Game Ranked You Will Eat The Bugs - A Mafia game brought to you by the World Economic Forum

[Aurelian]

tl;dw

Its cause your black

 

[Magic]

Tbh I saw that as something of a retraction, otherwise why even make the posts acknowledging that in the first place?

dont think i saw a retraction or much of one.

poyser isn't dumb as scum. he still needs to react to people reacting to him. not saying anything he did is out of place for him as town, i just dont think he deserves a top tier town read that melkor is trying to give him.

 

[Magic]

tl;dw

just because shit looks scummy on first glance doesn't mean any of those people are scum but when something feels out of place then it may just be scummy despite appearances!

 

[Grammaton]

dont think i saw a retraction or much of one.

poyser isn't dumb as scum. he still needs to react to people reacting to him. not saying anything he did is out of place for him as town, i just dont think he deserves a top tier town read that melkor is trying to give him.

Well that’s why it’s his read and not yours?

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

I got no opinion either way on gad tbh, hard for me to compare to last game given he got microscoped pretty early

Huh? You were the one leading the push on him last game and had a pretty good grasp of what his game amounted to that time. It should be really simple for you in particular to check out his play so far and compare that to what you noticed him do last game.

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

for starters, my read on him!

Well I for one think he's very similar to last game where you were just about the only one who correctly had him as town, so if you don't have him town this time, and push him over your other scum read which is Gram of all people, that doesn't sit right with me

 

[Grammaton]

Huh? You were the one leading the push on him last game and had a pretty good grasp of what his game amounted to that time. It should be really simple for you in particular to check out his play so far and compare that to what you noticed him do last game.

I think you need to think this through a bit more tbh

Like, he got mislynched last game, but the thing that drove said mislynch was that he didn’t react to pressure well

There’s nothing in his play so far that I have anything approaching an opinion on, do you?

Disappointingly redundant from you tbh

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

In a world he’s town, I’d be surprised if he thought I was scum tbh. He might think there’s not much evidence of me being town and I wouldn’t really argue that point, but sometimes life happens which he would know as much as anyone

Asking him then to ditch an actual stated scum read for that then becomes a reach. At least that’s how I see it, but he can answer for himself too (he already kinda has which is why I’m making this post in the first place, but that’s my interpretation )

Well given that the main issue he has with you is that you haven't done much except for following Poyser and Ratchet, he should definitely want to push you for more activity

 

[Magic]

Well that’s why it’s his read and not yours?

this is more to the point that such an easy town read for such simple things shouldnt be given to poyser.

Well I for one think he's very similar to last game where you were just about the only one who correctly had him as town, so if you don't have him town this time, and push him over your other scum read which is Gram of all people, that doesn't sit right with me

i was also the only one who had him correctly as town when he fucked up his claim in members. also had him as locked town in xmas!

so from your pov it's weird that the guy that keeps reading gad correct when everyone else seems to be wrong should be questioned because others have him as town this time around opposed to, idk, maybe thinking i could have a point?

 

[Grammaton]

Well given that the main issue he has with you is that you haven't done much except for following Poyser and Ratchet, he should definitely want to push you for more activity

I’m active now aren’t I?

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

You felt the same way from my first post last game. You probably just don’t like my play style idk.

We've been playing mafia for a few years now, if your general playstyle was my issue, we would have found out long ago

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

I am happy though that you agree with my point that Magic should want to push Gram over Gad, almost objectively

 

[Grammaton]

this is more to the point that such an easy town read for such simple things shouldnt be given to poyser.

I dont see the urgency to strike his read down here tbh - given you don’t really have any position on poyser afaict, unless you think he’s TMIing

 

[Aurelian]

Hmm, don’t like Nibels immediate reaction there

quite like tweets opening

Hmm, have to say not a fan of this, very much an appeasement post given you provide two practically unrelated answers and effectively ask Bachi to pick whichever he prefers. That’s the one of thing I’d do when I don’t care about the person asking, but it feels out of place from you

Vote Melkor

Fully agree, it’s day one

However the fact you seemingly weren’t willing to commit to what you were actually following betrays a lack of sincerity in what you wrote

I like that he stuck his head above the parapet early

Vote Melkor

Nothing I’m particularly married to just yet. I liked tweets entrance, but I also liked bachis response. There’s enough people vouching for Fuji that I’m probably ok accepting that at face value.

What’s your take on Nibel?

And my vote was on ekko, but yes, back on you now

Vote Lind

On reflection, agree with poysers take. I think ratchet made a point that I quite liked about him only giving scum reads (at that point in time) too

What are your thoughts on Magic, Gad, and Craig?

None, none and none

I seem extremely popular all of a sudden!

In all seriousness I haven’t really had the time or energy to play properly so understandable

I can’t really decide what I think on Melkor right now - initially I thought Nibel was acting in bad faith, but then I hated Melkors reply to Bachi about why he was reading him as he was

Poyser looked give or take how I’d expect town poyser to look, I also don’t feel he’s pushing a pre planned agenda given

Rugrat appears to just be trolling, wouldn’t really care if he’s lynched. Seems to be prioritising liking some of fangs more nonsensical posts over anything else. Also think the post about expecting magic and I to ‘joust’ is just plain wrong - if anything the last game would show how bad that can potentially be.

Still like tweet, probably the read I’m happiest with

Think the Bachi/Nibel/Lind axis is where I’d start, tier 4 maths but I feel there’s a high chance of scum in there, would probably say Nibel goes 1st

Finally a dishonourable mention for ratchet who gave me a town read I don’t really understand on reflection - that said he also voted Nibel straight up which aligns with my current worldview

If I haven’t covered it here, I probably don’t have an opinion on it

Hmm

 

[Grammaton]

Aurelian rapidly sliding down in my estimation - can anyone establish any point whatsoever to anything he’s doing with me right now?

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

I think you need to think this through a bit more tbh

Like, he got mislynched last game, but the thing that drove said mislynch was that he didn’t react to pressure well

There’s nothing in his play so far that I have anything approaching an opinion on, do you?

Disappointingly redundant from you tbh

Hmm yeah alright that is true, my bad

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

I’m active now aren’t I?

Yes but not because Magic pushed you there

 

[Aurelian]

Aurelian rapidly sliding down in my estimation - can anyone establish any point whatsoever to anything he’s doing with me right now?

Ohh? And why is that?

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

so from your pov it's weird that the guy that keeps reading gad correct when everyone else seems to be wrong should be questioned because others have him as town this time around opposed to, idk, maybe thinking i could have a point?

Fine, lemme give you the benefit of the doubt and see what you're cooking then

 

[Magic]

I am happy though that you agree with my point that Magic should want to push Gram over Gad, almost objectively

objectively i am voting the person i think is more likely to be scum. subjectively you guys think i should go for the better quality player and that should play a role in how im voting for whatever reason.

I dont see the urgency to strike his read down here tbh - given you don’t really have any position on poyser afaict, unless you think he’s TMIing

there is never urgency, but he had to defend his read and make a statement in regards to it and pull up quotes to support it which is better than just letting it slip in the abyss.