- Status
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Vanilla
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Don't know how only townies got killed
Ok.
The thing is you watched someone who was a bus drive target.
It's consistent, at least possibly, because whoever Poyser bus drove to (perhaps Ratchet) you would also see was only targeted by Poyser.
But we had 3 kills so it begs the question of why there's an additional unclaimed shit in play woof
Well given Gram's philosophy on bussing what do you think he'd tell his teammates to do.
Nonetheless Gram is quickly becoming a concern with my observation that he's never voted, which probably has some implication. Woof
Imposter
Illustrious
What benefit would be have to clear me as scum
Well snap. What's prompted you to come swinging out the gates this phase?
Well that wouldn't hold up if there is a dedicated vig
I'm Jake Moon, x-shot Bodyguard. Have history as one. Alfie's cousin, Danny's brother. I protected T-Pein N2
I feel like the intervention of blocking Pein also kind of speaks for itself. If these 3 are all town, no reason to use a block, and apparently Craig went unchecked:
Woof
Woof
What you're missing is that if Craig were redirected for example, the redirection would have been moved to me (let us assume the target was me). Which means Imposter is either Godfather, Lawyered or Town. It also means that scum either had no remaining counter play to the Cop, or did and chose not to use it, which would require them to be confident that whomever he target would either be as false result or easily discreditable. Food for thought.
Is this the definition of bodyguard that is equivalent to Doctor or is it the one where you die in his place if shot, woof?
Ah, slight mistake here Ultra. While your conclusion is within reason, they could have also blocked Pein anticipating that Xenos would shoot him, in other words it's clearing one of the town clears off via the SK. So there is reason to use the block even if all 3 of those are town. Plausible, even, though I certainly wouldn't bet the game on it.
Basically if the outcome is the same (a townie dies) then if they're fine with leaving the Cop unblocked they obviously stand to gain by leaving those three alive (if only to make the same argument that you just made) *and* get the SK killing Pein for almost free. Does that make sense @Ultra?
Kinda.
The thing is I think "fine with leaving the cop unblocked" requires quite a few assumptions. If they're a team of 5 they may have 1-2 means of investigation protection on any give night on average. So that doesn't completely mesh with me. And their regular means of manipulation may be interfered with by Bus Drive. So it does demand either a Block or a Strongman on Craig. So I think my conclusion is still slightly favorable. That or CP is scum woof. I can concede it's not super duper informative though.
Well if you take TAT's results as the truth, then CP can't have been blocked/redirected (or attempted to be blocked) by anyone. Unless the blocker also carries a Ninja modifier, I suppose, but I don't think that is at all likely. In light of this evidence if you don't doubt the claims (I'm not saying you don't) then the only plausible explanation left is that scum were fine with Craig taking a shot.
Actually, small correction - Scum could also have come to the conclusion that everyone is 2-shot and assumed Craig has nothing left. This is *still* a gamble anyway, which would on some level require them to be okay with Craig investigating undisturbed, but it's not quite so absolute as it could have been them weighing up the odds and taking a risk.
- Status