Monster Hunter World Mafia - Game Thread

[Poyser]

Oh just got to the part where evans outed his role for almost no reason

Town read was redundant but we go again!

 

[Evans]

When he flips scum I’ll be a hero

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

this interaction is weird as fuck. even at the time, but aurelian is basing his read off last game and that we shouldn't lynch lethal because of poyser.

i tell aurelian it's my wagon.

he asks who said anything about a wagon for poyser.

i repeat the lethal wagon is mine.

then he says he agrees with tpein that it's poyser's and then says we can CFD which was directly after the post where he said "who talked about a wagon for poyser".

???

Aurelian as a whole is just likely scum based on lack of meaningful activity

Imo

Tbh

 

[Poyser]

i saw people want to rolecop survivor before

fine cp claimed cop and wanted to cop imposter (albeit it obviously been a joke)

maybe i panicked and could have roleblocked him to save my mate

I think I’d rather you just didn’t post at all

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

So far my push/lynch pool for today is

T-Pein
Dalton
Aurelian
To a lesser degrew Impostor

If a scum player could please tell me why I should be lynching the townies in this list over their teammates that'd be swell

 

[Poyser]

Aurelian as a whole is just likely scum based on lack of meaningful activity

Imo

Tbh

I’m assuming he has posted between where I am and now but I was thinking this lol

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Oh then I just don't care lol

My entire play will be as lax as possible this game so I don't have stress, I'm especially not going to do those goofy read lists you lot love so you can toss that into the suspicious evidence box on me if you want to then

I think my old actions in day 1 were shitposting, asking Evan why he also voted Ekko, and me not liking the Lethal lynch and distrusting Poyser

Errrrr okay maybe not Aurelian after all

 

[Poyser]

scum have investigative abilities(for the most part rolecop). they're not rolecopping the claimed miller.

a preventative ability of some sort(usually roleblocker). they're not blocking the claimed miller.

kill abilities. cp isn't dead.

what action do you propose they visited cp with?

Tbf if there’s an SK then I suppose it’s possible mafia tried to kill cp and he was protected, as there could be a missing kill from n1

 

[Poyser]

Errrrr okay maybe not Aurelian after all

Why does this post make you think so?

 

[Dalton]

this is kinda nonsense tbh.

Care to elaborate?

cant really remember why i didnt give dalton as much shit tbh. i dont disagree that dalton has largely been chatting shit tho

Same here. What shit have I been chatting?

Dalton comes off a lot worse to me after a reread. I think him rolespeccing miller is NAI, I won't assume what assumptions he comes loaded into the game with, but he never actually pursued that thought any further or gave a read to CP and kinda just forgot about it. I usually don't have a hard time finding him as town even though he's low profile because he'll usually toss a thought or two out that check out, there's kind of a lack of that there.

Why would I pursue it? I said that CP is capable of fake claiming miller, particularly if Gramma tried to punish town for insta-clearing Millers by habit.

Not once did I say I think CP is scum for claiming miller; only that I think it is feasible.

Okay, Ace Dalton went from thinking Lethal's town to shading him in exactly 3 minutes lel

Its Lethal lol, I was reading through one of his wild-child defence phases and live-posting my feelings as i went.

 

[Poyser]

Care to elaborate?

Same here. What shit have I been chatting?

Why would I pursue it? I said that CP is capable of fake claiming miller, particularly if Gramma tried to punish town for insta-clearing Millers by habit.

Not once did I say I think CP is scum for claiming miller; only that I think it is feasible.

Its Lethal lol, I was reading through one of his wild-child defence phases and live-posting my feelings as i went.

The shit you’ve been chatting is wasting most of your posts on whether or not cp would fake millet and whether gram would give it as a fake. Pointless

Think you gave me a town read you didn’t really explain

Couldn’t tell you a single other point you’ve made lol

 

[Dalton]

Dalton never really commented about Pein either from what I can see, apart from "Okay with shooting him, he seems odd". They might be aligned.

I don't have an opinion on Hime tbh, I can't remember a single post they made.

vote Dalton

Think about my games as scum lol

I'm very trigger-happy when it comes to sussing my own teammates - most of my scum wins involve bussing my teammates to look townie.

Odo's last game (I think it was that one) is a good example where I was hard-bussing Doddsy all game despite us being aligned.

I don't see how it follows that I'd avoid interacting with T-Pein if we were scummates. If anything, it'd be a better tell if I focused in heavily on T-Pein even more than usual.

 

[Poyser]

Typical Lord Melkor post - completely off base and totally unsubstantiated.

I don’t think it is off base. What have you done today other than tell people to vote hime?

 

[Poyser]

Think about my games as scum lol

I'm very trigger-happy when it comes to sussing my own teammates - most of my scum wins involve bussing my teammates to look townie.

Odo's last game (I think it was that one) is a good example where I was hard-bussing Doddsy all game despite us being aligned.

I don't see how it follows that I'd avoid interacting with T-Pein if we were scummates. If anything, it'd be a better tell if I focused in heavily on T-Pein even more than usual.

This is fair tho

Was gonna say I actually think you’d more likely be town here as you’re way too image conscious as scum to just not really bother playing or pushing anything. Also think it makes it less likely you’d 180 on lethal so fast as well

As scum you either don’t show at all (NAI) or you put in a good amount of effort to make yourself look town

 

[Poyser]

Maybe this is a bad argument to make but does Dalton openly question the Miller as scum? I don't think I'd ever want that sort of heat

Good post

 

[Poyser]

ngl doc im a underwhelmed by this entrance.

