I don't really know why you keep employing this angleshooting here. No matter what his alignment is, he has been given a pass, he's not any more likely to be given a pass if he's town over scum - in fact, it would be the opposite, because a modkill on scum is more damaging from a strictly numbers perspective than one on town. It's not the first time you've invoked this either.
Beyond that, I noticed you mentioned me bringing up Phen0m as a shot target. Frankly, you're assuming I haven't given it due consideration without really qualifying it - of course I've noted it was Rugrat pushing it. I've also noted he only started pushing it when the PoE is closing in on him, which lends itself to plausibly bussing.
Lastly, I really need you to qualify your Lethal read - not sure if you have after the post I'm responding to. "Feels townie" is not good, and shouldn't be good enough for a player who claims to be a promoter of logical analysis. For what it's worth, I've found that claim of yours questionable in the past, so I'm not holdo g you to it, but if you are relying on third party meta then you should just say so, there is no shame in it. Otherwise I have no idea how you read his interaction with me and come away with the conclusion that it reads townie. It was flagrantly scummy, arguably too scummy to be scum, but the Ekko kill at least warrants a further look here. Lastly, you using his Hated claim as a point in his favour is pretty silly - it actively dissuades building a wagon on him, particularly in LyLo (which we are probably a phase or two away from), so the scum motivation should be pretty evident.