Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

[Ratchet]

Poyser/Rugrat/Gad/Dofla

Think that's the game winning PoE?

 

[Ultra]

@Ultra

You’re going to need to explain why if I am the SK, why I’d kill Fang who otherwise had strong SK suspicion. And his flip would give evidence to a confirmed killing role, which would sign my own death warrant.

I don't always require positive evidence, can you explain why you shot someone that we mutually agreed was going to be Jailed to check for SK, and why I'm to assume your role exists given these flips? If you can answer any of my questions I'll start giving you the time of day, otherwise idc

 

[Bachi]

I'm pretty sure Gram is town or he's fooled me considerably

Bachi should probably full claim today but I'm still leaning him as town that's been aggressively wrong.

Other than that...oh, Dofla. I have a reason for this too, when I get to my claim

IM HATED TOWNIE- NEED -1 VOTE TO BE LYNCHED AND I HAVE THIS PR AS A SECOND PASSIVE, THATS ALL
-MY LISTENERS KEEP YOUR EYES ON THE PRIZE-

 

[Rugrat]

Do you tend to trust the word of someone you think is scum?

I see no reason to use roles which have no opportunity cost to us.

 

[Ultra]

Not sure why Ratchet wants to lynch Poyser now, when his flip will be today

I don't believe he's confirmed he's instant use yet

 

[Grammaton]

As I say if I can make it to tomorrow unscathed, I have a piece of potentially game winning kit to give out

 

[Grammaton]

IM HATED TOWNIE- NEED -1 VOTE TO BE LYNCHED AND I HAVE THIS PR AS A SECOND PASSIVE, THATS ALL
-MY LISTENERS KEEP YOUR EYES ON THE PRIZE-

Kinda wish you hadn’t claimed this, but it’s understandable

 

[Ratchet]

I see no reason to use roles which have no opportunity cost to us.

If he wants to use it he can do so whenever, I know some of you people love to take one thing said and strawman it but I never said anything about speedlynching.

 

[Ratchet]

Kinda wish you hadn’t claimed this, but it’s understandable

I have lots of reservations about a setup with a hated townie plus Mafia having a poison plus a Hider, plus 5 scum, plus a serial killer. Like jeez that's rough. I do think he's probably not scum claiming it though.

 

[Ultra]

I'm Gran Torino, Vanilla Townie

True Vanilla townie - don't have an unlock or anything.

Given that unlocks appear to be default in this game, I'm a little sussed by Dofla's inclusion next to mine, though there's nothing strictly speaking that says there can't be two of us.

I can see him going either way, odds are fair that as basically the first person to claim he didn't read the sample in OP and botched and rolled with it

 

[Ratchet]

Am I claiming next? Rather, am I the last one?

 

[Rugrat]

I don't always require positive evidence, can you explain why you shot someone that we mutually agreed was going to be Jailed to check for SK, and why I'm to assume your role exists given these flips? If you can answer any of my questions I'll start giving you the time of day, otherwise idc

1. Didnt trust Fang or Nibel

2. Town have a vig in every game and scum have a poisoner which is a particularly potent killing role, so it wouldn’t reconcile town not having one.

In addition I’m only an odd night vig. Vigs infrequently live to N5 and generally only retards shoot on N1, so it’s not a high usage role either. Not as though killing roles are much of a bane to scum at any rate, and they may have another protective role - which may reconcile with Nibel’s failure to jail.

 

[Bachi]

Kinda wish you hadn’t claimed this, but it’s understandable

I THOUGHT THAT HE HAS MECH VS ME, I GOT 2 PASSIVES YEAH
-LETS GO MHA-

 

[DoflaMihawk]

I'm Gran Torino, Vanilla Townie

True Vanilla townie - don't have an unlock or anything.

Given that unlocks appear to be default in this game, I'm a little sussed by Dofla's inclusion next to mine, though there's nothing strictly speaking that says there can't be two of us.

I can see him going either way, odds are fair that as basically the first person to claim he didn't read the sample in OP and botched and rolled with it

Sup vanilla bro

 

[Ratchet]

I'm Gran Torino, Vanilla Townie

True Vanilla townie - don't have an unlock or anything.

Given that unlocks appear to be default in this game, I'm a little sussed by Dofla's inclusion next to mine, though there's nothing strictly speaking that says there can't be two of us.

I can see him going either way, odds are fair that as basically the first person to claim he didn't read the sample in OP and botched and rolled with it

I can see there being two to be fair, but yeah happy to keep him on the backend of PoE. Between him and Gad, can I assume you suspect him more?

 

[Ratchet]

I THOUGHT THAT HE HAS MECH VS ME, I GOT 2 PASSIVES YEAH
-LETS GO MHA-

For future reference, claimi g hated benefits scum because they know that they can keep you alive to reach majority a phase earlier.

 

[Ultra]

I can see there being two to be fair, but yeah happy to keep him on the backend of PoE. Between him and Gad, can I assume you suspect him more?

I think Dofla's posts have been hot dogshit so yeah.

 

[Grammaton]

I have lots of reservations about a setup with a hated townie plus Mafia having a poison plus a Hider, plus 5 scum, plus a serial killer. Like jeez that's rough. I do think he's probably not scum claiming it though.

only thing I really object to is the poisoner, I’m not that fond of scum having extra pills but this one was at least heavily gatekept

 

[Ratchet]

1. Didnt trust Fang or Nibel

2. Town have a vig in every game and scum have a poisoner which is a particularly potent killing role, so it wouldn’t reconcile town not having one.

In addition I’m only an odd night vig. Vigs infrequently live to N5 and generally only retards shoot on N1, so it’s not a high usage role either. Not as though killing roles are much of a bane to scum at any rate, and they may have another protective role - which may reconcile with Nibel’s failure to jail.

Town have hime and Fang, both killing utility roles. You're also adding this odd night Vig part now when really, given the suspicion on your slot, you should have done so earlier when it looks less like an attempt to navigate the argument against your claim.

 

[Ultra]

1. Didnt trust Fang or Nibel

2. Town have a vig in every game and scum have a poisoner which is a particularly potent killing role, so it wouldn’t reconcile town not having one.

In addition I’m only an odd night vig. Vigs infrequently live to N5 and generally only retards shoot on N1, so it’s not a high usage role either. Not as though killing roles are much of a bane to scum at any rate, and they may have another protective role - which may reconcile with Nibel’s failure to jail.

Well you see, I already addressed the bolded, and it's in fact part of my case against you, we had a vig!