• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Ranked One Piece Wano Arc

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Ratchet

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
Test
I don't think this is close to SRM lol. Has Craig even played one of those?

Anyway @Lord Melkor I probably would have avoided giving scum the same role straight up as town, especially a role like bodyguard which is typically a town role, but that's the only issue I can see. I don't think it needs to be an absolute rule, but if you're going that direction maybe make sure Mafia have something else safe they can claim. Honestly don't think they needed bodyguard at all.

Will need to deliberate the rest. Can you add me to dead/scum chats please.
 
T-Pein™

T-Pein™

The Nexus
Pronouns
They/Them
Magic said:
i did not play scummy at all.

you dumb fucks acknowledge my scum play is pro-sided when my scum play is based on my town play. i look for town and try to clear town.

you read me as scum for not wanting a duel. that isn't even alignment indicative, it's how i view(and ratchet) view the role should be utilized to avoid unnecessary risk.
Click to expand...

you got lynched by everyone.
not ekko nor me alone.
 
Lord Melkor

Lord Melkor

Exceptional
Ekkologix said:
king can claim law, busdriver. its a solid af claim. sux cp had no flavor knowledge
Click to expand...

Kurumi and GB had flavour knowledge.

I think Usopp was also solid claim for King, since tracker fits.

I think CP and GB actually had a chance to win this if GB approached her claim differently and they managed to janitor the watcher as was CP"s plan, so his role could clear him.

CP also forgot to use his day rolecop last day, it could help him identify Ultra as watcher for the janitor.
 
Emil

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
can i see ichigo's role? how did he mistake it for a bodyguard

nontheless claiming a flipped scum role is suicide on its own lol
 
Emil

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
Lord Melkor said:
Kurumi and GB had flavour knowledge.

I think Usopp was also solid claim for King, since tracker fits.

I think CP and GB actually had a chance to win this if GB approached her claim differently and they managed to janitor the watcher as was CP"s plan, so his role could clear him.

CP also forgot to use his day rolecop last day, it could help him identify Ultra as watcher for the janitor.
Click to expand...
usopp as fake claim is no bueno melkor :susdog:
 
Ratchet

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
Test
Magic said:
you had much better reads than me despite that. i had the game pretty close to solve by post 666 and then fell apart with the interactions. largely because it's hard to reconcile some of the shit that is spewed at me.
Click to expand...
Having been in the position though I know how tough it was. Usually it tends to be fairly easy to see who is genuine and who is not in their suspicion but it really was hard to get there. Scum obviously deserve some props for that. Some members of the town certainly didn't help. Honestly the part I'm most disappointed in is not sticking to my town read on you Day 2, it's something that's clearly a flaw in my play that I need to just get past somehow.
 
Magic

Magic

Resplendent
T-Pein™ said:
you got lynched by everyone.
not ekko nor me alone.
Click to expand...
outside of the bottom line that was addressed generally.

some of you also accuse me of poor scum play despite 1) my scum teams never really performing poorly while im alive 2) i am suspected and have been suspected in every single one of my town games without fail.
 
Ultra

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
Mafia Beast
Magic said:
i did not play scummy at all.

you dumb fucks acknowledge my scum play is pro-sided when my scum play is based on my town play. i look for town and try to clear town.

you read me as scum for not wanting a duel. that isn't even alignment indicative, it's how i view(and ratchet) view the role should be utilized to avoid unnecessary risk.
Click to expand...

This is probably also the exact angle of argument you would use assuming you were scum.

Anyway I think you got a bit jinxed. From my perspective, I saw you push a lot of townies in a row that ended up being nothingburgers enough to earn distrust. What happened is you had most mafia in your immediate PoE but didn't really end up following up and got caught in the dust of a dirty bus.
 
Lord Melkor

Lord Melkor

Exceptional
Ekkologix said:
can i see ichigo's role? how did he mistake it for a bodyguard

nontheless claiming a flipped scum role is suicide on its own lol
Click to expand...

I posted document with all roles, but here is the Marco's one:

Congrats Kurosaki, Ichigo, you are Marco The Phoenix, Wano Alliance Aligned.

Wincon: Eliminate all threats to town

A veteran pirate, you were once the right hand of the World's Strongest Pirate, Whitebeard. Now the time has come for you to retire from piracy, but not before you will help the new generation against the ogre Kaidou, aided by the power of your mythical Phoenix fruit.

Featured-Image-Marco-Going-Phoenix-Cropped.jpg



Active: Martyr Bodyguard - protect a player from immediate kills during the night but the kill will affect you instead.
Passive: Regeneration. You can regenerate from standard kills but in exchange you will be rolecrushed (unable to use your Active and your Passive will be disabled) for the 2 entire following cycles. Your powers will return normally after a 2 cycle cooldown. For example if you are targetted by a kill night 1, you are rolecrushed until night 4.
 
Magic

Magic

Resplendent
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Did she seriously commit sudoku lmao
Click to expand...

no not literally but she randomly killed then claimed the kill despite it not being posted in the thread(which hints towards non-town) then basically came forward saying she can kill nightly which is essentially admitting to being the SK.

just as intended, which is independently.
 
Tempest

Tempest

Leprous Monarch
That role is garbage lol, confirms the person they save AND they don't even die. then you had another townie confirmed by the SK's role PM.
 
Ratchet

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
Test
CraigPelton said:
Nah this was 100% SRM
Click to expand...
No lol, SRM as we know it at least is everyone having 6+ abilities with lynch stops and redirects and revives etc. This isn't anywhere close to that. I should also point out that this is Melkor's second game hosted, and a *huge* improvement over his first. I think I agree it does favour town as is, slightly, but that's about it.
 
Tempest

Tempest

Leprous Monarch
Ratchet said:
No lol, SRM as we know it at least is everyone having 6+ abilities with lynch stops and redirects and revives etc. This isn't anywhere close to that. I should also point out that this is Melkor's second game hosted, and a *huge* improvement over his first. I think I agree it does favour town as is, slightly, but that's about it.
Click to expand...
you're going to extremes to make your point. dismissed.
 
Magic

Magic

Resplendent
Ultra said:
This is probably also the exact angle of argument you would use assuming you were scum.

Anyway I think you got a bit jinxed. From my perspective, I saw you push a lot of townies in a row that ended up being nothingburgers enough to earn distrust. What happened is you had most mafia in your immediate PoE but didn't really end up following up and got caught in the dust of a dirty bus.
Click to expand...
im about 99% certain if i was scum i'd concede what you were getting at that it's a given it's going to happen and try angling it to a town player and saying we should just lynch kurumi.

i was planning to vote sky and just took it as a given kurumi was scum. then instead of being to slow down the duel forced me into adding more suspects, which was bachi(and doddsy although by the end i retracted on both lol).

psychic looked bad for her eod1, bachi looked bad for his interactions on dead scum, and whicker just looked like inactive scum. all 3, maybe outside of psychic, is where everyone else would have likely landed too. much like scum got fucked over by bachi and whicker being auto-town, so did i as it was where i went with my suspicions and then it was like "ya im cop" and "ya im luffy". i had whicker as town(with goddess) until you told me it was too quick and so i(poorly) pulled back on whicker and not goddess.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top