• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Game Ranked The Traitors Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.

hime

Exceptional
Pronouns
She/Her
uh huh no u dont get to say that ^^

if me and psychic r scum we'd recruit nat then mislynch u and aurelian with the support of ultra and sheph

ur contention was psychic in n1 kills players who suspect her, which r magic and cp. that shud also mean she will kill u or nat or aurelian as u guys voted for her, OR she can recruit one of you

in your world view, you should always busdrive one of you three (aurelian hime nat) with one of us 2 (me, psychic), that way if we recruited or shot you guys it goes back to us

you are scum. end of
u keep saying u and psychic r scum together yet i have never pushed that narrative :blobtimistic
psychic never recruits us 3 here, esp not me bc i have said many times i would not accept

she most likely tries to recruit u here as it does not change ur read of her nor ur current reads most likely and u will continue pushing lynches on those who scum read her
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
Okay, tell me the negative tradeoff. Cause town can pass the shield however we like, and the fact that Susopp had it N1 doesn't not influence that whatsoever. Neither does whoever had it N2.


Refer to post below. And also answer why you considered Richard and Magic for shield when they were in your scum reads.
they were not please refer to my read list

i said multiple times in day 2 magic became a town read while poyser became a scum read

as for richard, i said multiple times i belive his claim because i am a 2x watcher and i assumed he is the role that town gets when recruits become available

tpein said town gets invest roles to combat recruits. this sound like richard's n3+ voyeru role, so wanted to also make sure he is safe

basically all my strongest town reads from my read list
magic
ultra
sheph

richard was more null but i belived his claim and wanted to give him a chance to confirm it in n3. also i scum read poyser and thought he and richard cant be a team (before poyser flipepd)

this is the read list for reference.
my post that got deleted from yesterday

will make modifications later

2. @Richard Mille - null, never team with poyser. i belive the claim to be true, but i dont know if its town or mafia voyeur. need more gamesolving. so far is focused at forming town reads but not much attention given towards scum reads. his scum read of sheph turned into town core, his scum read of goth remains. never played with him so dont know his town/scum ranges but doesnt seem to be new player. still null sadly. dont see anything to warrant pushing towards town or scum heavily. need more pressure

3. @Goth Boy - null/town. weak town read for seeming lack of agenda and too many derps. as scum midnight shades players a bit and doesnt bother trying to clear them, and is more concerned about his wellbeing. he seems more townie here. need some pressure.

4. @Hans Tweetenberg - null. seems to overreact a bit vs poyser. also his play being slightly different from last game doesnt mean anything as he wud be intentionally aware to shift up his playstyle to not be sused again obviously. need to see more solving. pressure.

5. @Shepard - weak town, since most other players r null i think sheph is just town here. i need more town reads.

7. @Aurelian - null/town. tone is townie, content hoenstly lean scum. i dont know why out himself and hime, dont see much agenda there and checks out with when he revealed tracker in wresling wars. lean town side of null

8. @Ultra - town. strongest town read. RDK lynch sucked but doesnt change my read of ultra. man is atleast trying to do something for bunch of ingrateful inactive lazy ingenuine town

9. @Poyser - null/scum, never team with richard nor tweet imo. MAYBE low chance team with magic, one of them will have to die and the other goes to end game. if tweet is scum poyser town probably? that aside, poysers posts day 1 were townie. day 2 were enlarging PoE a bit. in his defense he is behind on thread so there is that

11. @Magic - null/town, solving the game more than most enough to put him town even if i dont agree with some of his takes. i want more town reads so happy to add him as town for now

13. @Psychic - town, my thoughts on her already public. i think town cuz i *hope* i know her meta by now

14. @Natalija - null/scum, one of her and hime is scum most likely. nat is the most ingenuine player in thread rn. whether it is on purpose so she stays alive longer as a PR or because she is scum doesnt change the fact that she is ingenuine

15. @Lethal - null/scum, dont agree with lots of his posts, particularly the scum read of me. seems to town read me now and tried working with me a bit earlier. hes just firmly PoE

