Game Unranked Archived Fairy Tail Mafia - The Dawn of Fiore [Main Game Thread] (Game Ended - Zeref Dragneel and Acnologia have won the game)
- Thread starter Emil
- Start date
- Status
Dr_Professor83
Professional Troll
Also while we at it I have no VP today lol
So here is my issue. Night 1 I investigated you, and received that you were Sting (I get alignment, and if I win a GMG the previous phase I get the role). I also took another action that I know landed on my target, so I can rule out being redirected completely.
Obviously, Aurelian flipped Sting. This means that you were busdriven Night 1 with a townie. Now I'll give some time for a townie to claim this, because it's not impossible that town swapped you two around, but I think it leans towards being less likely given both the choice of targets, and that neither you nor Aurelian were responsible for the busdrive.
Kobe
Paramount
I don't need more reasons than referring to your posts, which does not make sense to me. You came forward with this BP claim after N1, conveniently shielding yourself. Then, you are doubling down on the claim with another "I was shot" narrative when there are 3 other kills in N2. What am I supposed to make out of this? As the one who was fed with this information, I think resolving your spot *anyhow* makes sense, don't you think? You don't seem to be all that powerful either judging by the lack of other action claims on your behalf.
Remind you again that you were the one who came forward with possible red scum names, suggesting that the killer is one among them. That looks TMI to me, than anything else.
The reason I know when I'm shot is that I lose several aspects of my role when I do so - it's because I'm very very hard to kill. It comes back after a cycle, but I couldn't investigate anyone N2, and I won't be able to N3 either.
Dr_Professor83
Professional Troll
Well. I had nothing to do with it.
I feel like my voting/pushes should clear me of both mafias.
TSworder
Majin
Can you win with town?
So your argument is you need to lynch me today because I claimed, under no pressure, that I wasn't shot? It's not a very good argument. TMI is invoked lazily here - only certain roles should have been able to land a kill on me N1, those I listed. You've yet to establish basic aspects of this, such as motive, and your reasoning to suggest I must be resolved today isn't very well thought through.
Dr_Professor83
Professional Troll
^ lynch this if I die. Dying wish
Thoughts on Kobe's arguments on this page?
Kobe
Paramount
What was your reasoning for vigging Ruffles?
Dr_Professor83
Professional Troll
Haven’t read it lol
Dr_Professor83
Professional Troll
Inactive safe shot that I thought could be scum and if not not a huge loss. Planned to just tear through inactives unless I had something I thought was a really good shot
He is probably the only player I'm willing to lynch over you at this point, for the reasoning I lay out (I think his argument that I must be lynched today is scum motivated due to it not actually being important information that needs to be resolved).
Dr_Professor83
Professional Troll
I read it. I don’t support lynching Ratchet lol
Kobe
Paramount
You said that you would resolve your spot in D3, and yet you haven't. All I hear is "I was shot, I'm innocent", yet there is no proof of that being the case. You claim to be BP passive, but you have no active actions? No 1-shot? You should be SS at the very least based on your performance in the magic games. You don't seem honest by this defense on yourself.
I'm more interested in the possibility of him being scum here. I'm not concerned about being lynched, as I don't think it's at all a position that's supportable here, but I want to check myself on the motivation behind it. Does knowing whether I survived a kill or not matter so much today as to base the lynch around it? I don't think so.
I haven't because I was shot again. If you've read this page, you will know I have more than one active, I'll let you catch up first.
- Status