• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Monster Hunter World Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Magic said:
raem can you clarify why this is scummy to you?
Click to expand...
Look at my posts yesterday, I believed Lethal's claim and his schizo claim even fit the described monster etc.
Then people just dismissed it.
From my townie POV he looked pretty sincere, his claim and role fit very cohesively. I even quoted from the wiki how the 4 abilities fit well with how the monster is described and behaves.
zzz

We lynched the guy who was straight forward over Tpein who was just ugly emoji spamming most of the round, not even sure if he had any decent contributions. Just a half ass read list that he puts less than 1 sentence reads for everyone. That's nothing imo. Kept making excuses while catching up and replying to Poyser instead of just hunkering down and reading the game.

So yes I find ultimately settling on Lethal over Tpein yesterday more scummy.
If anything too we can check / watch Lethal since he did claim etc.

Tpein was still an unkown who refused to claim ,not that I think claiming is the end all be all. But couple with his general lack of gusto and productive thread presence the choice should have been clear.

I of course would have preferred one of my lynches.
Tsworder was dud :( I did not shoot him btw.
Xadlin suss'd me but I did not read him as scum in return, he just striked me as stupid for fixating on me for roleplaying as a monster.

I think Hans Tweet is scum? But uh I need to see more from him today and check who he voted.

I don't like the guy with the army helmet avatar.
The Dalton-Tpein thing seems interesting lead as well.

Town reads
Ultra, Hime, Psychic (i think unless im confusing her with another game). Craig P.
 
Flower said:
After a ISO during the night I think Melkor looks better. Not enough to put him in my Town leans, but I think his play can come from Town Melkor. I compared his posts to some from his recent scum games on NF and they look a bit different.
Click to expand...

You read an entire game for a meta dive and you don't have a lean on him? Was he your top suspect yesterday?

I more or less have a similar impression, for different reasons altogether, but ones I can't really substantiate on because ongoing game and all
 
Flower what happened to your big concern of Melkor having Ekko as town due to activity when apparently he’s well aware of ekkos ability to top post as scum? Is this now outweighed by him not buddying you?
 
Ultra said:
You read an entire game for a meta dive and you don't have a lean on him? Was he your top suspect yesterday?

I more or less have a similar impression, for different reasons altogether, but ones I can't really substantiate on because ongoing game and all
Click to expand...
One of my suspects, yeah. If you need a GTH rn I would say Town.
 
Poyser said:
Flower what happened to your big concern of Melkor having Ekko as town due to activity when apparently he’s well aware of ekkos ability to top post as scum? Is this now outweighed by him not buddying you?
Click to expand...
I think it's still flawed reasoning, but yeah, I do think scum LM isn't that suicidal after my reread.
 
RÆM said:
Look at my posts yesterday, I believed Lethal's claim and his schizo claim even fit the described monster etc.
Then people just dismissed it.
From my townie POV he looked pretty sincere, his claim and role fit very cohesively. I even quoted from the wiki how the 4 abilities fit well with how the monster is described and behaves.
zzz

We lynched the guy who was straight forward over Tpein who was just ugly emoji spamming most of the round, not even sure if he had any decent contributions. Just a half ass read list that he puts less than 1 sentence reads for everyone. That's nothing imo. Kept making excuses while catching up and replying to Poyser instead of just hunkering down and reading the game.

So yes I find ultimately settling on Lethal over Tpein yesterday more scummy.
If anything too we can check / watch Lethal since he did claim etc.

Tpein was still an unkown who refused to claim ,not that I think claiming is the end all be all. But couple with his general lack of gusto and productive thread presence the choice should have been clear.

I of course would have preferred one of my lynches.
Tsworder was dud :( I did not shoot him btw.
Xadlin suss'd me but I did not read him as scum in return, he just striked me as stupid for fixating on me for roleplaying as a monster.

I think Hans Tweet is scum? But uh I need to see more from him today and check who he voted.

I don't like the guy with the army helmet avatar.
The Dalton-Tpein thing seems interesting lead as well.

Town reads
Ultra, Hime, Psychic (i think unless im confusing her with another game). Craig P.
Click to expand...


Thank you. Just wanted to clarify in regards to the claim aspect as you refused to claim last game so wanted to.make sure you didn't find it scummy just because he didn't claim but this checks out.

I don't think there's any chance raem is scum in this game. Especially because of the bit here about the claims and checking to verify it matches. That said I don't think that's reliable as odo could have given full fakes
 
Magic said:
Thank you. Just wanted to clarify in regards to the claim aspect as you refused to claim last game so wanted to.make sure you didn't find it scummy just because he didn't claim but this checks out.

I don't think there's any chance raem is scum in this game. Especially because of the bit here about the claims and checking to verify it matches. That said I don't think that's reliable as odo could have given full fakes
Click to expand...
That claim thing is foreign to me in my home site. But I get that's how the rest of you play.

It seems counterproductive for certain town PR to do that too imo.
 
Magic said:
if youre lynching whatever why were you opposed to lynching lethal, as cp brought up several times.

i just looked over fairy tale and her play is somewhat similar there. is this just an general read instead of meta based or are you going off meta too?

i was gonna ask why you did this vote but later on you explained as moving to get things done. i think this vote was missed in odo's post count too.

if tpein's entrance was so bad to you why didn't you vote tpein over lethal or want to? i understand i likely missed the reasoning as im sure you gave some(i know you mentioned hesitancy in lethal's wagon compared to tpein's although not sure if that's really accurate).

this also reads weird as you didn't even feel like lethal was a wagon

i like the points toward sworder.

what about hime's posts did you like outside of her willingness to vote ultra which obviously was going nowhere

do you think everyone will be doing the exact same type of scum interaction?

@Flower can you actually explain the idea/thinking behind this? as ya it doesn't really make sense whatsoever.

dont be such a pussy.

you spent the majority of your time afterwards just crying about being sussed rather than contributing. like so far the majority of it is just whining about you being wagoned.


i think tweet's play is noticeably more town than his scum play. in his scum play he sort of does what he did with ultra except he initiates, then votes that person, then uses the bulk of his play around that person. his interaction with ultra seemed genuine and the fact he referenced a prior game where ultra mislynched him also seemed like town frustration.

what are your other town reads after day 1?
Click to expand...

I am a bit tired so won't be very verbose here - Hime seemed to become a bit more active EOD yesterday and even gave a list of reads though I would be curious if she can provide justification for them @hime.

Tpein yesterday was not great, though his stubborn reaction while being asked to claim could come from a townie. Scum can always just claim vanilla in this setup. I want to see more of him today, but remains in POE, same as Hime.

I know not everyone makes the same scum interaction, still they are more and less typical behaviours I have seen.
 
@Lord Melkor Your thoughts on the lynch and the night kills?
funny I think of tagging you and you are online Melkor. >>>ESP <<<<

Oh do u guys think we have an sk maybe?
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top