16. @hime - null/scum, dont think she is a team with nat, but one of them is likely scum and im having hard time identifying who exactly as they both are playing scummy. hime is solving the game more mechanically than threadplay wise, and is leaning more towards sheeping than original thoughts. i dont have good indication of her town play cuz i dont remember it but ultra vouching for her so probably town and nat scum
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
u keep saying u and psychic r scum together yet i have never pushed that narrative :blobtimistic
psychic never recruits us 3 here, esp not me bc i have said many times i would not accept

she most likely tries to recruit u here as it does not change ur read of her nor ur current reads most likely and u will continue pushing lynches on those who scum read her
fair point, but i rejected the recruitment as confirmed by the WUs

psychic doesnt have to recruit me cuz im already defending her in thread. she'd better of kill or recruit someone that is against her

u guys recruited me cuz i said i will join and u wanted to get me off your back. u guys recruiting me makes far more sense than psychic

lastly stop phoning in this scum read. if u think me and psychic are not a team and u think i am town u wont be reluctant to work with me in this fashion. if u think i am scum u wont be voting psychic instead of me.

u got yourself caught in a tricky situation and cannot move forward

there are some town motives to abstaining, but u have not helped me see u employ any of them. you are scum.
 

Natalija

Divine Departure
You are just hell bent on being as daft as fucking possible aren't you - I've made my point, the discussion is over, and should be over, and if it isn't there's no hope for this town
And you're uncooperative AND stubborn, don't cry to me if you are town and we lose

they were not please refer to my read list

i said multiple times in day 2 magic became a town read while poyser became a scum read

as for richard, i said multiple times i belive his claim because i am a 2x watcher and i assumed he is the role that town gets when recruits become available

tpein said town gets invest roles to combat recruits. this sound like richard's n3+ voyeru role, so wanted to also make sure he is safe

basically all my strongest town reads from my read list
magic
ultra
sheph

richard was more null but i belived his claim and wanted to give him a chance to confirm it in n3. also i scum read poyser and thought he and richard cant be a team (before poyser flipepd)

this is the read list for reference.
I should refer to the read list you posted after Poy's flip? Lmao get out of here.

I'm talking about D1 - since N1 you had the shield and had to pass it onto someone. D1 they were both among your scum reads.
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
You are just hell bent on being as daft as fucking possible aren't you - I've made my point, the discussion is over, and should be over, and if it isn't there's no hope for this town
idk why u still waste time with nat lol

i gave up trying to convince her

thankfully we have enough townies that her vote doesnt matter

i was so worried u or sheph wud be converted

mafia threw with that decision
 

hime

Exceptional
Pronouns
She/Her
fair point, but i rejected the recruitment as confirmed by the WUs

psychic doesnt have to recruit me cuz im already defending her in thread. she'd better of kill or recruit someone that is against her

u guys recruited me cuz i said i will join and u wanted to get me off your back. u guys recruiting me makes far more sense than psychic

lastly stop phoning in this scum read. if u think me and psychic are not a team and u think i am town u wont be reluctant to work with me in this fashion. if u think i am scum u wont be voting psychic instead of me.

u got yourself caught in a tricky situation and cannot move forward

there are some town motives to abstaining, but u have not helped me see u employ any of them. you are scum.
psychic recruits u *bc* u r defending her in the thread
if she recruits someone pushing her and we see a recruit in the wu and someone stops pushing her, then thats sus
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
And you're uncooperative AND stubborn, don't cry to me if you are town and we lose


I should refer to the read list you posted after Poy's flip? Lmao get out of here.

I'm talking about D1 - since N1 you had the shield and had to pass it onto someone. D1 they were both among your scum reads.
that read list was posted end of day 2, the exact list and got deleted

you dont have to refer to it, i have posts in day 2 that say the exact thing in the read list. the list is basically a compilation of my thoughts
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
@Natalija i did not have to pass the shield n1 no.

n1 i got it and it protected me

i had to pass it after RDK's flip, so end of day 2
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
And you're uncooperative AND stubborn, don't cry to me if you are town and we lose


I should refer to the read list you posted after Poy's flip? Lmao get out of here.

