called me scummy for lol
 
Ah, I see. Forget I asked.

I wouldn't say I'm hung up on it, I had the exact opposite impression because it didn't feel fake at all. You don't strike me as the type to make up a reason that you don't believe in at least a little bit either to qualify a read, so am I to take this as a concession that you did?
yes i did and i am the type to do that. id do it more often too if i could get away with it but people will latch onto to it as a reason to tunnel me so i dont.
 
Magic is wasting quite a lot of time trying to make sense out of Aurelian, something he has criticised me for in the past and called me scummy for lol
he's usually the one being like "guys aurelian is obvtown this is ez" and then giving others grief for not seeing it

thing is, this is all pretty obvious and doesn't feel like a trap he'd fall into as scum so idk what's going on here. makes me second guess myself tbdean
 
Magic is wasting quite a lot of time trying to make sense out of Aurelian, something he has criticised me for in the past and called me scummy for lol
that's cause aurelian is generally an easy town read for me and im not seeing it this game and those questions stick out in particular as he was the one that asked them.

im also not wasting time, im reading back to catch up, which is pretty evident if you just look.
Well currently it helps add to some ideas I've had

Later in the game if he is town it may help with some confirmation to my thoughts or if he is scum its something to look into with more detail
what are your ideas m8

what do you think of him saying poyser is town for essentially being the only one not to go after him and instead go for me then watson?
 
@Ekkologix you should claim, might help the wagon shift on to retro

Of course, it might not. But you won’t know until you try!

Wagon certainly won’t dissipate without a claim in any case
 
I agree it felt very forced and shallow. I think it's a bus tbh

Then both cannibalizing each other at the same time feels almost *too* obvious lol. Guess she would have to do something though. As town Watson sometimes goes days without even placing a vote so this is possibly more evidence of her being self aware. From Ekko's PoV that swap makes even less sense, could just easily be opportunism as well but in either case I think he's struggling to stay afloat
 
anyway assuming we lynch one of ekko/retro and they flip scum I am going to OFFICIALLY REQUEST PROTECTION as I feel I have made myself too obvtown and I don't usually get protected. Don't wanna get sidelined early again this game!
 
Adding to "I'll shit my pants over this player because reading them is difficult of my reads are ever so slightly off and incorrectly town read them"

GAD has proven to be one of these types for me - he is promoted to Captain Coinflip now
Is... that a good thing?
hey best buddy what u got for me this game
I was hoping y'all got something for me actually.
This post does not give me best vibes, seems performative.
I disagree. There's fluff, sure. And there's going to be fluff in the future as well. But they're valid points for me to look back on eventually.
Well for starter do you agree with his town reads?
Can't answer. I'm with Retro aka amnesia buddy on this one. Too early for me to have solid reads.
out of gad's play, his read on nipples is what i do like btw, but it also feels like one of the few things he is doing too.
I was told my play isn't constant tho.
youre really not giving any reads, mostly just comments.

everything also goes towards the null direction for you, even your responses to other people's reads such as poyser's here about watson.
Sorta true. Time issues plus D1 isn't my strongest phase to get into detective mode.

But also, not true, I've moved Best Buddy and Luka from slight town to N/A, and that's something. Not a lot, but it's something. I'll have something more solid later. D1 is usually y'all tryna catch someone but there's a chance that whatever y'all are reacting to and investigating might have been a joke/fluff post. I get it builds off of that but it's not the most accurate source for me to read off of.

I'm slowly reading through the thread while responding to any direct quotes atm so I'mma go back to that
 
alco makes this entrance post 3:37 my time


luka responds 1 minute later


alco then posts this 3:41


luka respons to alco 3:42



this interaction happens 3:42 to 3:43


luka already places alco in scum side in 3:44


alco makes this post 3:47 to continue his interaction with watson


luka makes no comment on alco, but somehow places him as scum here

QED the reason cannot be because of alco lurking etc.. alco has not reacted to any post while not posting himself, the read is bullshit. luka goes to scum reads
lmao wtf is this time analysis
 
What did you check?
Very disingenuous of you. I started by saying I don't scum read any of them - you've taken what my post was responding to out of context to make it look like I've flipped my read on Tweet, when I was simply asked which of Tweet Ultra and Famg I think are most likely to be scum. I acknowledge I haven't really given a read on Fang yet but I'd say town, probably more confident in that than I am in my Ultra read.
 
ekko your town reads seemingly appear from people not aligning against you or being willing to go somewhere outside of you(i.e. poyser voted me and you said you thought he was doing the best out of the T1's and then craig wanting to move to watson and suddenly you say you view him town too).

looks convenient more than actual solves.



why is ekko not going after an easy target weird? how do you view that as alignment indicative?

as i referenced earlier, ive been mislynched or shot as both alignments consistently in the past few months so your meta is mostly out of date. last time i was scum i was lynched day 2 i think and then town lost because they figured i wouldnt expect to die and wouldn't distance properly with my teammates even though i did expect to die because ive been dying a lot early.

so being above being accused isn't exactly on point. @Alco im not even sure why you liked this post, you just saw it last game and i was vigged night 1.
but i still think poyser is town and cp is lean town for his post to retro.

i also came around to seeing luka as town despite his main directions being shit

feel like ur trying to frame it to make me look scummy without really committing to it
 
Back
Top