• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Monster Hunter World Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
maybe dalton is the only good read in there.

Poyser and Hime I town read.

So him reading them both scum is red flags.
 
I actually find it more likely hime is good guy'ing psychic than defending a teammate here

I wanna hear what ekko has to say tho, he said he has cases to make on her among others. I liked the RAEM case so I'm gonna let it ride
 
she was sus on you before this phase so her voting you isn't that suspicious to me, and she had also already tried and failed to push ultra so it makes sense she wouldn't try again. I read all of her previous scum games and the difference is just really stark. I don't buy that poyser is coaching her. when we were scum together she barely paid attention to the QT and was extremely confused when we did our quicklynch win.
She thought I was trying to divert the lynch onto Dalton. I was the only one she picked out for doing that among everyone else doing the exact same thing at that point.
 
She thought I was trying to divert the lynch onto Dalton. I was the only one she picked out for doing that among everyone else doing the exact same thing at that point.
yeah that's irrational not necessarily scummy especially for her
 
If people aren't caught up can you disclose how much of tbe thread you're not caught up on. It's really hard to read people when they make nonsensical points that aren't based on what happened.

I.e. psychic saying I didn't vote poyser this phase and saying it's scummy to vote her and not him seemingly completely unaware that I did.
Let's talk about your flip flopping from town reading me one second and voting me the next.
Pretty sure u recruited Craig from this. Your reads are terribad.
are u saying that he's a mafia recruiter?
 
No irrational is taking credit for the tpein lynch. That isn't irrational, it's singling me out for something she would have seen others doing
she mentioned you switching to lethal d1, I mean you have to admit that that makes you look bad

I can see why she'd single you out
 
Let's talk about your flip flopping from town reading me one second and voting me the next.

are u saying that he's a mafia recruiter?
Probably.
-terrible thread presence
-bad reads
-focused on me for some reason??? Well it's same with nat they play with me a lot and if i change up from a game they read that one way or another. Maybe I can't blame him for that so minor point.
-got tracked, We know it wasn't a kill. Doubt it was an investigation. If he was actually a doctor scum ignored ekko. Think about that.
 
Probably.
-terrible thread presence
-bad reads
-focused on me for some reason??? Well it's same with nat they play with me a lot and if i change up from a game they read that one way or another. Maybe I can't blame him for that so minor point.
-got tracked, We know it wasn't a kill. Doubt it was an investigation. If he was actually a doctor scum ignored ekko. Think about that.
The day I'm in support of Magic lynch he comes in and tries to make me a main wagon with his flimsy reasoning.
 
poyser is going to be harder to logically case, because he attacks safe shit or makes posts look scummy when they arent. it's gna come to how much i value my early town reads and stick to them.

first - he entered thread accusing flower, who i thought was pretty townie in the early game. poyser calls her reads shit but disregards that flower made these within the first 2-5 pages of the game. ofcourse they will be "shit" its mostly gut reads. matter of fact calling gut reads shit is bizarre and just discredits her town reads. gut reads r gut reads for a reason. discrediting town reads will always be bad, if the reasoning applied doesnt check out with the player making the reads

flower attached some early reasons to her reads that i do not consider tmi. poyser is not accusing flower of having shit reads as town, poyser is accusing her of having tmi? i do not follow fully tbh. i think flower was town and approached the game how she would as town

=======

second - poyser moved in right from flower to cause a conflict between ultra and tweet, 2 players who i thought seemed townie early on. poyser seems to take ultra's side and says tweet looks scummy yet still maintains a slight scum read of ultra. ultra called him out for this, to which poyser brought an interaction to basically say "oops maybe they arent aligned after this" and then throw ultra a soft town read. whole thing is performative if you ask me.

========

third - poyser mocks ultra on his 11/10 confidence hime scum read and pleads him to beg him for vote etc.. this entire interaction is more focused towards mockery by poyser's side than solving. i dont know how this helps him as either alignment, specially if throws ultra a town read. poyser basically tells ultra if you are so confident why not try to convince me on it, while ultra's response is "you just admitted to not wanting to vote on it because i started it"... then the fact that poyser town read ultra afterward shud atleast get him to read and consider the case on hime without all this added extra performative mockery.

matter of fact i dont think hime and poyser are alligned. i think poyser is trying to play hard to get here and make his vote seem hard to be sold, only to follow the wagon later if needed and mislynch hime (or she flips serial potentially), then blame ultra for it.


======

fourth - poyser in many instances throws me a town read for ??? reasons and takes my side on conflicts that i did not even partake in or was interested to. in fact i town read both ultra and tweet. poyser is trying to get me to engage against them? its not happening

======

fifth - poyser town read raem for literally ??? reasons. just said that since raem shares same read on flower, he is town... ? this is an arbitrary read asigned based on another read, who i disagree with in both levels (the scum read on flower, and the town read on raem).
 
she mentioned you switching to lethal d1, I mean you have to admit that that makes you look bad

I can see why she'd single you out
I can too but that had nothing to do with diverting the tpein lynch and it doesn't take much to see that.

Did she go from rational to irrational when you were scum with her or what was her play like
 
damn I actually really like this lol

@Ultra I believe you said RAEM was one of your top town reads? rebuttal?

Basically I don't think he has really any scum game to speak of, his wider play screams townie to me. Not good, but townie - and that it requires specific framing to see Ekko's point.

Compared to Psychic who has no wider play and seems omnidirectional, once you pointed out that she's TMI burdened and probably pivoting off T-Pein to push me I couldn't unsee it.
 
Basically I don't think he has really any scum game to speak of, his wider play screams townie to me. Not good, but townie - and that it requires specific framing to see Ekko's point.

Compared to Psychic who has no wider play and seems omnidirectional, once you pointed out that she's TMI burdened and probably pivoting off T-Pein to push me I couldn't unsee it.

*unidirectional
 
I can too but that had nothing to do with diverting the tpein lynch and it doesn't take much to see that.

Did she go from rational to irrational when you were scum with her or what was her play like
she pretty much just coasted, posting fluff or commenting on irrelevant stuff, throwing out a read here or there and then not doing anything with it. constant activity excuses. she is aimless as scum
 
The day I'm in support of Magic lynch he comes in and tries to make me a main wagon with his flimsy reasoning.
Where in the fuck did I make you into a wagon at any point?

What the fuck are you guys on. Can I get email addresses from your schools so I can send out some emails of concern for their teachings in literacy
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top