I'm talking about D1 - since N1 you had the shield and had to pass it onto someone. D1 they were both among your scum reads.

I'm still picking my jaw up off the floor seeing how you've navigated this - just showing absolutely no subtlety or even an attempt at using that organ between your ears. Holy fuck.
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
idk why u still waste time with nat lol

i gave up trying to convince her

thankfully we have enough townies that her vote doesnt matter

i was so worried u or sheph wud be converted

mafia threw with that decision

Really?

Seems most likely they'd go for a claimed power role or something
 

Natalija

Divine Departure
I'm still picking my jaw up off the floor seeing how you've navigated this - just showing absolutely no subtlety or even an attempt at using that organ between your ears. Holy fuck.
Who had it before doesn't matter whatsoever, and I stand by that.
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
psychic recruits u *bc* u r defending her in the thread
if she recruits someone pushing her and we see a recruit in the wu and someone stops pushing her, then thats sus
u dont belive this AT ALL

the best value out of recruit is to either

1. recruit a player not in threat of being lynched, so ultra/sheph
2. recruit a player who is opposing you and want to lynch you. in this case psychic would recruit you, aurelian, or nat such that even if you guys lynched her, you will get insane town cred to win the game

if psychic recruited me and she flipped scum then i simply get lynched right after her. this is STUPID. no other explanation.

i am already defending her in thread. she does NOT need to recruit me and create an association between us. if anything my flipping town looks much better for her than me flipping scum. i am a free mislynch if she is scum
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
psychic recruits u *bc* u r defending her in the thread
if she recruits someone pushing her and we see a recruit in the wu and someone stops pushing her, then thats sus

Uh, no.

If you're suspected scum, you recruit someone on your case, and preferably someone who nobody suspects, you don't recruit a townie who is +1'ing you every step of the way already. That's just strategically optimal - scum have to pass a certain threshold to victory and the faster they can get there the better. You can argue otherwise, but it would be WIFOM after that point onwards.
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
Really?

Seems most likely they'd go for a claimed power role or something
the reason for that is u and sheph wud never vote for me, and will be willing to vote for aurelian and bounce ideas with me

u r the last genuine players i have left to play with, in addition to tweet and richard if they r town

i watched richard instead of you guys in n3 because i ASSUMED he will voyeur one of u guys or me, that way we get more ground covered if mafia try to mess, kill, or convert our newly unlocked voyeur i will see it, while the voyer checks you/sheph/me, while als the person i gave the shield to will shield another one of us. that was the best play to cover most ground
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
Who had it before doesn't matter whatsoever, and I stand by that.

:dumbpepe

Forget it - probably doesn't matter.

There's one quote I brought up from Psychic that you never responded to. I'll just put my cards on the table and then tell me what you think of it:

Votes.
@Ekkologix > Indigo
@Richard Mille > Indigo
@Goth Boy > Indigo
@Shepard > Indigo
@Ultra > Indigo
@Psychic > Indigo
@Lethal > Indigo
@hime > psychic
@Hans Tweetenberg > Psychic
@Poyser > psychic
@Magic > Psychic

@Aurelian > Psychic
@Natalija > Natalija
@Indigo > Ultra

Actually since me and Indigo are both town, mafia votes are scattered.
Highly sus on hime though. Her gameplay and thought process made absolutely no sense this game.
wanting to lynch someone who was baiting mafia.
Only wanted to lynch me after Magic push for my lynch.
Her wanting to lynch Ekko regardless of whether he was town or mafia.
I mean if she's town, she's just a detriment.

Vote lynch hime

This post came 5 minutes after the day started. Most likely, it was already prewritten.
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
Of course, I still have no clue why you'd make Magic one of your "candidates" when end of day 2, you still were putting him in a scum team with me.
he was literally in my town reads ffs

how many posts of "i like poyser and hime less and magic more in day 2" do u need lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top