• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
I mentioned this yesterday - he mentioned both CP and Watson, seemed to scum read them, but in terms of action either did nothing towards them, or supported them. Early on, he was backing up CPs push on Flower, without directly joining it. He had Watson as scum, but never discussed her slot, tried to pressure her, or really do anything that could further that read. Struck me as a partner that wanted to distance from his mates without actually committing to it.
You think my scum play is o just bring attention to my mates and leave?
 
Just a basic assumption, mafia have no reason to kill Ekko when he was fairly heavily sussed, and also not really pushing anyone
I don't really think this is true at all? He was unlikely to be scum with CP, in fact he was pushed almost entirely as a counter wagon to CP, and also this doesn't consider him potentially having been rolecopped or something too. I think there are enough permutations at play here to warrant against arbitrarily assuming who the Mafia opted to kill. Who do you think killed Ekko, then?
 
It also makes no sense that a N1 poison would resolve at the end of N2 rather than end of D2
Huh? Poisons typically resolve a cycle afterwards - a full cycle would be the end of the following night phase. Otherwise how would healers ever heal it?
 
I don't really think this is true at all? He was unlikely to be scum with CP, in fact he was pushed almost entirely as a counter wagon to CP, and also this doesn't consider him potentially having been rolecopped or something too. I think there are enough permutations at play here to warrant against arbitrarily assuming who the Mafia opted to kill. Who do you think killed Ekko, then?
I think the vig/SK killed Ekko and the other killed Watson

I’d be gobsmacked if mafia killed Ekko. Thrown for a loop!
 
What are you talking about ratchet. Traditionally a poison on N1 would be announced start of day 2 and resolved end of day 2. What mafia games have you been playing??
 
He claimed to target Cubey for tracking BEFORE Nibel revealed he tried to jailor Mango
Well, I am pretty sure Nibel claimed first, but I wasn't aware of this. I certainly saw Nibel's post after I posted, but that was because I was late to the party so I didn't see it before I was reading back.

Of course, in this case you'd have to give me the benefit of doubt since technically I could have feigned ignorance like a certain someone has continually done.
 
Well, I am pretty sure Nibel claimed first, but I wasn't aware of this. I certainly saw Nibel's post after I posted, but that was because I was late to the party so I didn't see it before I was reading back.

Of course, in this case you'd have to give me the benefit of doubt since technically I could have feigned ignorance like a certain someone has continually done.
has continually accused me of'
 
I think the vig/SK killed Ekko and the other killed Watson

I’d be gobsmacked if mafia killed Ekko. Thrown for a loop!
Why would the SK kill Ekko, or rather, why would it be more likely for the SK to kill Ekko compared to the Mafia? Note that you also claim Ekko was scum read enough to possibly be Vigged, and the SK would have incentive to hit town after scum died back to back, which isn't to say they would of course.

If you're the Vig that shot Ekko, you should probably just say so, scum will have figured it out already and it beats trying to argue around this.
 
Why would the SK kill Ekko, or rather, why would it be more likely for the SK to kill Ekko compared to the Mafia? Note that you also claim Ekko was scum read enough to possibly be Vigged, and the SK would have incentive to hit town after scum died back to back, which isn't to say they would of course.

If you're the Vig that shot Ekko, you should probably just say so, scum will have figured it out already and it beats trying to argue around this.
I’m not the vig lol. Tbh my working theory is that mafia killed flower, the vig killed Ekko and SK killed Watson but the latter 2 are shooting in the dark as there’s no real way to spec between them. You can spec about the mafia kill, and I don’t think mafia killing Ekko makes any sense
 
if there is an sk, i think its possible that melkor was the sk kill and mafia tried to kill gram
would explain nibel being potentially blocked last night
 
Ehhh, I believe I made a post about this earlier. But he only came onto me when Flower was shouting to all hells about me and I was a topic of conversation. His vote on CP was also soon when the phase extended. I think he's playing a game of convenience and trying to give himself some space to claim otherwise

If this doesn't make sense maybe I should just go sleep
I don't know what epic you're in, but that is not even remotely close to what went down lmao.

Flower said one thing to me; "read from the start of D2."

Look, I really don't care what you or anyone else think, I've had enough of your stupid game. I've wasted enough energy on this already.
 
What are you talking about ratchet. Traditionally a poison on N1 would be announced start of day 2 and resolved end of day 2. What mafia games have you been playing??
When does this ever happen? Like seriously, it's always cyclical to give healers a chance, unless the healer is a day action for whatever reason. What games are you playing, here is the description of the Poison ability:

"[Poisoner(2 shot)]-You can target a player at night and poison them. If they are not healed they will die at the conclusion of the following night phase. If a successful poison kill is accomplished the role will automatically be set to zero shots."

Now I don't know about you, but "at the conclusion of the following night phase" seems pretty explicit to me. It's how it has always been done here - you're completely inventing this just to have something to argue. Sincerely, what on Earth are you doing?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top