• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Monster Hunter World Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Magic said:
honestly from what i read so far tpein is just posting shit. he can be posting shit as either alignment, i wont object to him being lynched as i dont really care if he's removed and i dont think his slot will be solved and he'll be liable in end game. not to mention he seems to get by posting shit as scum as people wont actually lynch him for it since he does as both alignments.

i could probably join you on hime as well as she has been much more lackluster from her previous game and hasn't really shown the same level of intent when it comes to solving. i dont really buy her being bored.

dalton i didnt really like his play or emphasis around the miller stuff as it seemed off and needless.

going to review the lethal wagon and see what else i see on there. i remember nat was pretty vocal in lethal of pein, especially as things started to shift from lethal to pein the first time, but i dont think there's much reason in resolving her prior to pein himself because if pein is town too it's not really scummy for nat to go from one town to another town for no reason as scum.

im also not entirely sure why youre getting a pass for your play thus far as similarly to poyser i dont really feel like you did all that much effort into actually trying to develop a wagon on hime or push your scum read on her outside of repeating it a bunch.
Click to expand...

This accusation has been thrown at me constantly an I have no idea where this stems or what causes that perception lmao. Do I need to drop a full case with citations? Why is this expectation placed squarely on me and nobody else? It's bizarre
 
Poyser said:
the bottom is actually why i think he's likely town, as ive already told you

pretty sure you replied saying its fair and you agree its not like last game... but then hedged about being told he is usually different as scum?
Click to expand...

it isn't hedging. others, and i know youre aware of this cause you were surprised at his play last game, said his last game surprised them because he's much more reserved as scum. i obviously have no context for his town game, but it's a pretty general tell if someone pushes something without actually pushing it.

i dont think he's priority or anything, i just dont really understand the town reads.
 
Poyser said:
not sure on number, but with me magic and cp all on him it was starting to look like pein/lethal/nothing as options. but then obv lethal became looking the most likely again esp when magic switched
Click to expand...
There was a point where TPein had 7 and lethal had 5, then magic switched back to lethal and I ultimately conceded to the lethal wagon to avoid a no lynch
 
Ultra said:
My current scum reads actually have nothing to do with the wagons yesterday

I saw Hime drop a wallpost after EoD which I didn't get to read in its entirity, but honestly seemed high effort. I hate to hold this against her, but I don't think I've ever seen her do this before and it's not something I associate with her town game. I'd be interested in giving it a look over anyway though

Dalton comes off a lot worse to me after a reread. I think him rolespeccing miller is NAI, I won't assume what assumptions he comes loaded into the game with, but he never actually pursued that thought any further or gave a read to CP and kinda just forgot about it. I usually don't have a hard time finding him as town even though he's low profile because he'll usually toss a thought or two out that check out, there's kind of a lack of that there.

Still kind of suspicious of Imp too but more of a backseat scum read than these two
Click to expand...

why are you sus of imp?
 
Magic said:
it isn't hedging. others, and i know youre aware of this cause you were surprised at his play last game, said his last game surprised them because he's much more reserved as scum. i obviously have no context for his town game, but it's a pretty general tell if someone pushes something without actually pushing it.

i dont think he's priority or anything, i just dont really understand the town reads.
Click to expand...
thats the only time ive seen him as scum, but ive seen him as town a fair few times lol
i dont really believe the shite about him being timid/reserved as scum after actually seeing him play as it, so im surprised you would give credence to that when hes just shown how capable he is of being aggressive as scum
 
Poyser said:
thats the only time ive seen him as scum, but ive seen him as town a fair few times lol
i dont really believe the shite about him being timid/reserved as scum after actually seeing him play as it, so im surprised you would give credence to that when hes just shown how capable he is of being aggressive as scum
Click to expand...

his aggression dropped after my death and a lot of it can be attributed to ekko being so far up his ass and helping lead the lynches that if a gastrologist went to check his prostate he'd have a hard time determining if ekko is apart of the asshole or not.
 
Man Dalton sure posted a lot of poop around the Lethal lynch.

I guess the "I'm switching between readback and realtime" can be a valid excuse, but the progression from clearing Lethal to wanting to hammer him doesn't look natural at all.
 
Magic said:
why are you sus of imp?
Click to expand...

His case on Melkor seemed like an overextension, you may recall my catch earlier that his "ping" on him didn't really make sense. Also when I asked him about Ekko and why he was scum reading him, he told me that he wasn't a fan of Ekko's town reads, which didn't make any sense because he was town reading the same people Ekko was. So on two occasions he made cases on players which sound ok but upon further scrutiny didn't really check out. Otherwise he's been...okay, I don't think he's a bad player by any means or he's super obvious scum but he's been a bit off
 
Dalton never really commented about Pein either from what I can see, apart from "Okay with shooting him, he seems odd". They might be aligned.

I don't have an opinion on Hime tbh, I can't remember a single post they made.

vote Dalton
 
CraigPelton said:
It's more that I think he was trying to be clever about the lethal wagon, doesn't really fit his MO especially as he was null on lethal anyway
Click to expand...

i will say the exchange between tpein and poyser about how poyser is always wrong about lethal is probably the biggest i could see as poyser being town if tpein is scum.
 
vote dalton
ya im good with this too.


i will say while i dont want to use the entire day to just lynch tpein, i also dont want to out a bunch of claims that scum can use if we're likely just lynching tpein as it will do us no favours anyway.
 
CraigPelton said:
Bro we were literally gonna lynch him and you switched back to lethal and that made me think you felt strongly about lethal and caused me to switch reeee you are gonna look so bad if TPein flips scum lmao
Click to expand...
i did feel strongly about lethal being scum. i genuinely just think pein's play is shit. like skybox tier shit, hence why i ended up switching. im not going to let him coast by though for being shit as he did that in fairy tale mafia and apparently some other game where he was scum cop.
 
Alco said:
Dalton never really commented about Pein either from what I can see, apart from "Okay with shooting him, he seems odd". They might be aligned.

I don't have an opinion on Hime tbh, I can't remember a single post they made.

vote Dalton
Click to expand...
Ok might be on to something there.

Dalton came in end of the day? I haven't read those pages yet.
[Vote Lynch Dalton]
 
RÆM said:
Bro this is cringe to read not gonna lie.
i
Click to expand...
raem youre a cool guy and all, but this is mafia and not real life. we're not all equals here. if we were all equals mafia wouldn't look to kill the same people every game that never get protected and then win while the same people alive at end game keep mislynching.

im not saying you cant go ahead and try to lynch us, but if your contention is about potential value loss then ya it checks out.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top