• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Medieval Fantasy Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Black Pegged Dragon said:
Why do you think Melkor is town? I did feel he was wolf out the gate so I'm curious as to why our reads differ.
Click to expand...
I thought a lot of the questions he asked were good ones (ones I’d ask) and I didn’t see any reason to scum read him while browsing his ISO. It seems to me that the majority of the counter reads to this deal with his meta which isn’t something I’m putting into my personal reads at the present (my willingness to follow someone’s/consensus meta read depends on many other factors).

I also had the gut reaction (from my personal view as a host) to see a double voter as town. To me, the role is significantly stronger as a mafia role than a town one, and so for balance reasons is one I personally avoid when making games. I also think scum!Melkor would want to find out beforehand (and in a way has more opportunity to find this out as a teammate could have asked) if their vote would show in the VC, and I felt Melkor was genuine when he said he didn’t realize
 
Whicker said:
I thought a lot of the questions he asked were good ones (ones I’d ask) and I didn’t see any reason to scum read him while browsing his ISO. It seems to me that the majority of the counter reads to this deal with his meta which isn’t something I’m putting into my personal reads at the present (my willingness to follow someone’s/consensus meta read depends on many other factors).

I also had the gut reaction (from my personal view as a host) to see a double voter as town. To me, the role is significantly stronger as a mafia role than a town one, and so for balance reasons is one I personally avoid when making games. I also think scum!Melkor would want to find out beforehand (and in a way has more opportunity to find this out as a teammate could have asked) if their vote would show in the VC, and I felt Melkor was genuine when he said he didn’t realize
Click to expand...
My read on melkor wasn't based on meta.
 
@Magic in past games there have big some relatively big spats between Poyser vs BPD, Grammaton vs BPD, me vs BPD, but he's sort of mellowed out as a player. I've observed the chance when he was playing Ratchet's Fate game, again in Ratchet's Final Fantasy game, then again in Ekko's Jujutsu Kaisen game, and again in the game where I was scum and he was town in Melkor's Dresden Files game.
 
Whicker said:
I thought a lot of the questions he asked were good ones (ones I’d ask) and I didn’t see any reason to scum read him while browsing his ISO. It seems to me that the majority of the counter reads to this deal with his meta which isn’t something I’m putting into my personal reads at the present (my willingness to follow someone’s/consensus meta read depends on many other factors).

I also had the gut reaction (from my personal view as a host) to see a double voter as town. To me, the role is significantly stronger as a mafia role than a town one, and so for balance reasons is one I personally avoid when making games. I also think scum!Melkor would want to find out beforehand (and in a way has more opportunity to find this out as a teammate could have asked) if their vote would show in the VC, and I felt Melkor was genuine when he said he didn’t realize
Click to expand...
Hmmm. These are good points.

If Whicker is wolf, I might be in trouble this game.
 
Anyway, enough talking about my job lol. Any important developments? Did anyone slip or do sth really sus? I‘ll catch up once I wake up, which considering my exhaustion can be at 2pm lol.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top