• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Elden Ring Mafia

I don’t need help with my wincon. I can claim more about what the other aspect of my wincon actually is, but it would make more sense to elaborate on it tomorrow if im still alive, as I can show that it’s not anti town
I assume you meant to quote me with this. I'm fine with you claiming it tomorrow, I'm also fine with you establishing a consensus before claiming, with the obvious expectation that you do so (claim) when the time comes. I'd like flavour, too.
 
First couple of pages - Evans comes off as very on the periphery, making empty observations without drawing any sort of conclusion with them. Points to RDK and Ratchet for saying what I was thinking before I even read their post

Like this the only post where you actually address problems with my early posts (I mean, drawing conclusions a few hours into the game is a bit lol and tbf, I drew the conclusion that I disagreed with Poysers town lean on Lethal and thought his behaviour was not alignment indicative)
 
I think your position is fair, but we do have less than 10 hours left if I'm not mistaken. Or maybe around 10. I'm not with you regarding Retro, if anything I lean town on them, so is there any other player you'd like to discuss?
Not really, I'd have to have a think about it but busy atm. I've admittedly tunnelled my focus on Retro a bit to this point.
Knowing what Odo/Gram is like with his roles and the depth of their abilities. I think there's a strong chance Aurelian is hiding something. GoT & Norse are excellent examples of this.
Correct. Odo loves a complex third party role.
Why wouldn’t you want to lynch him if you think he’s lying tho?

I believe he’s indy, but he’s 10000% lying about his wincon, not even a doubt
Because there are several reasons to lie about his wincon, and they're not all necessarily anti-town.

I'm not against voting him down the line but for now I think we want a lynch that gives the most info possible and his flip doesn't really do that.
Ahhhh I’ve been battling back and forth but might help us solve so fuck it

I am also a pro town indy, so it’s highly possible Aurelian is telling the truth on the whole, but he’s definitely lying about what his actual win con is and that’s rubbing me up the wrong way. Like my win condition is that the golden order have to be utterly destroyed, and I have to be alive obv and I also have another aspect of it that I have to do with my role

I thought the great runes was gonna be his version of that; but there’s no way on Earth his win con is “town have to get at least most of the great runes” lol. I also don’t really believe town have to get them to win anyway, if anything it would surely be that he has to get them personally
I imagine there's something to the whole rune situation that powers him up - would be kinda similar to my role in Norse and Odo loooved that role.

Not sure if that'd make sense in the lore tho
 
Objectively, what has he contributed besides trying to mire what you considered a free town read? It's frankly more confusing that I have to convince you. Unassertive, "Look at this cute little contradiction" posts tend to fit the profile more of unconfident scum. He's not a dead ringer, but only for the same reason there isn't any compelling defense for him - there isn't very much there otherwise.

Can you tell me what else I was supposed to do that early in the game with only 9 people? It generated discussion, no? Helped develop some current game standings for people, no?
 
Can you elaborate? I've seen multiple shots at me from you but not much follow through?

You're apparently aware of the comments I have made about your play, but still require further explanation, and then tie it with a bow by saying there's "not much follow through"? What?
 
But does he really put 2 pro town indies in a game?
I was considering this angle too, if only because Gram strikes me as the type of host that mostly prefers Indie roles to be... Independent. Not much of this "Pro-Town Indie" thing. Obviously not to say he wouldn't use them at all. But two in one game isn't something I was really expecting, at least as far as they've been claimed.
 
You're apparently aware of the comments I have made about your play, but still require further explanation, and then tie it with a bow by saying there's "not much follow through"? What?

There's been absolutely no follow through other than "He disagreed with a soft town lean 6 hours into the game" and begging people for their thoughts on me lol
 
I was considering this angle too, if only because Gram strikes me as the type of host that mostly prefers Indie roles to be... Independent. Not much of this "Pro-Town Indie" thing. Obviously not to say he wouldn't use them at all. But two in one game isn't something I was really expecting, at least as far as they've been claimed.

From memory, there was pro-town indie in the GoT game on WorstGen but that would need a proper check as it was a while ago
 
I am neither sure what your expectations of me here is or how I have somehow failed it

You've been persistently scum reading me for 26 pages, yet your only angle is my play for the first few hours of the game.

I'd expect more considering the rest of the activity in this game.
 
Idk what the hell fo make of Ekko claiming to be someone Aurelian needs to kill but not wanting to lynch him and trusting that he’ll instead protect him lol. Makes no sense
 
@Ultra what's your read list and can you give some explanations as to why you're reading them that way?

Surely you have more than just me & Alco?
 
Here is the post cut off from when you left the thread until you joined a couple of hours ago. Post #155.

And you're treating this as some sort of gotcha. Seems extremely disingenuous.

And we're on post #1540 with this one...

:heston
 
Back
Top