Game Death Note Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ratchet

Resplendent
Advisor
I was going to wait for MVP's, but I think T-Pein is an obvious one. The Town should have lynched him Day 1, because in this setup with Lynchpins, as soon as it's clear that a player isn't a lynchpin, the slot is effectively resolved for Scum. For Town, there is always a chance that they are scum, so flipping a player who at worst would be Vanilla would always be preferential at minimum cost. After that though, he played very well, and he caught onto Evans reacting to Tiara assuming he had been investigated, meaning they had an idea of him being a lynchpin before most of the thread did. I was a bit surprised the Mafia opted to use the 3 hour delay every time, because while hiding the kill can make it harder for town to guess the whole setup, it left Mafia unsure when day began if their kill had worked, potentially making it very awkward until the time had passed (and they were sure I wasn't going to announce it). I had anticipated it would be used specifically to try and force a speed lynch in some scenarios or cause some confusion. I think, I'd probably rework it next time, or maybe do away with it entirely.

As for honourable mentions, I do have a tough time here. I felt like most of the town struggled to make themselves look obviously town or clear themselves, and it was mostly coupled with off-reads. The off-reads is understandable as it's harder to scumhunt in this game, which is why the town *generally* has more chances than normal to kill Scum (on average, about 4 mislynches to get two scum). I think most would admit to not having their best game, though. In spite of saying this, I think Craig deserves his props - he caught onto Doddsy, and generally had one of the better games from the town. So he is my first one.

For the second one, earlier I was leaning towards Gram, for making the best of a bad situation he was given with Evans, but I think I've come around to Doddsy. I felt like he mostly coasted, but if I'm being fair, he did do enough to get by and find a way to win. So I'm going with Doddsy for my second one.
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Advisor
you say this but its what lost us the game

blind sheeping
joining wagons with scum reads for no reason
lazy hammering without hearing the defense of the person u scum read
arrogance and posturing

thats a summary of why town lost lol

Biggest problem is the wall of consensus. No discussion about Big Man was even *possible*. Dodd could have easily been lynched there as well, but for no good reason, he got 0 attention
 

Grammaton

Consigliere
Moderator
you say this but its what lost us the game

blind sheeping
joining wagons with scum reads for no reason
lazy hammering without hearing the defense of the person u scum read
arrogance and posturing

thats a summary of why town lost lol

not really

the game was lost because we wasted two days on lethal which broke town, and then (sorry) Evans put us on the clock

at the end of the day, you were mad you misplayed your hand, you tried to make too big an adjustment and you looked like you were happy to lynch anyone. That’s on you and only you.
 

Psychic

Yennefer
We scanned Ultra and Poyser.
Tried killing flower twice.
Tried Killing Evans Twice.
How did the kills on Evans failed twice?

:hestonpls

Damn I got played this whole game. LOL, I was starting to suspect you too. But GG you deserve this win.
I had a feeling Gram was lynchpin day 1. That's why I never voted him. I guess I tunneled Ultra too hard lol.
Sorry Craig. You were just too scummy though.
I'm glad the game ended and put me out of my misery.
 

T-Pein™

The Nexus
Pronouns
They/Them
How did the kills on Evans failed twice?

:hestonpls

Damn I got played this whole game. LOL, I was starting to suspect you too. But GG you deserve this win.
I had a feeling Gram was lynchpin day 1. That's why I never voted him. I guess I tunneled Ultra too hard lol.
Sorry Craig. You were just too scummy though.
I'm glad the game ended and put me out of my misery.

oh we succeeded on the 2nd try.
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
like give me more time to lay out my claim

then let me question the people on my wagon one by one

I liked @Poyser the most out of everyone on my wagon. said that many times. he at least questioned me on stuff, but was very cocky and arguing in bad faith

I didn't like @Grammaton voting for "lol" and voting with his scum read flowa

I didn't like @Ultra voting me for a case using my EoD 2 play when I told him I didn't read at that time so those r legit my worst posts in the game. and I'm conscious about playing different its not rly scummy lol. just a meta shift from last game. ultra failed to case me from anywhere else and stuck to this so not much I can do about it. i guess I shudnt post live EoD 2 without reading then? my bad

obviously didn't like @Big Man and @CraigPelton voting on my wagon without asking me a single question. also they r voting on a wagon their scum read poyser is pushing. how am I supposed to read them when they play like this??

@Tiara was a complete bot this game. voted me cuz I wanted to lynch her for hinting L and N. and I'll do it again cuz I had a feeling you arent N or L so ur hint meant nothing. and you backtracking it was so much worst

left over is just @Doddsy who voted with a catjam emoji and went off without asking me a single question. i caught onto his weak town read off @Tiara's iso posts being bullshit but obviously the thread didn't even bother letting him explain the vote


like i said its:
1. arrogance and posturing
2. blind sheeping
3. voting with people you scum read without a reason of your own to join a wagon
4. arrogance again
5. lazy hammering while the person is still talking
 

Ratchet

Resplendent
Advisor
If anyone wants to join dead/mafia chats, please let me know (ideally in one post each). Currently have Gram for both and T-Pein for dead.
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
Same for you @Ultra . You did find me, but stop with the paranoia jokes, please. I was legit worried.
no you werent worried lol. u were just shit talking while everyone is working hard and solving lmao

you literally suggested no lynch in day 4 :lul
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Advisor
like give me more time to lay out my claim

then let me question the people on my wagon one by one

I liked @Poyser the most out of everyone on my wagon. said that many times. he at least questioned me on stuff, but was very cocky and arguing in bad faith

I didn't like @Grammaton voting for "lol" and voting with his scum read flowa

I didn't like @Ultra voting me for a case using my EoD 2 play when I told him I didn't read at that time so those r legit my worst posts in the game. and I'm conscious about playing different its not rly scummy lol. just a meta shift from last game. ultra failed to case me from anywhere else and stuck to this so not much I can do about it. i guess I shudnt post live EoD 2 without reading then? my bad

obviously didn't like @Big Man and @CraigPelton voting on my wagon without asking me a single question. also they r voting on a wagon their scum read poyser is pushing. how am I supposed to read them when they play like this??

@Tiara was a complete bot this game. voted me cuz I wanted to lynch her for hinting L and N. and I'll do it again cuz I had a feeling you arent N or L so ur hint meant nothing. and you backtracking it was so much worst

left over is just @Doddsy who voted with a catjam emoji and went off without asking me a single question. i caught onto his weak town read off @Tiara's iso posts being bullshit but obviously the thread didn't even bother letting him explain the vote


like i said its:
1. arrogance and posturing
2. blind sheeping
3. voting with people you scum read without a reason of your own to join a wagon
4. arrogance again
5. lazy hammering while the person is still talking

You can complain but remember last game you let a lynch slide on me for info and it similarly cost the game. I can own up to the fact that I shouldn't have lynched you there but I also don't think you would do too much different in m shoes personally lol
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Advisor
not really

the game was lost because we wasted two days on lethal which broke town, and then (sorry) Evans put us on the clock

at the end of the day, you were mad you misplayed your hand, you tried to make too big an adjustment and you looked like you were happy to lynch anyone. That’s on you and only you.

Yeah Evans really dropped the fucking ball, no offense. But this is why lynchpin games are UGH

How hard can it be to keep your mouth shut when it's your most important job?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top