• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Monster Hunter World Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Somewhat off topic but I haven't witnessed a single game where Dalton has signed up and then not subbed out, we probably should start enforcing against this crap (even though I like him)
 
Dalton said:
Curious that you don't have any opinion of me in this list considering I'm one of the top scumreads in the thread rn
Click to expand...
kind of weird dalton chose this hime post to reply to when this is all he had to say, seems pretty weak so what was the purpose
 
Ultra said:
Somewhat off topic but I haven't witnessed a single game where Dalton has signed up and then not subbed out, we probably should start enforcing against this crap (even though I like him)
Click to expand...
what sucks is he said he was definitely going to start playing properly in his last post 🥴
 
Ekkologix said:
pausing at page 30 cuz got alot to talk about,

first, raem is some sort of scum this game - fits mafia or serial killer. i'll evidence so with quotes below each point

1. raem initially voted tpein with practically no reason. basically a vote to get things rolling. raem at the time had no real town reads / discredit meta town reads, and had not engaged in any meaningful game solving interaction


2. raem pivots to pretty easy scum reads with no resistance to them - xadlin, hime, tpein. he votes tpein to move things forward but the moment tpein made 2 posts (without addressing raem AT ALL), raem simply moved to hime without commenting on tpein's posts AT ALL



3. raem's last scum read at the time was xadlin, who did not offer much in the thread readwise. however, notice how raem is accusing xadlin of something that he himself was doing?? flavor talk.
not only that, but xadlin had a scum read on hime. this is important because raem also scum reads hime. raem did not make any comment about this mutual scum read when addressing xadlin.


4. here xadlin votes hime but also says that he is willing to go back to suspecting raem. guess who died night 1? xadlin. why? because he suspected the right player. its raem or hime. one of them serial, another mafia. one of them killed him. neither of them cared to respond to this as far as im concerned up to page 30. why? because they have the ability to remove him at night.

a counter argument would be that hime will kill ultra instead, but this is too obvious. it brings attention to herself. killing xadlin is much more safer. the same can be said for raem, except nobody other than xadlin actually showed much suspicion on raem up to this point. imposter did a bit but it was a comment about stopping the flavor solving rather than suspicion. in fact imposter is now dead so it is entirely possible that raem took him out aswell after xadlin.


5. the last point i wanna make here (and this points more to raem maybe being mafia) is that raem tmi'd magic's general directions as "lynching townies" but has not once established why he reads any of the directions magic was pushing as town. magic was onto tpein and lethal at the time, both players raem was fine with lynching. in fact raem scum read and voted tpein himself, so where is this comment about magic leading town lynches coming from? this is very ingenuine. but not just town ingenuine, this is scum ingenuine.



first proper scum read this game - raem
Click to expand...
damn I actually really like this lol

@Ultra I believe you said RAEM was one of your top town reads? rebuttal?
 
T pein super focused on the miller recruit thing.
not only in rating posts about it but also talking about it.

Was he trying to get Craig lynched for some easy town cred. Did he know for sure he was recruited.
if so that Makes Ekko mafia?

possible.
that's a scary.
i havent seen him vote craig though just arguing that the recruit thing is very likely.

Ultra saw the same thing and was like just vote craig then. I'm still reading but he never votes Craig. despite hyper focusing on the recruit thing. If craig is on the scum team he can't exactly push his boy.

Magic gets really mad at Tpein for focusing on the recruit thing. Post #2204 Craig likes the post


Still working on a bigger post but shouldn't have everything crammed in it or it will be too big.

Did craig ever give his monster flavor? Because I can't think of anything in the lore for the base game MHW that fits the option of being recruitable.
 
If people aren't caught up can you disclose how much of tbe thread you're not caught up on. It's really hard to read people when they make nonsensical points that aren't based on what happened.

I.e. psychic saying I didn't vote poyser this phase and saying it's scummy to vote her and not him seemingly completely unaware that I did.
 
vote lynch raem

have more posts coming up

fos on - hime, poyser, dalton, raem, maybe alco

i think if raem is mafia, hime is serial potentially, otherwise she is town. i do not fully mafia read hime, not so far atleast
 
Ekkologix said:
vote lynch raem

have more posts coming up

fos on - hime, poyser, dalton, raem, maybe alco

i think if raem is mafia, hime is serial potentially, otherwise she is town. i do not fully mafia read hime, not so far atleast
Click to expand...
Pretty sure u recruited Craig from this. Your reads are terribad.
 
RÆM said:
T pein super focused on the miller recruit thing.
not only in rating posts about it but also talking about it.

Was he trying to get Craig lynched for some easy town cred. Did he know for sure he was recruited.
if so that Makes Ekko mafia?

possible.
that's a scary.
i havent seen him vote craig though just arguing that the recruit thing is very likely.

Ultra saw the same thing and was like just vote craig then. I'm still reading but he never votes Craig. despite hyper focusing on the recruit thing. If craig is on the scum team he can't exactly push his boy.

Magic gets really mad at Tpein for focusing on the recruit thing. Post #2204 Craig likes the post


Still working on a bigger post but shouldn't have everything crammed in it or it will be too big.

Did craig ever give his monster flavor? Because I can't think of anything in the lore for the base game MHW that fits the option of being recruitable.
Click to expand...
really dislike this
 
CraigPelton said:
really dislike this
Click to expand...
He could have scum hunted but the one topic he choose to discuss all of day 2 or the most of the day was the miller being recruitable. He even spent time looking up previous games where the mechanic occurred.
He liked me talking about it
Liked when Hime mentioned etc.
Anyone who mentioned the mechanic he encouraged it. He never voted you though despite all of that. Very curious.
 
RÆM said:
He could have scum hunted but the one topic he choose to discuss all of day 2 or the most of the day was the miller being recruitable. He even spent time looking up previous games where the mechanic occurred.
He liked me talking about it
Liked when Hime mentioned etc.
Anyone who mentioned the mechanic he encouraged it. He never voted you though despite all of that. Very curious.
Click to expand...
yeah it was easy content for scum idk how this reflects on me in any way but a positive one
 
I'm pretty sure I flamed Tpein hard day 1 of this game no? This was this game right?

I called him a sissy bitch no?

You think I would bm my teammate like that?
 
CraigPelton said:
yeah it was easy content for scum idk how this reflects on me in any way but a positive one
Click to expand...
Not on you per say.
I'm saying he was hyper fixated on it.
Magic dismiss the idea all together.

Mechanic talk scum love it.
But uh evans says he tracked u and Ekko acting sketchy this game with a new meta. 1+1
 
Magic said:
But why? She went from a strong impression to abandoning it to omgus her wagon
Click to expand...
she was sus on you before this phase so her voting you isn't that suspicious to me, and she had also already tried and failed to push ultra so it makes sense she wouldn't try again. I read all of her previous scum games and the difference is just really stark. I don't buy that poyser is coaching her. when we were scum together she barely paid attention to the QT and was extremely confused when we did our quicklynch win.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top