Game Ranked Negima Mafia

[Whicker]

The point is that you're looking increasingly scummy when pressed on your reasons

This is kind of Orca’s MO. He doesn’t actually believe in the “7th spot” or anything, but he wants to see how people respond to him

 

[Sky]

This is kind of Orca’s MO. He doesn’t actually believe in the “7th spot” or anything, but he wants to see how people respond to him

Oh so he's another T-Pein then. Good to know

 

[Polar Bear]

Pretty sure everyone has their own style when playing as scum. Can't really peg it down to one single method or tactic on this site at least.

Of course. But in general I'd wager that across communities drawing unneeded and unwarranted attention to yourself is not going to be a general playstyle for scum

How convenient, those people have like 10 posts between them

That's the point, do you not want to look at the "lurkers" for a reason?

 

[Whicker]

Orca, fine? Really? The guy who voted for no reason, then revealed he had nothing except fake statistics, and doubled down on his statistics? Really?

very much noted

See above. Although to be fair both Polar and Orca are good at replicating their town games and I’m not 100% at reading them.

They’re both experienced mafia players though nor are they idiots. I don’t think this is a scum ploy

 

[Polar Bear]

Oh so he's another T-Pein then. Good to know

T-Pein on steroids, I'd say I'm more calculated but a bit wilder at times lol

 

[The Orca]

The point is that you're looking increasingly scummy when pressed on your reasons

Should I care that they appear scummy to you? They are my reasons. You do with it as you like

 

[Sky]

Should I care that they appear scummy to you? They are my reasons. You do with it as you like

They're very shaky reasons, and when forced to confront that you refuse to admit it

 

[Sky]

That's the point, do you not want to look at the "lurkers" for a reason?

Lurkers are definitely worth testing later, but it's the first half of Day 1. They've not produced any content yet. We're not blind voting

 

[The Orca]

Orca, fine? Really? The guy who voted for no reason, then revealed he had nothing except fake statistics, and doubled down on his statistics? Really?

very much noted

Why are you as well ignoring the non statistical reasons as well

 

[Polar Bear]

Lurkers are definitely worth testing later, but it's the first half of Day 1. They've not produced any content yet. We're not blind voting

Isn't that what you are in fact doing lol.

Unless you just had a slip there? You have more knowledge then you are letting on?

 

[Ratchet]

Vote Count Day 1

Hime: Grammaton > Polar Bear
Sky: Grammaton > Unvote > Psychic
T-Pein: Grammaton > Polar Bear > Sky
Whicker: The Orca > Sky > Polar Bear > Hime Balsamic: Hime
Kurumi: Psychic
Grammaton: Retro
Psychic: Sky
Aurelian: Retro
Polar Bear: Sky
The Orca: Kurumi
Fujishiro: Lethal

Sky - 3
Hime/Lethal/Retro/Psychic - 2
Kurumi - 1

CC @Flower (current as of post 369)​

 

[Sky]

Isn't that what you are in fact doing lol.

Unless you just had a slip there? You have more knowledge then you are letting on?

....uh no? Just because we don't have info doesn't make the Psychic vote a blind vote, it's based on her activity in the thread. Blind voting would be jumping on someone like CP who hasn't posted once

 

[The Orca]

See above. Although to be fair both Polar and Orca are good at replicating their town games and I’m not 100% at reading them.

They’re both experienced mafia players though nor are they idiots. I don’t think this is a scum ploy

Oh man, now I wish I had done something different to start this game lmao

They're very shaky reasons, and when forced to confront that you refuse to admit it

Did I ever say either of the statistical reasons were guaranteed? Its just a part of the equation and that part is far from a guarantee. It is however (for our old board) a statistical probability that the 7th spot is most likely to be scum regardless of game size. Does that hold true here, who knows, I dont. It is and how I framed it, a strike in my eyes

 

[Sky]

Why are you as well ignoring the non statistical reasons as well

From what I can tell (since you didn't quote shit) they are based on posts during fluff phase and so have about the same amount of basis as you continuing to latch on to slot 7 theory (which is to say none at all)

 

[Polar Bear]

....uh no? Just because we don't have info doesn't make the Psychic vote a blind vote, it's based on her activity in the thread. Blind voting would be jumping on someone like CP who hasn't posted once

But we are all blindly voting at its core. Everyone just rationalized things to make them feel correct

Oh man, now I wish I had done something different to start this game lmao

Did I ever say either of the statistical reasons were guaranteed? Its just a part of the equation and that part is far from a guarantee. It is however (for our old board) a statistical probability that the 7th spot is most likely to be scum regardless of game size. Does that hold true here, who knows, I dont. It is and how I framed it, a strike in my eyes

You mean like popping on with your first post and going

"Does red mean im with the good guys"

 

[Polar Bear]

@Sky since you are here, let me ask you this.

How often is scum lynched D1?

 

[The Orca]

But we are all blindly voting at its core. Everyone just rationalized things to make them feel correct

You mean like popping on with your first post and going

"Does red mean im with the good guys"

"How do I join the mafia chat"

 

[T-Pein™]

@Sky since you are here, let me ask you this.

How often is scum lynched D1?

This is Sky 1st game here.
Scum always wins tho.
all year scum lost 3 times and 2 of them was cuz of extreme bussing.

 

[T-Pein™]

Almost never.

 

[Sky]

@Sky since you are here, let me ask you this.

How often is scum lynched D1?

I don't get what you're trying to ask here. Is the implication that since often Day 1 is a ML, we might as well not bother trying to get scum before D2?