• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Game Ranked OLF Members Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Lord Melkor

Lord Melkor

Exceptional
Sky said:
You're just gonna call me fake off nothing? Nice, towny

It isn't a good look hard defending Ultra off your own thoughts though. The question isn't should Ultra claim, it's what does the fact that he doesn't want to claim say? And you've muddied that by going in and giving him a reason, so we can't really read off it
Click to expand...

I can think of several reasons, at least one of them very obvious.
 
Ratchet

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
Test
I have some thoughts on the Ultra/CP situation but was hoping to save them until I catch up - I think Ultra comes off the better of the two. There was one instance in particular where CP to me looked a bit rattled - Gram brought up a player (Magic, I think) and CP immediately went to grab some quotes from that player, in isolation it struck me as him looking for an escape route.

I do agree with CP in that Ultra's insistence he tie all his scum reads together day 1 was silly, but I do think it's something you do subconsciously. Like as I'm writing this I'm trying to fit Retro and CP as a team. I think I'd like a claim from Craig.
 
Ratchet

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
Test
Ratchet said:
I have some thoughts on the Ultra/CP situation but was hoping to save them until I catch up - I think Ultra comes off the better of the two. There was one instance in particular where CP to me looked a bit rattled - Gram brought up a player (Magic, I think) and CP immediately went to grab some quotes from that player, in isolation it struck me as him looking for an escape route.

I do agree with CP in that Ultra's insistence he tie all his scum reads together day 1 was silly, but I do think it's something you do subconsciously. Like as I'm writing this I'm trying to fit Retro and CP as a team. I think I'd like a claim from Craig.
Click to expand...
Kweh!
 
Votecount: D1 P1488
  • Index
    • Poyser

    Poyser

    Moderator
    Moderator
    Day 1 Vote Count

    Dr Watson (2) - Ratchet, Tweet
    Flower (2) - Nibel, Xadlin
    Nibel (1) - Gramma
    Ultra (4) - Sky, CP, Gad, T-Pein
    Ekko (1) - Lord Melkor
    Lord Melkor (3) - Ekko, Rej, Aurelian
    CraigPelton (4) - Ultra, Flower, Magic, Luka
    Evans (1) - The Orca

    With 25 alive, it’s 13 to lynch. You have 30.25 hours remaining​
     
  • Index
    • Lord Melkor

    Lord Melkor

    Exceptional
    Sky said:
    I do have thoughts about something Ultra said which is actually very correct

    Basically no one has made a concrete stance on me, I wonder how much of that is genuinely not knowing and how much is opportunism
    Click to expand...

    I gave you a town read pretty early for starters. I think Grammaton did as well.
     
    Lord Melkor

    Lord Melkor

    Exceptional
    Lord Melkor said:
    Town reads so far:

    Sky
    Watson
    Aurelian
    Ratchet
    Click to expand...

    @Ratchet those were my early town reads. I would also add Flower, Ultra and Tpein to town reads right now.

    On scum leans i have Ekko (no activity other than push on me, he should know better), Tweet (i do not recall any serious engagments from his other than weak push on Ultra), CP (weak entrance which resulted in him just agreeing with 2 most popular scum reads in me and Watson, also not convinced by his Ultra push), to lesser extent also Gad and Gram.
     
    Ultra

    Ultra

    THE BEAR
    Moderator
    Mafia Beast
    Lord Melkor said:
    And why did Gram stop being your scum read @Ultra?
    Click to expand...

    When I push a direction and it completely and utterly falls flat on its face - I mean 0 reception, I'm privy to the fact that means *something*. I'm basically sure it just flat out doesn't happen if Gram is scum in a game with 25 players, at least one scum mate would break formation and distance or something, but the positioning around his play seemed entirely oriented in calling him town. This by itself is good enough for me to call it a day. It's possible, hypothetically, that he is scum and that his whole squad just remained headstrong. But in practice that's fairly unlikely.

    Looking at my wagon composition, some of the reasoning tossed around for voting me being couched in Gram being town, I think him being so is just much easier to explain as me taking a swing, missing, and then getting henpecked over it
     
    Reader mode
    Status
    Not open for further replies.
    Back
    Top