Penguini
The Best Dog
Cake/Vinegar fka Juice
Ranked One Piece Wano Arc
- Thread starter Lord Melkor
- Start date
- Status
My solve day 3 was craig/goddess Ekko. It's what I was arguing for up until Craig claimed tracker. Then I wanted a mass claim.
Magic
Resplendent
ya but it's vexing as mafia to deal with this hyper town-sided indies. it isn't to the spirit of the game at all imo. just play to your own win condition, you're not here for town.
What I'm saying is it has the potential to be a bit silly if unchecked, I'm assuming you're referring to your role, but there's no hard rule that says you can't have dual actions, even in very hardball environments like Mafiascum and such it's allowed. Really dependent on how the roles are balanced. Multiple actions also carry inherent risk, circumstantially.
I didn't start day 3 with this solve of course, took time to get there.
Lord Melkor
Exceptional
Hm....
I gave town some killing power because scum had iron GF, BG and some other tools. There was also Big Mom, that was hard to kill.
I also concentrated town power since there were a lot of vanillas which makes claiming more tricky.
Magic
Resplendent
the counter claim from a martyr/weak bg so it wasn't exactly the same.
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
I'm talking about our conventions for what constitutes ranked. This game was SRM in my view, extremely swingy. I wouldn't have approved the setup as-is.
I feel like we went through hell together this game lol
Lord Melkor
Exceptional
Also, I gave scum list of 9 characters to flavour claim safely, including 3 Strawhats and Law. Also some minor characters having in mind they would fit the VT claims.
Great Potato
Preeminent
Been out of the mafia loop for a while. Thought I had a good D1, but lost the plot a bit afterwards. Didn't expect scum to be willing to off the rest of their squad out of the gate, and clearly there's good reason for that because it made the game virtually unwinnable for them afterwards.
king can claim law, busdriver. its a solid af claim. sux cp had no flavor knowledge
Tempest
Leprous Monarch
it had zero bearing on anything
Magic
Resplendent
i did not play scummy at all.
you dumb fucks acknowledge my scum play is pro-sided when my scum play is based on my town play. i look for town and try to clear town.
you read me as scum for not wanting a duel. that isn't even alignment indicative, it's how i view(and ratchet) view the role should be utilized to avoid unnecessary risk.
Hans Tweetenberg
Exceptional
GGs peeps, guess we're finally figuring out how to hack it together as town
You also gave Luffy/Zoro both the capacity to bypass.
Thing is even if you balance killing roles with equivalent amounts of bulletproofs sometimes you end up with a shooting gallery and the game's pace is dictated around kills and kills failing more than the lynches, which is kind of what happened here. We had access to scum spew right off the bat. Game should mostly revolve around days.
Even if it's properly balanced, makes things more interesting that the focus is more around day time tug of war than actions.
Magic
Resplendent
you had much better reads than me despite that. i had the game pretty close to solve by post 666 and then fell apart with the interactions. largely because it's hard to reconcile some of the shit that is spewed at me.
- Status