• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Monster Hunter World Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Magic said:
Where in the fuck did I make you into a wagon at any point?

What the fuck are you guys on. Can I get email addresses from your schools so I can send out some emails of concern for their teachings in literacy
Click to expand...
I quoted myself talking about ekko.

You need to chill man.
 
well more null/town but im leaning town. i'll have a more definitive read by end of the day

i think however she should not be the lynch today ever

best lynch options imo - hime, dalton, alco, poyser, raem

i can come around flower, nat, evans being town. i think in the list above there may be 1-2 townies at most. i am still reading approaching page 40

@Magic i dont really like ur directions this game (if its psychic now), i do think u r town from how u handled raem / how raem handled ur slot in my worldview, but if he is serial it reflects negatively on ur alignment in my view. your interactions with the tpein directions were meh at best

clearing townies is okay. if psychic is in ur PoE and u r town, i expect u to move once u r able to see her as such. please let me know what ur town reads are rn
 
Ekkologix said:
pausing at page 30 cuz got alot to talk about,

first, raem is some sort of scum this game - fits mafia or serial killer. i'll evidence so with quotes below each point

1. raem initially voted tpein with practically no reason. basically a vote to get things rolling. raem at the time had no real town reads / discredit meta town reads, and had not engaged in any meaningful game solving interaction


2. raem pivots to pretty easy scum reads with no resistance to them - xadlin, hime, tpein. he votes tpein to move things forward but the moment tpein made 2 posts (without addressing raem AT ALL), raem simply moved to hime without commenting on tpein's posts AT ALL



3. raem's last scum read at the time was xadlin, who did not offer much in the thread readwise. however, notice how raem is accusing xadlin of something that he himself was doing?? flavor talk.
not only that, but xadlin had a scum read on hime. this is important because raem also scum reads hime. raem did not make any comment about this mutual scum read when addressing xadlin.


4. here xadlin votes hime but also says that he is willing to go back to suspecting raem. guess who died night 1? xadlin. why? because he suspected the right player. its raem or hime. one of them serial, another mafia. one of them killed him. neither of them cared to respond to this as far as im concerned up to page 30. why? because they have the ability to remove him at night.

a counter argument would be that hime will kill ultra instead, but this is too obvious. it brings attention to herself. killing xadlin is much more safer. the same can be said for raem, except nobody other than xadlin actually showed much suspicion on raem up to this point. imposter did a bit but it was a comment about stopping the flavor solving rather than suspicion. in fact imposter is now dead so it is entirely possible that raem took him out aswell after xadlin.


5. the last point i wanna make here (and this points more to raem maybe being mafia) is that raem tmi'd magic's general directions as "lynching townies" but has not once established why he reads any of the directions magic was pushing as town. magic was onto tpein and lethal at the time, both players raem was fine with lynching. in fact raem scum read and voted tpein himself, so where is this comment about magic leading town lynches coming from? this is very ingenuine. but not just town ingenuine, this is scum ingenuine.



first proper scum read this game - raem
Click to expand...
going to say this is astronomically shit take on me and one that i do take offense to

In no world do I fear xadlin of all ppl, wtf
I can hold my own just fine vs ultra and u think I find the need to kill xadlin???
Y not someone else who sussed me that phase if ultra was too obvi
 
hime said:
going to say this is astronomically shit take on me and one that i do take offense to

In no world do I fear xadlin of all ppl, wtf
I can hold my own just fine vs ultra and u think I find the need to kill xadlin???
Y not someone else who sussed me that phase if ultra was too obvi
Click to expand...
hime this is only based up to page 30 where i read

xadlin and ultra where the major 2 on u

killing ultra is too obvious. a serial wud elect to kill a low profile target suspecting them. xadlin is a perfect kill for u to carry as serial

up to where i read, u did not reply to xadlin's posts. if u did and u convinced him of ur townies in a future post, i'll see it later and update my read

as of now i lean u either town or serial, but mostly not mafia, and definitly not aligned with poyser imo
 
Ekkologix said:
poyser is going to be harder to logically case, because he attacks safe shit or makes posts look scummy when they arent. it's gna come to how much i value my early town reads and stick to them.

