• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked EastEnders Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
As for roletrack spec, its not very helpful especially on D1. Its just an odd choice thats worth thinking about, but CP put forth a pretty good counter to what I was saying anyway
I can somewhat see ruling certain people out even if that's a bit dicey too but trying to figure out who would target any given player (besides maybe with a kill) seems a bit of a crapshoot
 
I can somewhat see ruling certain people out even if that's a bit dicey too but trying to figure out who would target any given player (besides maybe with a kill) seems a bit of a crapshoot
Eh, there can be all sorts of WIFOM about why mafia would kill a certain someone. You wouldn't tend to see them roletrack somebody they weren't either wary of or planning to push tho
 
The reservation I have with Tweet here is - why as scum does he claim stump? I understand that this is approaching WIFOM, but with Xenos on the table I feel like basically anything but "lynching me is fine" would be strong enough a claim to at least dissuade some people from wanting his flip, but he chose the one claim that actually invites it. I don't believe this has been given due consideration - it was just tabled and then dismissed.
 
The thing you fail to realize is that saying that somebodys lynch is a foregone conclusion doesn't mean that that lynch therefore has to take place immediately and no other discussion is to take place that day. We knew one of the two indy claims was gonna get offed some 8 hours into the phase, but there's no need to rush it through especially on d1.

Though if I knew most of d1 was gonna be an endless back and forth of what I believe to be two townies I woulda ended it asap.
Weak defence tbh
 
The reservation I have with Tweet here is - why as scum does he claim stump? I understand that this is approaching WIFOM, but with Xenos on the table I feel like basically anything but "lynching me is fine" would be strong enough a claim to at least dissuade some people from wanting his flip, but he chose the one claim that actually invites it. I don't believe this has been given due consideration - it was just tabled and then dismissed.
Scum stumps have been seen on WS/WF games before. Although Tweet's go to claim is VT generally
 
@Alco it was this stuff with Imposter. These were all in the first handful of pages in the game and I really liked it as an entrance because he got straight stuck into trying to play the game and prodding with questions and votes, and I thought he handled TATs sus on him really well lol. Could be that they're a really good player and Im not giving them enough respect but I vibed them town pretty strongly actually

Lynch Flower

Nah. I just don't like to waste my vote

Have you played with Onerios much Flower?

I see. Do you have more of a general mistrust of miller claims?

What does that mean?

Okay. I don't really think meaningless votes are a thing. Are 'mundane' questions more obviously an excuse to put yourself about compared to fluff?

You don't crack a game on page 1. You prod
 
Yeah no not gonna bother, I don't think anything is wrong with me and just think Poyser and Ultra choose to view everything I say as unflattering as they possibly can
 
The reservation I have with Tweet here is - why as scum does he claim stump? I understand that this is approaching WIFOM, but with Xenos on the table I feel like basically anything but "lynching me is fine" would be strong enough a claim to at least dissuade some people from wanting his flip, but he chose the one claim that actually invites it. I don't believe this has been given due consideration - it was just tabled and then dismissed.
There could be a number of reasons tho, like it could be a given fake from the host, a tailored fake claim or just a list of roles he's given that are safe to fake. It could also be his real role. Also the added benefits of never having to provide any kind of results or protection lol, excuses never being shot by scum etc
 
I have less confidence in Tweet being scum. This kind of lazy and half-hearted defence is very rarely ever scum in my experience.
 
Tweet I've got 3 votes on me including your own, there is clearly a level of interest there from others to lynch me and yet you're not at all interested in going back and forth with me or pushing it further. I even invited you to go deeper into your scum read of me earlier and now you're refusing to engage. Its almost like you don't believe in it at all
 
Scum stumps have been seen on WS/WF games before. Although Tweet's go to claim is VT generally
I've seen scum treestumps before - that isn't the point I'm making. Whatever Tweet *actually* is is besides the point, I'm asking why, as Scum in this hypothetical, does Tweet elect to claim the one role that gives compelling reason to lynch him over Xenos, who from Scum's perspective, is a very easy pivot because he is an outed anti town killer. There are actually few worse claims for Tweet to have possibly made here as scum.
 
There could be a number of reasons tho, like it could be a given fake from the host, a tailored fake claim or just a list of roles he's given that are safe to fake. It could also be his real role. Also the added benefits of never having to provide any kind of results or protection lol, excuses never being shot by scum etc
Yeah I mean there are reasons sure, but it strikes me as very suboptimal given the current game state to roll with it. Even just vanilla is more compelling.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top