Watcher?
Ranked One Piece Wano Arc
- Thread starter Lord Melkor
- Start date
- Status
Alright that puts Craig back on the table.
Vote: CraigPelton
@Ultra @Ekkologix Would appreciate you both backing me on this. Let me call today's lynch, if it's wrong we will go Lethal tomorrow.
Vote: CraigPelton
@Ultra @Ekkologix Would appreciate you both backing me on this. Let me call today's lynch, if it's wrong we will go Lethal tomorrow.
Yup
Was tempted to claim this lol
I want Tweet to claim first
I think that while it means Craig isn't clear I think a trifecta of investigative abilities makes sense in this set up. Otherwise we'd be pretty thin. I know GP's role is unknown - but I don't think he was an investigator, because he claimed targeting me.
T-Pein™
The Nexus
- Pronouns
- They/Them
Well actually this is what he had to say, he got feedback from it so honestly not sure.
T-Pein™
The Nexus
- Pronouns
- They/Them
shulda done kekko....
^Here's what else GP claimed fyi
T-Pein™
The Nexus
- Pronouns
- They/Them
obviously needed to Janitor one of the unclaimed roles...
there wasn't much to choose from .
Anyway to shore up Craig - yesterday he talked about how he didn't expect a Watcher to be present, which is fine and all but it all came day 3, which on readback gave me the impression he was deliberately trying to lay the groundwork for the claim. Then he talked about me having to accept him being confirmed which came across as weird - why would I be angry if he can prove himself? His anger actually didn't feel earned either.
Also his position around the janitor comes across as heavily informed to me. He has no reason as town to contemplate "risking the janitor" when he would otherwise be clearing himself. Especially after Goddess outed herself.
His reaction to that by the way was to cast aspersions on the claim she made which made no sense. Also back in Day 1 where he talked about Ekko being good at LyLo as reason to keep him around long term... all of this just feels very fake to me. Not something he would genuinely believe.
If I'm wrong, I'm wrong. Happy to cop to a bad read. But there are a lot of little things here that strike me as this being scum Craig and I don't think I'm going to be able to get over them. Happy to concede Lethal looks bad in some parts but as scum he would know he is under pressure and I find it unlikely that he would just straight up claim to have used it on Tweet and not someone like Ekko or myself - a player that is generally town read but has a degree of paranoia around them. Obviously blocking me wouldn't make sense for his reads but you can work around that.
So yeah in conclusion I think it's Craig. With Ultra as Watcher the one part I was struggling to get over is gone, happy to wait for his results of course but I think this is the answer.
Also his position around the janitor comes across as heavily informed to me. He has no reason as town to contemplate "risking the janitor" when he would otherwise be clearing himself. Especially after Goddess outed herself.
His reaction to that by the way was to cast aspersions on the claim she made which made no sense. Also back in Day 1 where he talked about Ekko being good at LyLo as reason to keep him around long term... all of this just feels very fake to me. Not something he would genuinely believe.
If I'm wrong, I'm wrong. Happy to cop to a bad read. But there are a lot of little things here that strike me as this being scum Craig and I don't think I'm going to be able to get over them. Happy to concede Lethal looks bad in some parts but as scum he would know he is under pressure and I find it unlikely that he would just straight up claim to have used it on Tweet and not someone like Ekko or myself - a player that is generally town read but has a degree of paranoia around them. Obviously blocking me wouldn't make sense for his reads but you can work around that.
So yeah in conclusion I think it's Craig. With Ultra as Watcher the one part I was struggling to get over is gone, happy to wait for his results of course but I think this is the answer.
T-Pein™
The Nexus
- Pronouns
- They/Them
vote lynch ekko
He received some feedback from the role because he knew it failed, so he must have been some sort of investigator.
Anyway Ultra we have a few bad faith players around here so that's why I'm asking for complete co-operation, I'm happy to defer completely tomorrow if I'm wrong, but I really don't think I am here and frankly I think I've earned the right to call the lynch after Days 2 and 3.
He never investigates me there with something conventional, he had complete trust of me. I'm watcher. I don't think it was investigative. Could be something like increasing my VP, or neighbor, or something else
T-Pein™
The Nexus
- Pronouns
- They/Them
T-Pein™
The Nexus
- Pronouns
- They/Them
Possible but again he wouldn't receive feedback for most things. Could have been a paranoia check too, complete trust or no he may want to chdck his blind spots. Without his claim we can only assume, I think it doesn't really hold as a point of defence at this stage.
Also I can just sense the scum on Craig lol, @Psychic style. I need you to back me here.
- Status