• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Game Ranked EastEnders Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.

Imposter

Illustrious
3. Phenom - Double voter
4. Grammaton - ?
5. Ratchet - Mason
8. CraigPelton - Cop
9. Alco - ?
10. Rugrat - ?
12. Ultra - Dog post restriction
13. xenos5 - SK
14. Retrolize - Miller
16. One Last Username - Vanilla
17. Black Pegged Dragon - ?
18. Lethal - ?
19. TAT - Jack of all trades
20. Goth Boy - Vanilla
21. Dalton - ?
22. Imposter - Bodyguard
23. Ekkologix - ?

Is this missing anything?
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
@Ratchet

Mind elaborating on this post? Before Alco recieved results on him? What results? Why is Gramma safe? Woof
...the results that T-Pein was supposed to bring? Have you forgotten that he claimed he was going to target Gram? It felt weird to me that someone would be voting before getting them. Gram was "safe" because it was consensus to scum read him, I.e it was not a notable position to hold.
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
...the results that T-Pein was supposed to bring? Have you forgotten that he claimed he was going to target Gram? It felt weird to me that someone would be voting before getting them. Gram was "safe" because it was consensus to scum read him, I.e it was not a notable position to hold.

Forgot about that context.

I'm surprised you held this position and have had little to say in the discussion surrounding Alco because the main point of contention for everyone reading him positively is that what you're attributing as a "safe" position is something he would never do.
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
Forgot about that context.

I'm surprised you held this position and have had little to say in the discussion surrounding Alco because the main point of contention for everyone reading him positively is that what you're attributing as a "safe" position is something he would never do.
I don't have much to say on Alco because I barely remember what he's done. I don't think he has been all that strong against Gram either. To be entirely honest though Ultra I know you heavily scum read him but I'd be lying if I said I could recall the particulars of your case too. Firmly null.
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
I don't have much to say on Alco because I barely remember what he's done. I don't think he has been all that strong against Gram either. To be entirely honest though Ultra I know you heavily scum read him but I'd be lying if I said I could recall the particulars of your case too. Firmly null.

My case is essentially what your observation is - and then comparing his showing to previous games. He's done very little to show himself town. I think his posts come off as more fabricated too, his reads feel more "prepared" and less shooting at the hip as well. Woof.
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
My case is essentially what your observation is - and then comparing his showing to previous games. He's done very little to show himself town. I think his posts come off as more fabricated too, his reads feel more "prepared" and less shooting at the hip as well. Woof.
Can you substantiate the reads claim please, or rather, point me to where you have? I think the lack of making himself town readable is justification for PoE, the going with the flow potentially scummy, but the reads if evidenced would be a pretty compelling case.
 

Tempest

Leprous Monarch
Didn't gram say he was gonna show up and play today so we shouldn't have lynched him yesterday? And he didn't place a vote despite being around at EOD and asked a lame question about why we were lynching OLU as if it wasn't obvious lol

Poyser placed a futile vote on ratchet which did SUS me out a bit but thankfully he died
 

One Last Username

Distinguished
Don't know how only townies got killed
Mafia had a kill. And they would kill townies.

poyser was sus and so he was probs vigged

and someone else’s was killed because they were sus or threatening

turns out all three were town.

you could have killed your scummate if you wanted.

change vote lynch Goth boy
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
Can you substantiate the reads claim please, or rather, point me to where you have? I think the lack of making himself town readable is justification for PoE, the going with the flow potentially scummy, but the reads if evidenced would be a pretty compelling case.

I can give you the cliff notes, will have to wait if you want me to go full quote walls. The essentials:

- His push on Tweet that he was given credit for was actually quite LHF in that it came after Tweet contradicted his read on BPD by his own admission, owning up to having no conviction on his vote and Poyser asking him why that is, before he voted. I didn't hate the vote at the time, but even then I didn't consider it very hard.
- Had some bad posts grilling Fang about why in his back and forth with X he didn't vote him and implied that he wasn't actually trying to solve him, which I found to be mostly nonsensical
- The whole Ekko thing earlier, where he uses his town meta to scum read him, probably the worst part of his ISO so far
- His Elden Ring game, even D1, he's doing much more threadsolving and feels like he's guided by gut impression instead of these kinda gotchya's he's been doing this game

Woof
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top