first - he entered thread accusing flower, who i thought was pretty townie in the early game. poyser calls her reads shit but disregards that flower made these within the first 2-5 pages of the game. ofcourse they will be "shit" its mostly gut reads. matter of fact calling gut reads shit is bizarre and just discredits her town reads. gut reads r gut reads for a reason. discrediting town reads will always be bad, if the reasoning applied doesnt check out with the player making the reads

flower attached some early reasons to her reads that i do not consider tmi. poyser is not accusing flower of having shit reads as town, poyser is accusing her of having tmi? i do not follow fully tbh. i think flower was town and approached the game how she would as town

=======

second - poyser moved in right from flower to cause a conflict between ultra and tweet, 2 players who i thought seemed townie early on. poyser seems to take ultra's side and says tweet looks scummy yet still maintains a slight scum read of ultra. ultra called him out for this, to which poyser brought an interaction to basically say "oops maybe they arent aligned after this" and then throw ultra a soft town read. whole thing is performative if you ask me.

========

third - poyser mocks ultra on his 11/10 confidence hime scum read and pleads him to beg him for vote etc.. this entire interaction is more focused towards mockery by poyser's side than solving. i dont know how this helps him as either alignment, specially if throws ultra a town read. poyser basically tells ultra if you are so confident why not try to convince me on it, while ultra's response is "you just admitted to not wanting to vote on it because i started it"... then the fact that poyser town read ultra afterward shud atleast get him to read and consider the case on hime without all this added extra performative mockery.

matter of fact i dont think hime and poyser are alligned. i think poyser is trying to play hard to get here and make his vote seem hard to be sold, only to follow the wagon later if needed and mislynch hime (or she flips serial potentially), then blame ultra for it.


======

fourth - poyser in many instances throws me a town read for ??? reasons and takes my side on conflicts that i did not even partake in or was interested to. in fact i town read both ultra and tweet. poyser is trying to get me to engage against them? its not happening

======

fifth - poyser town read raem for literally ??? reasons. just said that since raem shares same read on flower, he is town... ? this is an arbitrary read asigned based on another read, who i disagree with in both levels (the scum read on flower, and the town read on raem).
Click to expand...

Poyser's approach to me definitely didn't sit right as it was happening.

Taking a step back though, I picked up a couple of aspects from his scum game when we last played and I think there's a bit of a departure there.

For example in Traitors he identified his targets very early on and didn't really deviate from them all that much. Compared to here where he caught up, opened with a case on me and tweet being scum/scum (Was pretty fucking terrible though) and then he walked back both reads basically on his own progression. Unless tweet's his team mate or something it's just easier to buy that as town, and that's without considering his interactions with T.

I'm not cementing this kind of read and frankly I'm not sure he'd agree himself he's so limited in range he can't fake progression but it stuck out to me

He's experienced and probably fluid enough where I wouldn't say
 
Ekkologix said:
well more null/town but im leaning town. i'll have a more definitive read by end of the day

i think however she should not be the lynch today ever

best lynch options imo - hime, dalton, alco, poyser, raem

i can come around flower, nat, evans being town. i think in the list above there may be 1-2 townies at most. i am still reading approaching page 40

@Magic i dont really like ur directions this game (if its psychic now), i do think u r town from how u handled raem / how raem handled ur slot in my worldview, but if he is serial it reflects negatively on ur alignment in my view. your interactions with the tpein directions were meh at best

clearing townies is okay. if psychic is in ur PoE and u r town, i expect u to move once u r able to see her as such. please let me know what ur town reads are rn
Click to expand...
Lynch me ***got. I'm tired of comprising with retards. You guys weren't lynching tpein last phase if I didn't repeatedly ask people to join the wagon. I don't care what anyone here has to say for it, the general wave of stupidity shows as much considering it took a bit of extra just to get him hammered yet I'm supposed to believe I couldn't have shifted the wagon elsewhere as scum. You and anyone else can go shove a dildo up your assholes
 
Ultra said:
Poyser's approach to me definitely didn't sit right as it was happening.

Taking a step back though, I picked up a couple of aspects from his scum game when we last played and I think there's a bit of a departure there.

