Game Ranked The Traitors Mafia

[Ultra]

vote lynch poyser

@Ultra u down?

That's going nowhere. After RDK flips scum he'll be put into play.

Ftr I'm not scum reading nearly as hard as RDK. But I do think he's getting a fair degree of less scrutiny than he deserves. Unfortunately his behavior is rewarded with absolute and complete veneration - he suffers 0 consequence for almost anything he does so if nothing else it's more pragmatic to just kick the can down the road, truth be told. You know what I'm talking about.

 

[Emil]

his overt focus on me as scum day 1 and tunnelling is akin to his town game, although i dont really have a scum game for reference.

and he's mostly tried lynching the same 3 people. rdk, yourself, and myself. that said i dont think those really should be the 3 his focus is still on as that wouldn't really make sense anymore.

right @Ekkologix

my suspicion of RDK is mostly today/EoD1

i still scum read richard and lethal to certain degree. and now scum read hime and poyser as well but weaker

and do not town read aurelian

thread runs in circles with u and nat, down to move elsewhere, but not for what nat did, but rather the lack of any movement from the other players

 

[Emil]

She seemed to imply her play was intentional and I was trying to lead her into a discussion to demonstrate that.

If she's faking a role, then she makes that post to backfill reasoning e.g. "See guys! This is why I was so scummy!" I'm inviting her to show me this and see if it checks out.

also her result on magic was "hes town" ?

why not innocent or guilty

also could he be godfather... or simply her teammate

lastly... why not check me as im her biggest scum read. with a result she can lynch me properly, otherwise im never getting lynched this game. she didnt even scum read magic

actually me and magic cant be in the same team. in what world she scum reads me and checks him...

 

[Emil]

but i guess we need to suck it up and reward shitty and lazy town play? is that the only way to win in this site?

 

[Emil]

That's going nowhere. After RDK flips scum he'll be put into play.

Ftr I'm not scum reading nearly as hard as RDK. But I do think he's getting a fair degree of less scrutiny than he deserves. Unfortunately his behavior is rewarded with absolute and complete veneration - he suffers 0 consequence for almost anything he does so if nothing else it's more pragmatic to just kick the can down the road, truth be told. You know what I'm talking about.

do u think poyser kills cp btw? wifom speaking that kill doesnt benefit him. might be reverse psychology etc..

 

[Emil]

@Magic if possible can u make 1 post with all of ur town reads in order from strongest to weakest and why for each one please

 

[Ultra]

also her result on magic was "hes town" ?

why not innocent or guilty

also could he be godfather... or simply her teammate

lastly... why not check me as im her biggest scum read. with a result she can lynch me properly, otherwise im never getting lynched this game. she didnt even scum read magic

actually me and magic cant be in the same team. in what world she scum reads me and checks him...

As someone who came into today thinking both Nat and Magic were suspicious, my initial thought to Nat claiming to have exactly one innocent read on Magic was "of course". Magic and Poyser both expressed scum reads of Nat early into Day 2 and when it came to crunch time never voted for her, and I am surprised at which the speed Magic has accepted her claim.

However, by default, I still tend to err on the side of caution here and say there's no need to full send and deny potential information here. I was actually inviting Nat to bridge the gap by explaining her perspective and she responded like I was speaking japanese. It's tiresome.

 

[Emil]

Predictable and linear which is scummy and agenda based.

Your past games here have been far less calculated and trolly which I think has gotten you mislynched a few times. This is night and day.

I'm not saying it makes you definitely scum because it doesn't, I have games I can't get into much as town too and get mislynched and then I have town games where I'm on it and very focused. This isn't one of them unfortunately

who do u have as ur top 3 scum rn, with reasoning pls

 

[Ultra]

do u think poyser kills cp btw? wifom speaking that kill doesnt benefit him. might be reverse psychology etc..

Actually CP agreed with me very early on that Poyser seemed a bit off lol

But you should know by now I don't put too much stock into individual NK's, by nature they're extremely subjective. I think over the course of a game sometimes a pattern starts to emerge, but it would be dishonest to stick this against Poyser. If he's scum that should be able to be surmised by his play.

 

[Rej]

@Richard Mille @RDK @Poyser @hime

can i have ur thoughts on each other pls

all 3 are town

 

[Goth Boy]

@Richard Mille @RDK @Poyser @hime

can i have ur thoughts on each other pls

All sus

 

[Ultra]

all 3 are town

All sus

The duality of man

 

[Emil]

Actually CP agreed with me very early on that Poyser seemed a bit off lol

But you should know by now I don't put too much stock into individual NK's, by nature they're extremely subjective. I think over the course of a game sometimes a pattern starts to emerge, but it would be dishonest to stick this against Poyser. If he's scum that should be able to be surmised by his play.

i think CP wanted to shield poyser later on

went from agreeing with us and scum reading poyser (from as early as poyser not replying to magic's post) to reverse the read and start reading poyser townie to wanting to shield him

i thought the kill is probably sub optimal to be done by posyer unless CP was maybe onto poyser's mates which in this instance can be richard and RDK?

 

[Emil]

all 3 are town

who do u have as scum rn. top 3 with reasons pls

 

[Emil]

poyser rdk lethal
poyser rdk hime
poyser rdk richard - maybe not?
poyser rdk goth/psychic

these can fit the most with them

 

[Ultra]

i think CP wanted to shield poyser later on

went from agreeing with us and scum reading poyser (from as early as poyser not replying to magic's post) to reverse the read and start reading poyser townie to wanting to shield him

i thought the kill is probably sub optimal to be done by posyer unless CP was maybe onto poyser's mates which in this instance can be richard and RDK?

Maybe!

 

[Emil]

actually dont think poyser is solving as much as trying to cause confusion / expand PoE

also latching onto things like magic not voting nat and my watcher target is a bit opportunistic. hime falls under the latter as well. the problem here is the left it hanging without really giving a read on us to end their posts with

 

[Emil]

Maybe!

richard might be lynch bait. poyser/rdk/hime or poyser/rdk/lethal seems more legit

 

[Emil]

All sus

want to lynch any of them? would u join us to yeet RDK and poyser?

 

[Ultra]

richard might be lynch bait. poyser/rdk/hime or poyser/rdk/lethal seems more legit

I'm not sure about Lethal but I did have a thought on Poyser's early call on Aurelian being a bit premature. He's not ducking the thread like he tends to do, but he actually has a town tell that he hasn't demonstrated yet which I won't disclose for observational purposes