Do you not think scum doc would force himself to put a read on me given the expectation that he can read me well?

This seems like something you’d pick up on in your effort to clear townies!

 

[Poyser]

seems kinda towny this phase yeah

Glad it’s not only me that thinks so lol

 

[Dalton]

That claim thing is foreign to me in my home site. But I get that's how the rest of you play.

It seems counterproductive for certain town PR to do that too imo.

If town power roles refuse to claim, it becomes clear they're power roles, rendering the idea of not claiming irrelevant.

i dont think i have time to find all the quotes rn but ill give brief reasonings for all

1. Ultra - lean scum

• ive explained this one enough i think

2. Melkor - lean town

• believe ive explained this one too but personally i dont really see him as scum here, it feels like hes been playing catch up a lot this game but hes stayed calm under pressure for the most part and i cant see who he can be aligned with really.. iirc in GOT, he got lynched pretty easily after tying himself up to some of our other teammates

3. Indigo - inactive af
4. Lethal - lean scum

• personally, i dont really like how he simply just gave up here, last game although he was annoyed af for being voted, he still went back and reread the thread and gave reads and everything in an attempt to actually solve... not feeling that from him here really

5. Nat - lean town

• not sure how to explain it but this feels like town energy nat, shes made some points that i especially agree with such as with sworder looking scummy despite everyone else at the time basically town reading him

6. REM - null/idk

• not sure what to make of this slot, he feels diff than the last 2 games ive played with him but overall is taking pressure and stuff really well??

7. CP - lean town (possible recruit??)

• i dont think hes lying abt being miller personally, i feel like its kinda risky if u lie and theres another miller actually in the game
• i say possible recruit here bc as a few other players pointed out, gram doesnt like putting millers in his games, as the only other gram game i played was GOT im going to base my thoughts using that game as an example... in GOT, we had the ability to convert the miller if certain requirements were fulfilled (unfortunately it didnt happen that game but thats how it worked there)

8. T-Pein - lean scum

• i liked his vibe earlier but i think hes kinda just taking the im not going to claim thing to the extreme, iirc he claimed in valentines when he was town so im not sure what to make of it here... i do know in valentines he got upset that i claimed for no reason and told dofla not to claim when he (dofla) was being sussed... tho tbf i think he wanted xadlin to claim that game

9. Magic - lean town

• i like ur vibe this game, it feels similar to fairy tail, also i think ultra is scum and i doubt u 2 r aligned tbh

10. Psychic - inactive af
11. Dalton - null/idk
12. Alco - null/idk
13. Hime - town af
14. Flower - null/idk

• idk, she feels more calm this game than most, usually i see her posting a bunch and getting in arguments/debates with other players more... kinda feels like shes slipping under the radar a bit but it feels kinda similar to fairy tail before she subbed out

15. Ekko - null/idk

• not sure what to make of new ekko and his insistence that hes scum over and over agn

16. Imposter - null/maybe slight scum lean?

• feels like he is slipping under the radar too now, thought the whole thing with him voting players like LM and t-pein came off a bit opportunistic

17. Evans - null/maybe slight town lean?

• honestly not sure on this slot, i like his overall vibe but there isnt a lot of hard content to go off of

18. TSworder - lean scum

• idk where all the town reads on this guy came from, feels like he just made a couple of posts to seem solvy and dipped... sounds like hes just sheeping and going with whatever the crowd wants after he came back... personally kinda see it as him trying to appease the actives and look like hes actually contributing

19. Xadlin - lean scum

• poyser pointed it out earlier but his vote on me literally came out of nowhere lol... also he made this post that really rubbed me the wrong way abt how hes just useless dp1, felt like an excuse to divert attention off of him and it was strange hearing it from him of all ppl, usually used to ppl saying such things abt other players' play

20. Poyser - lean town

• i liked his entrance and catch up, he seems genuinely interested in solving and looking at players from a fresh perspective and coming to his own conclusions rather than sheeping which is easy to resort to when arriving late to the game

21. Tweet - lean town

• think i explained this earlier as well but he feels very similar to traitors but just active, his attitude in in fairy tail was to try and remain neutral and get ppl to like him whereas here he literally doesnt give a fuck and questions and challenges other players

i posted this last phase but i didnt realize the lynch got posted so i had to delete^
clearly i was wrong abt 3 of my scum leans since then so i might have to reevaluate...

Curious that you don't have any opinion of me in this list considering I'm one of the top scumreads in the thread rn

 

[Poyser]

Think we can pull the trigger on getting a magic claim here

Man is struggling af

 

[Dalton]

The shit you’ve been chatting is wasting most of your posts on whether or not cp would fake millet and whether gram would give it as a fake. Pointless

Think you gave me a town read you didn’t really explain

Couldn’t tell you a single other point you’ve made lol

I get the first bit, although that was just in my initial readback - I posted more in the few hours before EOD as I continued my readback and was caught up.

Second bit I did explain - in fact my town read was in direct response to your big reads post which was a significant mind meld of me including the Tweet stuff and so to me it obviously seems genuine and logical.

This is fair tho

Was gonna say I actually think you’d more likely be town here as you’re way too image conscious as scum to just not really bother playing or pushing anything. Also think it makes it less likely you’d 180 on lethal so fast as well

As scum you either don’t show at all (NAI) or you put in a good amount of effort to make yourself look town

:slip:

harsh but fair

Honestly I was playing D1 on catchup cos i was on holiday over the weekend and on monday which is a public holiday - so wasn't really on my PC for extended periods.

I fully intend on playing this game properly (Gramma game hype)