For example in Traitors he identified his targets very early on and didn't really deviate from them all that much. Compared to here where he caught up, opened with a case on me and tweet being scum/scum (Was pretty fucking terrible though) and then he walked back both reads basically on his own progression. Unless tweet's his team mate or something it's just easier to buy that as town, and that's without considering his interactions with T.

I'm not cementing this kind of read and frankly I'm not sure he'd agree himself he's so limited in range he can't fake progression but it stuck out to me

He's experienced and probably fluid enough where I wouldn't say
Click to expand...
i'll give you one thing - i agree that his play does not seem to be pre-planned. it seems just right on the fly, or he expected some sort of reaction from tweet and did not receive it. eitherway he puts himself in a weird situation and gather sus on him for this play.

the issue is i town read most of the other slots so this will remain in PoE until i read a townie play from poyser.

before i continue reading, thoughts on alco and dalton? also what r ur town reads rn and how many mafia u expect in the game

do u read hime as mafia or serial?
 
Magic said:
Lynch me ***got. I'm tired of comprising with retards. You guys weren't lynching tpein last phase if I didn't repeatedly ask people to join the wagon. I don't care what anyone here has to say for it, the general wave of stupidity shows as much considering it took a bit of extra just to get him hammered yet I'm supposed to believe I couldn't have shifted the wagon elsewhere as scum. You and anyone else can go shove a dildo up your assholes
Click to expand...
u dont nearly have enough pull as u think u do

oi magic san

15865752661688045752274914033209.jpg
 
Ekkologix said:
u dont nearly have enough pull as u think u do

oi magic san

15865752661688045752274914033209.jpg
Click to expand...
There's been a grand total of one scum in the past two games after I've died and that one scum was my main scum read.

This has nothing to do with pull. You have pull and lead nothing but mislynches. Imagine the lack of respect your town game must have to mislynch repeatedly and not be called scum for it

You guys consider ultra a good player and for a large part of the game he's posted nothing but shit. If this is his town game it's pathetic.
 
RÆM said:
T pein super focused on the miller recruit thing.
not only in rating posts about it but also talking about it.

Was he trying to get Craig lynched for some easy town cred. Did he know for sure he was recruited.
if so that Makes Ekko mafia?

possible.
that's a scary.
i havent seen him vote craig though just arguing that the recruit thing is very likely.

Ultra saw the same thing and was like just vote craig then. I'm still reading but he never votes Craig. despite hyper focusing on the recruit thing. If craig is on the scum team he can't exactly push his boy.

Magic gets really mad at Tpein for focusing on the recruit thing. Post #2204 Craig likes the post


Still working on a bigger post but shouldn't have everything crammed in it or it will be too big.

Did craig ever give his monster flavor? Because I can't think of anything in the lore for the base game MHW that fits the option of being recruitable.
Click to expand...
Also raem is posting in a stream of consciousness cp.

Read his posts without reading the content. Its not dissimilar to what doc and Shepard game sounds like. He's spouting shit but the manners he doing it comes without any sort of agenda, it just seems like his honest thoughts.

He thought tpein and psychic were both being falsely suspected for something common in their play from his perspective
 
Magic said:
Lynch me ***got. I'm tired of comprising with retards. You guys weren't lynching tpein last phase if I didn't repeatedly ask people to join the wagon. I don't care what anyone here has to say for it, the general wave of stupidity shows as much considering it took a bit of extra just to get him hammered yet I'm supposed to believe I couldn't have shifted the wagon elsewhere as scum. You and anyone else can go shove a dildo up your assholes
Click to expand...
Also Magic

My man chill a bit
 
Ekkologix said:
i'll give you one thing - i agree that his play does not seem to be pre-planned. it seems just right on the fly, or he expected some sort of reaction from tweet and did not receive it. eitherway he puts himself in a weird situation and gather sus on him for this play.

the issue is i town read most of the other slots so this will remain in PoE until i read a townie play from poyser.

before i continue reading, thoughts on alco and dalton? also what r ur town reads rn and how many mafia u expect in the game

do u read hime as mafia or serial?
Click to expand...

Town on Alco scum on Dalton/Rugrat

You know lists aren't really my thing but I'll throw one together some point today.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top