Depends on exact set up but usually yeah
Tbh I dont see an indie in this setup but I may be wrong
Some of it is historical and based on past games.
OLF (Vanilla) Mafia
- Thread starter Dr. Watson
- Start date
-
- Tags
- olf mafia
- Status
there is one 100%
You the indie?
im bully mguire of mafia
a troll
but with loud mouth
anyway w.e as long as we get the job done
sigis its in the wiki lol
also a kill likely failed on me so thats 3 kills last night, one indie one maf one vig
Byakuya
Senbonzakura
This is my thought process as well.
My problem with you however is you say people are scummy but you don't provide any reasons why. You've stated multiple times that you are suspicious of Odd and Mystic. Why are they scummy? Do they have some connection to Yub and Daw? You need to explain your reasoning. You can't just accuse people of being scum and expect us to follow you blindly like sheep.
If you want to be the town leader so badly, then do your job properly.
Yeah not like Trin said this game was modified or somethin
odd knows why
mystic is uninvolved in a scummy way, yet aware of whats happening, or atleast displayed some sort of awareness when she voted LG out of nowhere and said LG's vote is good. she didnt comment on the other wagons. i dont think this makes her 100% scum obviously, but shes a good place to start from. we gotta develop reads slowly and work our way up. i didnt like ral either yesterday but it seems like he was going against wad's vote on yub really hard. it doesnt seem like they were on the same page perhaps? maybe mafia really did not have day talk i guess.
i think mafia was really comfy with the bus last day. reading the game state and thread action, it seems wad just placed his vote on yub while mystic does w.e. if both scum voted yub to bus him then the second mafia could be yoshi. he basically voted with literally no reason.
what do u think based on the wagons last day and the flips we have today are the scum?
this doctor version only stops kills if im not mistaken, so i was hit by a kill and it failedYeah not like Trin said this game was modified or somethin
and indie is confirmed in game
the setup we have is likely this one:
(9) Mafia JOAT, Mafia Rolecop, Mafia Goon, Town Doctor, Town Odd-Night Watcher, Town 1-Shot Vigilante, Town 1-Shot Cop, 6 Vanilla Townies (10:3)
except maybe what trin meant here:
this is the only setup where a vig and doctor exist together
basically we r missing the mafia scum cop and the serial killer
(9) Mafia JOAT, Mafia Rolecop, Mafia Goon, Town Doctor, Town Odd-Night Watcher, Town 1-Shot Vigilante, Town 1-Shot Cop, 6 Vanilla Townies (10:3)
except maybe what trin meant here:
a serial killer is added accidently and the JOAT is changed to godfather, so trin introduced a 14th player to take the 1x vig position.
this is the only setup where a vig and doctor exist together
basically we r missing the mafia scum cop and the serial killer
Where?
last day vote count:
Gogeta (sub-in for Yub) [5]
(Wad, Ruffles, Yoshi, Fang, Bya)
> if we are to believe mafia went all out on this bus, then both scum will be on this wagon, meaning one of yoshi/ruffles is mafia. i find this highly unlikely tbh. i don't think wad will tell his teammate to do that. if i have to take a guess, maybe yoshi is the mafia? the way he jumped in on yub was just outright scummy, but idk if it falls under the too scummy to be scum category or not.
> on the other hand i liked ruffles early interactions with wad. didnt seem like they are THAT much of teammates there. ruffled voted me first then later on decided to swap to yub without much substance added behind the vote. if i would have to guess, and i need to iso more here, both yoshi and ruffles are just town and mafia didnt go for the all out bus
Ekko [3]
(Nep, Phenom, Ral)
> i am town from my PoV. for the rest this should be uncolored. the way i see it this wagon randomly formed and grew until it reached 5 people on it iirc, with ruffles and hunter swapping to yub. this wagon here goes against the planned day 1 bus. the more i think about it the more it seems that mafia had no day 1 comms. ral's stubbornness in standing for yub is pretty scummy on its own, but he could of voted LG to save him last day, which he didnt. I don't think he was there by EoD tho but eitherway does not look like we was on board with the bussing plan at all. likely non mafia? i wouldnt bet on that though
nep and phenom clearly didnt want anything with the bus either. they seem to be doing their own thing. there is a low teammate equity with wad and i dont sense any ulter motives behind their votes.
Odd (sub-in for LG) [3]
(~Mystic Serenade~, Ekko, Gogeta)
> again this is from my PoV/reads, but this wagon here is a last ditch effort by gogeta/yub slot to survive and it obviously was not enough? at the very least he could be trying to make it seem like he wants to lynch odd but is fully aware thats not gna happen? could be a distance with odd, but i'd wanna avoid tinfoiling that rn. mysic on the other hand just casually ignored all the yub/ekko discussion, placed a vote on LG and dipped. like the play is ridiculously scummy on its own.
Gogeta (sub-in for Yub) [5]
(Wad, Ruffles, Yoshi, Fang, Bya)
> if we are to believe mafia went all out on this bus, then both scum will be on this wagon, meaning one of yoshi/ruffles is mafia. i find this highly unlikely tbh. i don't think wad will tell his teammate to do that. if i have to take a guess, maybe yoshi is the mafia? the way he jumped in on yub was just outright scummy, but idk if it falls under the too scummy to be scum category or not.
> on the other hand i liked ruffles early interactions with wad. didnt seem like they are THAT much of teammates there. ruffled voted me first then later on decided to swap to yub without much substance added behind the vote. if i would have to guess, and i need to iso more here, both yoshi and ruffles are just town and mafia didnt go for the all out bus
Ekko [3]
(Nep, Phenom, Ral)
> i am town from my PoV. for the rest this should be uncolored. the way i see it this wagon randomly formed and grew until it reached 5 people on it iirc, with ruffles and hunter swapping to yub. this wagon here goes against the planned day 1 bus. the more i think about it the more it seems that mafia had no day 1 comms. ral's stubbornness in standing for yub is pretty scummy on its own, but he could of voted LG to save him last day, which he didnt. I don't think he was there by EoD tho but eitherway does not look like we was on board with the bussing plan at all. likely non mafia? i wouldnt bet on that though
nep and phenom clearly didnt want anything with the bus either. they seem to be doing their own thing. there is a low teammate equity with wad and i dont sense any ulter motives behind their votes.
Odd (sub-in for LG) [3]
(~Mystic Serenade~, Ekko, Gogeta)
> again this is from my PoV/reads, but this wagon here is a last ditch effort by gogeta/yub slot to survive and it obviously was not enough? at the very least he could be trying to make it seem like he wants to lynch odd but is fully aware thats not gna happen? could be a distance with odd, but i'd wanna avoid tinfoiling that rn. mysic on the other hand just casually ignored all the yub/ekko discussion, placed a vote on LG and dipped. like the play is ridiculously scummy on its own.
the kill failing on me confirms it
What?
That just confirms there was a doctor, unless you are right now claiming ot be a bulletproof Indie, that doesn't track logically at all even with the Wiki setups as Doctor does that
~Mystic Serenade~
Active member
LG needed to die cause I know him from another forum, my only regret is that he subbed out instead of accepting death. 
- Status