Game Ranked Tower of God Mafia Thread

[MangoSenpai]

i can assure you there was nothing disingenious about my point and it was pretty spot on. what ratchet was doing is much more likely to be buddying than what melkor was doing as buddying.

I don't know, I am not buying that narrative you're selling.

But by all means, if later down the line you have more evidence to support the narrative where Ratchet is doing what he's doing to be scum driven I might give it a re-evaluation, but as things stand with this discussion in a vaccuum, I am unfortunately finding myself on the side of Ratchet here.

And that is not because he's "defending" me, but rather he is pointing out things that I agree with.
I am of course biased here, but I find it hard to see why Ratchet would bother pointing out these minute details as scum when he could instead build upon your angle to create a mislynch down the line.

The argument against this would obviously be that since Ratchet is an "expert" in reading me, once he reads me wrong I would know something was up.
But at that point I would have to fight an uphill battle versus Ratchet who alleges that he can read me quite well, to prove my innocense. I think Ratchet would have a great advantage in this scenario.

 

[Ratchet]

should mango not be weary of town reading you?

do tell.

LMAO

That can't be what you take from that post. I don't really care how Mango reads me, I care about you trying to get ahead of it when there wasn't satisfactory reason to do so. That's only one part of the issue though, another one being that you seem to be caught in two minds as to what you want your position to actually be.

 

[MangoSenpai]

Not sure about Ratchet yet, wondering though what would be scum Ratchet's motivation of voting Magic instead of me, since I should be easier target.

That's because it wasn't about you or your vote, this whole discussion came from Magic misrepresenting my post adressing your post.

I said that your post would be an example of what Ratchet said I wasn't doing - not to say what you were doing was scum motivated - but rather a black on white example of what my post was not.

 

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

to the extent that if ratchet is scum youre essentially already pocketed based on your own behaviour here lol.

If he's in Ratchet's pocket, I understand that you have Mango as villager

 

[Flower]

Ratchet: Polar Bear
Aurelian: Ratchet
Lord Melkor: Luka
Luka: Luka >
Mango: Ratchet

Ratchet: 2
Luka/Polar Bear: 1

With 26 alive it's 14 to lynch.

Luka looks town



I'm saying it's unnecessary explanation. Scum have a habit of announcing pointless periods where they won't be present or excuses for not playing up to par(not saying town never does this but it's more typical of scum). They'll announce they're going to be away but not to worry because they'll be productive upon arrival! It's pre-emptively defending themselves as their sole motive is to survive.

Fucked the vote so

vote ruffles

I mean I can definitely vote this way to put pressure, but I think that this is in NAI territory as I could see town do this too - as they announce they've seen the game started but can't participate fully just yet

Vote Lynch Ruffles

Good entrance from Magic.

Vote Lynch Ruffles

Vote Lynch Lord Melkor

I am very busy

Page one tells me a story giving me the chills, so
Vote lynch Luka

I'm not up in arms about your accusation, I'm saying that your point isn't tracking. This is yet again misrepresentation of the discussion. It's not about defending Mango, it's attacking you.

Vote: Magic

Ratchet: Polar Bear > Magic
Aurelian: Ratchet
Lord Melkor: Luka > Ruffles
Luka: Luka > Lord Melkor
Mango: Ratchet > Ruffles
Magic: Ruffles
Ichigo: Luka

Ruffles: 3
Luka/Magic/Lord Melkor/Ratchet: 1

With 26 alive it‘s 14 to lynch.

 

[Ruffles]

Alright so I don't really have this familiarity with the players because I never play this so I'm about to have a lot of questions

Before that though...
What does NAI mean?

 

[Grammaton]

I think magic’s points are just fine in that exchange and find ratchets vote a tad performative

 

[Luka]

Because I don't like these subtle shades you're throwing so early when Mel is usually a self-resolving slot and him being auto scum read by the majority of players makes him a prime lynch candidate. It's easy.

It's not that the act of what you're doing is incredibly shady (town can pull this shit to, but if I ask myself "why Mel? Why is someone going after Melkor?" it's, in my experience, usually a bad sign

You're coming across as mighty opportunistic
If it were, say, anyone else I wouldn't blink an eye (or at least not players that are not historically LHF)

One point in your favor of you actually generating content and giving dialogue, tho

Right so back to my original question
So that's one scum read
What are your other reads, 2 townie reads? 1 more scum 1, 1 town read? Name em

The shade shouldn't be suddle, that must be my mistake. I think Melkor is sucm, that help?
I stated that I think that Mango and Ratchet are town, I stated that I think that Melkor is wolf. If you were genuinly reading me that much should be obvious, and I do not know Melkors meta. I have not played on this forum for around 3 months, I have not played with him in a while as well. What's the point of accusing me for accusing another player, and that player being, as mentioned by others; normally LHF? Which, for the record, you yourself admit. Granted, this post does do one thing. Add one more player to my scum pile.

 

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

Alright so I don't really have this familiarity with the players because I never play this so I'm about to have a lot of questions

Before that though...
What does NAI mean?

Non Alignment Indicative

 

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

I think magic’s points are just fine in that exchange and find ratchets vote a tad performative

Ratchet is always performative, I don't think that's a scum tell

 

[Grammaton]

Because I don't like these subtle shades you're throwing so early when Mel is usually a self-resolving slot and him being auto scum read by the majority of players makes him a prime lynch candidate. It's easy.

It's not that the act of what you're doing is incredibly shady (town can pull this shit to, but if I ask myself "why Mel? Why is someone going after Melkor?" it's, in my experience, usually a bad sign

You're coming across as mighty opportunistic
If it were, say, anyone else I wouldn't blink an eye (or at least not players that are not historically LHF)

One point in your favor of you actually generating content and giving dialogue, tho

Right so back to my original question
So that's one scum read
What are your other reads, 2 townie reads? 1 more scum 1, 1 town read? Name em

Er I don’t think any of this is particularly persuasive

 

[Grammaton]

Ratchet is always performative, I don't think that's a scum tell

Er thanks

 

[Grammaton]

@Magic why is Watson town to you?

 

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

Er thanks

why are you thanking me?

 

[Ruffles]

Is Magic known for being aggressive in these games

 

[Grammaton]

why are you thanking me?

Cause you gave me something I didn’t ask for, seemed rude not to

 

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

Cause you gave me something I didn’t ask for, seemed rude not to

It seemed to me that you want to say that performative would be something bad

 

[MangoSenpai]

I think magic’s points are just fine in that exchange and find ratchets vote a tad performative

That's quite a lukewarm take, surely that's not all the interatctions have left you with?

Do you have any any thoughts on who is looking good/ bad in the interaction, if any?

 

[Grammaton]

That's quite a lukewarm take, surely that's not all the interatctions have left you with?

Do you have any any thoughts on who is looking good/ bad in the interaction, if any?

At this stage, not really, certainly from an alignment pov

 

[Grammaton]

It seemed to me that you want to say that performative would be something bad

And the reason this would bother you is?