Ranked One Piece Wano Arc

[Bachi]

I think Kurumi is likely a hit. I don't buy for a second she would just ghost as Town here.

She must be cold-blooded if she is doing this to a scum team

 

[Ultra]

I haven't claimed CP was a home run and I dont know why that needs to be the burden of evidence when he has otherwise done, what, exactly? I also said I didn't like his position around Ekko because it feels like he is, what do they say, good guying him.

So let's talk about the bigger picture here, let's say CP is scum.

He is currently in THE BOX and needs to find a way out

Your argument is that his solution to THE BOX is to very lightly, with a fairy's touch, denounce your town read and then "good guying" Ekko, who I am presuming from your PoV in this scenario is town?

If Ekko is town why not play into what you/Magic are doing beating the stuffing out of him? Would be strategically neglectful to not try and push the envelope a bit.

And as a general extension what do you think his strategy here has been because I haven't noticed him making any big leaps in assumption or contributing to the solve on a way that is misdirecting.

Finally, you're neglecting an important aspect of scum CP - he gets demotivated rather easily. I've seen it countless times, and this situation would 100% qualify as an excuse for him to wanna pitch it in and fuck off. Instead he seems pretty normal. Minor detail, but goes along way, the reverse is also true for those who had genuine reaction/celebration to the Sky thing rather than immediately folding into the next topic

 

[Aurelian]

Has there been a precedent in past ranked games here of town vigs having daykills? Last game I remember with a daykill was Gramm's MHW and the time it happened came from the SK.

 

[Flower]

She must be cold-blooded if she is doing this to a scum team

I mean, it's better to ghost than to create more spew, sometimes.

 

[Doddsy]

Finally, you're neglecting an important aspect of scum CP - he gets demotivated rather easily. I've seen it countless times, and this situation would 100% qualify as an excuse for him to wanna pitch it in and fuck off. Instead he seems pretty normal. Minor detail, but goes along way, the reverse is also true for those who had genuine reaction/celebration to the Sky thing rather than immediately folding into the next topic

This is not a good meta read of CP

 

[Flower]

Has there been a precedent in past ranked games here of town vigs having daykills? Last game I remember with a daykill was Gramm's MHW and the time it happened came from the SK.

Wrestling Game. And I'm not a full Vig. The daykill was my only ability.

 

[Ultra]

Idk why you think CP is Town, Ultra. The guy gave me nothing so far. And I don't think I'm a bad CP reader myself.

I'm willing to reread him and give him a fair shake but I am not strongly convinced. He's in the table of course since his interactions with Sky don't even exist, I would like to give him another day. I've seen hints of insight that seem more likely to come from town CP who is genuinely helpful

 

[Ultra]

This is not a good meta read of CP

Thank you resident expert and prime lynch candidate Doddsy who is looking for anything he could possibly grab into as life support!

 

[Ratchet]

So let's talk about the bigger picture here, let's say CP is scum.

He is currently in THE BOX and needs to find a way out

Your argument is that his solution to THE BOX is to very lightly, with a fairy's touch, denounce your town read and then "good guying" Ekko, who I am presuming from your PoV in this scenario is town?

If Ekko is town why not play into what you/Magic are doing beating the stuffing out of him? Would be strategically neglectful to not try and push the envelope a bit.

And as a general extension what do you think his strategy here has been because I haven't noticed him making any big leaps in assumption or contributing to the solve on a way that is misdirecting.

Finally, you're neglecting an important aspect of scum CP - he gets demotivated rather easily. I've seen it countless times, and this situation would 100% qualify as an excuse for him to wanna pitch it in and fuck off. Instead he seems pretty normal. Minor detail, but goes along way, the reverse is also true for those who had genuine reaction/celebration to the Sky thing rather than immediately folding into the next topic

He has barely done anything Ultra. I give you all of this but your point is self-contradictory - you argue he would be pushing to get himself out of the box while also arguing he would be demotivated, when being demotivated is a perfectly reasonable explanation to not bother really trying to get himself out of "the box"

 

[Doddsy]

Thank you resident expert and prime lynch candidate Doddsy who is looking for anything he could possibly grab into as life support!

It's irrelevant to my lynching, I've played with CP for 14 years

 

[Flower]

I'm willing to reread him and give him a fair shake but I am not strongly convinced. He's in the table of course since his interactions with Sky don't even exist, I would like to give him another day. I've seen hints of insight that seem more likely to come from town CP who is genuinely helpful

The issue I have with him is he's not even CP'ing. Have you ever seen a Town CP not immediately trying to read Psychic?

 

[Emil]

Yeah there's no fucking way Kurumi ragequits after Sky's death but is also town

why can't she?

 

[Ultra]

It's irrelevant to my lynching, I've played with CP for 14 years

You could be married to him and I would still trust my own assessment over his recent score of scum behavior

 

[GoddessBlade]

why can't she?

Ekko, I'm not going to support your inability to use your own brain any longer.

 

[Doddsy]

You could be married to him and I would still trust my own assessment over his recent score of scum behavior

Well I'm down if he is

 

[Aurelian]

Wrestling Game. And I'm not a full Vig. The daykill was my only ability.

Did you claim vig though after Sky's killing?

 

[Lord Melkor]

@Lord Melkor vote count please.

I am in work so you may need to wait a bit.

Someone could be nice and check from the last vote count i threadmarked.

 

[Flower]

Actually thinking Psychic is the Townier one in their one interaction they had since she was seemingly irritated at him calling her a queen and buddying her for no reason.

 

[Ultra]

The issue I have with him is he's not even CP'ing. Have you ever seen a Town CP not immediately trying to read Psychic?

This is the angle he was caught over last game, he wouldn't be unconscious of it

 

[Flower]

Did you claim vig though after Sky's killing?

No.