Ranked Baki Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.

Aurelian

Titan
Administrator
Decepticon
How is that relevant to this game tho
How isn't it when there's a pattern to you as scum sniping from the sidelines to prep someone when you did it multiple times in the Negima game and tried to do it in the OP one more recently.

It's your meta as scum.
 

Frinckles

Paramount
So we still haven't heard from Lethal and I believe that's all. I'm sure he'll pop in with a red check on Bachi.
 

Hans Tweetenberg

Exceptional
Think that's why he wants me in the game, not out of desperation for players but laziness to help him VC where all he has to do is correct it

Pretty much in line with his "women belong in the kitchen! And the vote counter!"
Did anybody actually ask you to do the VCs? You're free to make yourself more useful than that.
 

xenos5

Objectionable Objection
V.I.P. Member
You voted me only after you were pushed into a corner, your entire reaction and responses have been about shading and discrediting my vote and scum read on your early posts in the thread. You aren't solving only applying busywork fluffposting and setup speculating.

I don't even know where you got the notion I don't have 'confidence' to confront you when I voted you and explained my reasons pretty cleanly. You pivoted instead of bringing anything else simply to defend yourself from being scum read by me.

You are floundering.
Pushed into a corner by one vote? Are you being serious?

How is questioning the reasoning behind a read, not solving? Questioning the motives behind a read, and asking for evidence to back up your statements is Mafia 101.

I don't think you yourself even believed that the way I am in this game is comparable to my Eastender's posting style.

I think you thought it was a cheap excuse you could use to justify a vote on me. You weren't concerned at all if anyone would actually press you on what specific posts in that game were similar to posts from me in this game.

You haven't done anything else besides play defensive and try to defend yourself from being voted at all.

And your reason for scumreading me to start with is based on a faulty comparison that you've refused to attempt to back up because you know you can't. I literally just did the work for you.

I can at least understand suspicion or even a vote on me if the reasoning makes sense. But your reasoning was a faulty meta comparison that doesn't stand up to scrutiny.

There is no reason for me to feel threatened or worried about you bringing up the Jojo game as some kind of gotcha. I don't town read you, so I vote you.

And you scumread me for acting the exact same way as I did in the Jojo game. You know that comparison works better. But that's not the one you brought up because it was inconvenient for the point you wanted to make.

If you actually believed I was acting similarly to the Eastenders game you would've done the bare minimum to try to prove it.

You didn't because you can't.
 

Hans Tweetenberg

Exceptional
It isn’t about the content of the “case” so much as I don’t agree he looks scummy for reasons listed. Low hanging fruit at best
Have you got any experience of playing with the guy to declare him LHF instead of venturing that there might actually be something there that could be scummy?
 

xenos5

Objectionable Objection
V.I.P. Member
I think i'll just go ahead and post the Jojo game thread here. Since i've already brought it up this much.


as well as the search results for my and Fang's posts within that game, to make things easier.


 

Frinckles

Paramount
Here's thinking Aurelian v Xenos is t/t
Decent take.

Guess I can understand a passionate meta argument against Xeno event if it ends up TvT. We've all played those games.

I can't really understand scum!aurelion going so hard on this unless it was purely intentional via mechanics somehow.

And the fact that everyone else is just okay with this boring thunderdome and not solving is crap.
 

Hans Tweetenberg

Exceptional
Decent take.

Guess I can understand a passionate meta argument against Xeno event if it ends up TvT. We've all played those games.

I can't really understand scum!aurelion going so hard on this unless it was purely intentional via mechanics somehow.

And the fact that everyone else is just okay with this boring thunderdome and not solving is crap.
I kinda ge tthe impression that people are already sick of it and glossing over it

Hear that guys, stop it
 

Frinckles

Paramount
I kinda ge tthe impression that people are already sick of it and glossing over it

Hear that guys, stop it
I already told them that this sucks and shouldn't be a d1 thunderdome. I appreciate you opining on it because, while I don't nessecarily agree either side is misrepresenting the other, I can hold you to your words.
 

Aurelian

Titan
Administrator
Decepticon
Pushed into a corner by one vote? Are you being serious?

How is questioning the reasoning behind a read, not solving? Questioning the motives behind a read, and asking for evidence to back up your statements is Mafia 101.

I don't think you yourself even believed that the way I am in this game is comparable to my Eastender's posting style.

I think you thought it was a cheap excuse you could use to justify a vote on me. You weren't concerned at all if anyone would actually press you on what specific posts in that game were similar to posts from me in this game.



And your reason for scumreading me to start with is based on a faulty comparison that you've refused to attempt to back up because you know you can't. I literally just did the work for you.

I can at least understand suspicion or even a vote on me if the reasoning makes sense. But your reasoning was a faulty meta comparison that doesn't stand up to scrutiny.



And you scumread me for acting the exact same way as I did in the Jojo game. You know that comparison works better. But that's not the one you brought up because it was inconvenient for the point you wanted to make.

If you actually believed I was acting similarly to the Eastenders game you would've done the bare minimum to try to prove it.

You didn't because you can't.
I already gave my reasons with quoted posts from you and paralleled that to your slot in the Eastenders game where you were a hostile indie to town. You can pretend that didn't happen if it helps you quote. If you failed to understand that your posts droning about setup spec doesn't get equated with your mindless busywork posts in that game, that isn't my problem.

I can point to the night and day difference in how Magic has engaged in the game with other players vs you doing nothing until I started pressuring you. I also stand by my statement there is scum equity between you with Craig and Sky. And ultimately your defense has to been stall trying to discredit the vote and angleshoot by bringing up a game that didn't happen here while OMGUS voting me.

Don't see any reason to town read you. I'm happy with where my vote is.
 

Hayumi

Illustrious
Have you got any experience of playing with the guy to declare him LHF instead of venturing that there might actually be something there that could be scummy?
I vaguely remember a game or two with him but no I don't have enough knowledge to judge him based off meta or anything like that. But again, after a quick iso of literal 9 posts I disagree he seems scummy and don't see what some are on about. Seems like an easy placeholder.
 

Frinckles

Paramount
Plus old mafia wisdom I was taught years ago
I don't think I misrepresented him at all though.
Okay but clearly you two would prefer the other one gets escorted off a cliff. The other person has 3-4 other scum buddies or whatever the hell this setup is.

On top of that, the only other real noise was me and magic. So. Yeah, we gotta figure shit out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top