Okay from skimming through, I don't actively think Melkor is scum. My impression from the thread is that he got some pressure early and has felt like he's kept digging, as scum he would try to back off (see Members, where he was under pressure early and then said "I am known for being scummier as town" to work backwards from where he was).
Bachi can have a lean town. Liked how he was prompting Melkor, as scum I think he tends to stay more on the sidelines over the main points of co tention, and it would be quite easy to do here.
Lind... eh I want to say town, but he's still missing something.
@Lindltaylor typically you tend to look for townies and your reason is often the kinds of things that mostly get ignored or overlooked, like them being funny or something. Here, I feel like you've mostly been looking for scum reads. Can you explain/reconcile the difference there?
Don't like Nibel so far.
Think he waited on Melkor to get voted by Gram first to then find a way to join in on the wagon, has offered little else but parroting really. In relation to that, Gram more likely to be town.
Vote: Nibel 
